Motivations for Deliberation Essay

Motivations for Deliberation Essay

Length: 782 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In a deliberation, it is essential to be motivated by something to deliberate. There are certain characteristics that define deliberation as outlined in Gastil’s criteria, but an underlying question is why do people choose to take part on a deliberation? What makes us want to follow criteria stated by Gastil? In our recent class deliberations, it seems that in order to be motivated to deliberate a topic, we must have true personal stakes in the topic at hand. Being college students, we are living, breathing examples of this discussion. I feel as though if there had been a topic which none of us were interested in, the deliberation would have been a flop. Throughout the course of our deliberation around the National Issues Forum on Higher Education, the two most prominent problems I saw included our inability to, in the words of John Gastil, “make the best decision possible." In our deliberation on Higher Education, decisions towards deliberations were mainly chosen based on major. I feel like by having a topic which hits close to home, everyone felt passion and had a strong sense of what they wanted, as pointed out in their personal stakes. There is a reason Gastil’s analytic process starts with the step of “creating a solid information base.” Without it, deliberation loses the necessary concreteness. I believe that although a deliberation may consist of many positive characteristics on the surface, a true deliberation involves open, organized give and take with the discovery of a final common ground, rather than defense or contentment leading to unresolved conflict.
At the start of the deliberation, every person went around and stated their personal stake. Most went on to talk about their majors, minors, previous credits and so ...


... middle of paper ...


...ith valid consideration. Deliberation can only work when deliberators embrace views contrary to their own and learn how to work with people holding contrary views.
Deliberation must involve collaboration. Deliberation does not require compromising but allows open exchange and an accurate reflection of beliefs, because the outcome of deliberation is common ground, not artificial agreement. Our group did an effective job of keeping the deliberation going, although it was much harder to find a common ground. Some felt so strongly about the math/science majors being a main priority and others did not. Without the pressure to form an agreement however, the group did not pressure each other enough to find the common ground that exists between our differences. Part of our failure to discover common ground was due to our reluctance to identify a broad range of solutions.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay The Neglected Ethical And Spiritual Motivations

- My article that is titled: The Neglected Ethical and Spiritual Motivations in the Workplace overall is about the understanding of what motivates employees in the workplace and the importance of how it affects the level of work production. Motivation as defined by our book as the process of arousing and sustaining goal-directed behavior. Motivation alone plays a huge role in any workplace despite the industry. You as a manager always want your coworkers having positive vibes and coming to work with good attitudes, without this, they may as well not even walk in the door....   [tags: Motivation, Maslow's hierarchy of needs]

Better Essays
1108 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Free Will, Deliberation, And Determinism

- In Philosophy, one of the most controversial discussions is whether or not humans actually have free will to make the choices and do the actions that they desire to complete. In order to understand the argument, defining key terms like free will, deliberation, and determinism is vital. One Philosopher, Daniel Dennett, explores the topic and issues of free will and determinism in his 1984 book Elbow Room. I disagree with Dennett view and I believe that humans do not have free will. We are controlled by several things, like our evolutionary past and genetics, or environment, and they all play into determinism....   [tags: Free will, Determinism, Daniel Dennett]

Better Essays
1860 words (5.3 pages)

Media Deliberation And Public Opinion Essay

- Media Deliberation “Ok ladies now let’s get in formation” are the words we heard at this year’s 50th Super Bowl halftime show, sung by singer Beyoncé’. As she sang and danced the crowd went wild and cheered her on as usual. During and after her performance people took to social media discussing how great she looked, the costume she wore, how she almost tripped, and the alleged political stand she was taking. Since her performance there has been a wide spread of conversations on talk shows, news outlets, social media sites, and radio stations discussing what is said to have been a controversial performance....   [tags: Mass media, Concentration of media ownership]

Better Essays
1952 words (5.6 pages)

Different Types of Motivation Essay

- ... Sometimes too many rewards also affect student motivation. This will lead to decrease in intrinsic motivation. Why rewarding an already intrinsically rewarding behavior leads to decrease motivation. One of the main reasons is that student tend to examine their own motivations for engaging in something such as activity. Once they got reward by doing something, they focus on importance to the role of the strengthening in their conduct. Other reason is activities that firstly feel like play or fun can be changed into work or obligations at the point when fixed to an external prize....   [tags: intrinsic and extrinsic motivations]

Better Essays
1181 words (3.4 pages)

Deliberation and Legalization of Marijuana Essay

- Deliberation on the legalization and regulation of marijuana is divisive where one side argues for its economic contribution through taxes while the other argues against it because of the health concerns associated with prolonged marijuana use. On one hand, there are social and health issues that arise at the expense of marijuana legalization, which is bound to encourage prolonged use among youth who are then vulnerable to addiction and mental health problems. On the other hand, the economic and tax benefits that comes from legalizing marijuana are undoubtedly important because the money from the taxes can help regulate the consumption and prevent youth be affected by this drug as it’s has b...   [tags: British Columbia, drugs, health, economy]

Better Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Motivations of Superheroes

- Peter Parker said, “Whatever life holds in store for me, I will never forget these words: ‘With great power comes great responsibility.’ This is my gift, my curse. Who am I. I’m Spiderman.” Without a doubt, being a superhero would be fun in the beginning, but being a superhero in general would ultimately lead to a miserable life. A superhero would always have great responsibility, would have fear of putting their loved ones in danger, and would have trouble trying to live two different lives if they chose to keep their identity anonymous....   [tags: heroes,]

Better Essays
510 words (1.5 pages)

The Attribution Theory Is Essential For Coaching And Understanding Our Athletes And Their Motivations

- The attribution theory is essential to coaching and understanding our athletes and their motivations. Throughout sports and competitive activities, individuals are determining whether the activity they are doing is a success or a failure. But the real question that needs to be asked is why are they attributing something as a success or a failure. What is guiding them to view something that can be as simple as getting out of bed in the morning as a success or failure. This paper will dive into why the attribution theory is so critical to coaching and how you can use it to guide yourself, your players, and your teams to become as successful as possible....   [tags: Game, Play, Motivation, Want]

Better Essays
1482 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Motivations Of Terrorists

- Discussing terrorism and motivations leading to terrorism brings up thoughts of random acts of violence. These acts are mostly considered to be methods of insane men. Most of these modern terrorists follow their own political agenda with each group trying to achieve a particular goal. There are three types of terrorists in today’s society: the single individual, a certain group, and government funded organization. These terrorists all resemble criminals with one major difference; they are dedicated to a higher cause and are not taking extreme measures for personal gain (Deleon)....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Better Essays
716 words (2 pages)

Iagos Motivations Essay

- Every good play has a great villain. Othello by William Shakespeare is no exception. In writing Othello, Shakespeare took characters he had gotten from an Italian short story, and developed them further. I would not say Shakespeare created Iago, but he definitely made Iago the evil man that everyone knows him to be. Iago may be one of the greatest villains of all time. He was honest, loyal, and brave in all of the other characters’ eyes. However, in reality he was a cruel, deceitful, immoral man....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
840 words (2.4 pages)

Motivation Essay

- What is Motivation. Motivation is the force that makes us do things: this is a result of our individual needs being satisfied (or met) so that we have inspiration to complete the task. These needs vary from person to person as everybody has their individual needs to motivate themselves. Depending on how motivated we are, it may further determine the effort we put into our work and therefore increase the standard of the output. When we suggest factors (or needs) that determine the motivation of employees in the workplace, almost everyone would immediately think of a high salary....   [tags: Motivation Leadership Management]

Better Essays
1303 words (3.7 pages)