Musketeers of Pig Alley as a Historical Source on Gangsters Essay

Musketeers of Pig Alley as a Historical Source on Gangsters Essay

Length: 894 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Films have proven to have significant impact on the ways in which we perceive or make sense of the society in which we live in. In an increasingly post-literate society, where aliteracy is becoming commonplace, there is no doubt that film is considered to be a major medium in the ways in which people inform and educate themselves. The use of film as a tool to understand history is becoming a popular approach and is a much-debated topic among historians who question the legitimacy of using films as a historical source. This essay will argue that film can be used effectively as a historical source in relation to studying ideas about gangsters. This will be demonstrated through examining the representations of gangsters in films and will also attempt to address to what extent these portrayals of gangsters can be considered accurate or realistic. Finally, this paper will conclude with a discussion on the inherent challenges and opportunities, which prevail when using film as a historical tool.

Gangsters are integral parts of history and have emerged as iconic figures of the industrial twentieth century and represent a culture of mobility, urban space, access and individual life. The gangster is also regarded as an anti-social figure as he is the focus for liberation from hierarchy and the past that society and ideology wish to repress. Therefore we can see that the film gangster represents a seminal figure in the history of twentieth-century culture and forms the focus for a range of tensions that have dominated the discourses of industrialized society. Gangsters are prominent characters in popular culture such as the genre of film with movies that often feature the glorification of their criminal actions and lawlessness often in ...


... middle of paper ...


...ocess of examining films should also involve the process of the careful selection of evidence and weighing of value.

In conclusion, film can portray the general ideas and attitudes towards gangsters at the time and can act as a good representation. Film can serve as a good reflection of the period in which they were made. Hence, as historians, we need to extricate the historical value from films and distinguish these facts with other historical evidence. Good films such as D.W. Griffith’s Musketeers of Pig Alley can make valuable contributions to our historical understanding. However, merely watching a film is not enough and it is up to us to develop from these general ideas about gangsters and use other historical documents from the time in which these events occurred and use primary sources such as print media to construct an accurate understanding of gangsters.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Idea of Gangsters in America Essay

- Deep down inside everyone has the same desire – to do what one wants whenever he or she chooses to and to not have to worry about anyone or anything else. Along with this desire to be able to do what ever it is that one wishes to at any given time, a person wants to be successful at what they do. The type of success that a person wants may be measured in money, property, fame, or even the entourage that follows him or her. This kind of lifestyle is only truly lived by a certain kind of people – gangsters and mobsters....   [tags: Gangsters, USA,]

Better Essays
912 words (2.6 pages)

Free Essays on The Three Musketeers

- The Three Musketeers              In The Three Musketeers is a very good book.  It is about 4 heroes who save the day like in most heroic books.  They are successful in defeating the evil because of the heroic deeds of d’Artagnan.   D’Artagnan is introduced to the three musketeers by incidentally insulting all of them.  They each challenge him to a duel for what he has done to them, but while he is dueling with one of the musketeers, one of the cardinal’s guards threatens to arrest them because there is a law in which says there is no dueling.  D’Artagnan and the musketeers join forces and drive the guards away.  Then, d’Artagnan becomes friends with the musketeers.  There first m...   [tags: The Three Musketeers Essays]

Free Essays
916 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about The Epic Of Sundiata As A Historical Source

- The Epic of Sundiata, which relates not only information about the Empire of Mali in the 13th and 14th centuries but also details of the ancient Mande Culture, is a valuable document that describes a period of time about which very little is known. Despite this reality, historians continue to debate the epic 's suitability as a historical source. It is clear that such a discussion revolves around the underlying question of the reliability of oral tradition; arguably, to deny the epic solely on the grounds that it relies on oral tradition constitutes a veritable disregard for a form of history that, when employed correctly, may effectively reveal important cultural values and ethics....   [tags: Historiography, History, Folklore, Historian]

Better Essays
1127 words (3.2 pages)

Hadith Reports as a Historical Source Essay

- There are many controversies surrounding the first century of Islamic history. Historians often have trouble agreeing on whether or not it is reliable to use hadith literature as a source for the origins of Islam considering a large amount of hadiths surfaced well after the time of Muhammad. Many historians find issue with the isnad and matn of hadith. Historians argue that these can be easily forged given the nature of how hadith is transmitted by word of mouth. Another problem with using hadith as a historical source for the origins of Islam is that many hadith collections contain anachronisms, which, again raises questions about the reliability of such collections....   [tags: Origins of Islam, Controvery, History, Islam]

Better Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)

A Historical View of The Three Musketeers Essay

- In the novel The Three Musketeers by Alexandre Dumas, King Louis XIII and Cardinal Richelieu are in authority in France, each struggling to gain absolute power. As a result conflicts emerge that will lead to the progress of France. France was constantly in external conflicts with England and in internal conflicts with the Huguenots that provoked war against the Catholics and even the King, but never against the Cardinal (Dumas, 1). Queen Anne’s romance to the Duke of Buckingham, who at the time was an enemy of France, was not unknown to the Cardinal, like nothing else that escaped him from knowing it....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about The Three Musketeers by Alexandre Dumas

- The Three Musketeers is about 4 heroes who save the day. They are successful in defeating the evil because of the heroic deeds of d'Artagnan. D'Artagnan is introduced to the three musketeers by incidentally insulting all of them. They each challenge him to a duel for what he has done to them, but while he is dueling with one of the musketeers, one of the cardinal's guards threatens to arrest them because there is a law in which says there is no dueling. D'Artagnan and the musketeers join forces and drive the guards away....   [tags: Three Muskateers]

Free Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Primary Source Evaluation

- Title of Primary Source: ACCOUNT OF THE SLAVE TRADE ON THE COAST OF AFRICA by ALEXANDER FALCONBRIDGE The book was published in 1788 -- substantially after the events described took place. The time gap did not seriously affect the main content of the material because the events he describes were very serious and unforgettable ones. He wrote the material at the time he had already been a member of the Anti- Slavery Society leaving room for a little suspicion of his tendency to exaggerate some descriptions in his narrative....   [tags: Source Evaluation]

Better Essays
1014 words (2.9 pages)

Infamous Gangsters: Al Capone Essay

- He may not be the president of the United States, the CEO of a company, or even the governor of Illinois, but Al Capone was without a doubt the leader of the Chicago area. A man of loyalty, brutality, and business, he wasn’t someone to recon with. In the 1920’s and still today, Al Capone is one of the most well known gangsters in history. He is known for his evasive way from the law, Alcatraz, and his brute honesty. Baptized as Alphonsus, which is Latin for the Italian Alfonso and English equivalent to Alphonse, was born to Gabriel and Theresa (Alphonse Capone)....   [tags: St. Valentines Day Massacre]

Better Essays
1500 words (4.3 pages)

How Useful is Archaic Greek Poetry as a Historical Source Essay

- “The higher Greek poetry did not make up fictitious plots; its business was to express the heroic saga, the myths” - Gilbert Murray, 1909 Gilbert Murray, the preeminent Australian classicist, expresses a statement in his preface to Aristotle on the Art of Poetry that raises the highly contentious issue of how useful is archaic poetry as a historical source. If we accept the definition of a ‘source’ as anything that can provide us with information which can add to the sum of our knowledge of the past, and the definition of a ‘historical source’ as any such piece of information used by a historian to make a point....   [tags: odyssey, trojan war, poetry, gilbert murray]

Better Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Three Musketeers & Alexandre Dumas

- The Three Musketeers & Alexandre Dumas Alexandre Dumas’s novels and in particular The Three Musketeers are so great for his ability to mix fact with fiction. As a historical novel, The Three Musketeers bases its story around some major characters and events of 17th century, French history. Cardinal Richelieu, Anne of Austria, and other important characters really lived and acted the way they do in the novel. In fact, the historical basis of Dumas's story extends all the way to his initial idea for the novel, even to the Musketeers and d’Artagnan themselves.(history 1) The Three Musketeers is inspired by a 17th century work entitled Memoires de d'Artagnan by Gatien de Cortilz de Sandras, wh...   [tags: Essays Papers]

Better Essays
637 words (1.8 pages)