In “Crito” and “Antigone,” Plato and Sophocles both talk about disobeying the law. Plato claims that it is wrong to disobey the law when the individual will gain something from his disobedience. On the other hand, Sophocles argues that it is wrong to disobey laws that do not follow the laws of God. While I agree with Plato and Sophocles in regards to their concepts of the law, I claim that Socrates and Plato would both agree that it is not right to follow an immoral law; it is better to break an immoral law than to follow it.
If a law goes against an individual 's morals, one should break it. When Antigone talks with Kreon, she knows that burying her brother is ethically wrong, but it was morally right because she thought her brother deserved a proper burial. “And yet, as men’s hearts know, I have done no wrong, I have not sinned before God. Or if I have, I shall know the truth in death. But if the guilt lies upon Kreon who judged me, then, I pray, may his punishment equal my own” (308 66-69). Here, Antigone says that she did nothing wrong, and everyone knows that her actions are just because she did what God wanted. She will only know if what she did was wrong after she dies, but she wants Kreon to have an equal punishment because he wrongfully punished her. From this, I say that family must stick up for one another regardless of the consequences because family is meant to support each other through the highs and lows of life. Also, following god’s laws are more important than following the laws of the State. For example, jaywalking is against the law; however, a lot of people often do it. If my brother was jaywalking, and I saw a car coming for him, I would run out and push him out of the way. Even tho...
... middle of paper ...
...nce. I say that people need to follow the beliefs and instincts that they have.
During the 1940’s when Hitler led the totalitarian government in Germany, the Jewish people were required to leave their homes to go to concentration camps. It was against the law for the Germans to hide Jews; however, some Germans decided to hide them anyway because they thought it was immoral to poorly treat the Jewish people just because of their faith. In Anne Frank’s case, once her family and the Germans hiding them got caught, they were all arrested because they broke the law. These Germans, like many others, felt a need to help out the Frank family against the law because they thought the law was immoral, and they were fully aware of the consequences. Like Antigone and Socrates, they were punished for following their moral beliefs and they stood up for what they thought was right.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Many arguments have been made over whether or not religion and morality are interconnected. It is quite difficult to find a well rounded definition of religion or morality due to everyone having different perceptions of both of the words. The word religion comes from the Latin words Religio or Religare both have similar meanings, a bond/bind (Diener, 1997). Merriam-Webster dictionary defines religion as "a cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith (Religion).” Morality comes from the Latin word mores meaning character or manner (Diener, 1997).... [tags: Religion, Morality, Human, Ethics]
1374 words (3.9 pages)
- In today’s society it’s very common to hear people debate about whether someone’s action was “moral” or not. The concept of morality is discussed like there’s a set definition of it, when the reality is far from it. There are so many definitions for morality that it makes the word itself unclear. To have a better understanding of morality it 's best to look at the word’s root word: moral. Having morals is defined as having good character and how that person interacts with others. Having morals is to have morality.... [tags: Morality, Ethics, Religion, Human]
864 words (2.5 pages)
- Many people believe laws are in place to protect them from danger and each other. Thus inferring they take some sort of control over people's actions. Laws are in place by our government (authority) to control a group of people living in a area together (community) (merriam-webster). These laws should not be broken or a penalty fitting the crime will be given, and those responsible will be sentenced to pay. Although not all laws that are broken are meant to be an act of defilement some are broken to show one's stand on a issue or as solidarity to others.... [tags: laws, justice, ]
1186 words (3.4 pages)
- Question: Is there a role for morality in the law. If so, what is this role. In society a code of morality could be seen as a set of beliefs, values and principles. The root of morality is bad and good behaviour. Moral views differ between individuals also within society. A dictionary definition of morality is ‘a set of personal or social standards for good or bad behaviour and character.’ Furthermore, law could be seen as a set of rules assigned by the government to keep society in order by following these rules.... [tags: Morality, Law, Human rights, Moral]
1660 words (4.7 pages)
- Machiavelli believed that, ethics and morality were considered in other categories than those generally known. He does not deny the existence of, but did not see how they can be useful in its traditional sense as in politics and in the government of the people. According to Machiavelli, a man is by nature a political angry and fearful. Machiavelli had no high opinion of the people. It is assumed that a person is forced to be good and can get into the number of positive features, such as prudence and courage.... [tags: Political philosophy, Morality, Ethics, Government]
1447 words (4.1 pages)
- Being Morally Justified in Disobeying Laws We Consider to be Immoral The answer to this question depends very much on our understanding and opinion on the status of the law. On this issue it is likely that everyone falls into one of two broad categories. People falling into the first of these categories would be those who consider that through social contract we are obliged to obey the law, whatever the law states and regardless of our opinion on the moral status of that law and that we are morally obliged to operate within the law.... [tags: Papers]
629 words (1.8 pages)
- 1. Introduction The relationship between morality and law has always been a subject of contention in jurisprudence. Consequently, many legal theories have attempted to define the appropriate limit and scope of morality’s influence on the law. Legal moralism, as proposed by Patrick Devlin, is the belief that society has “the right to pass judgement at all on matters of morals” (375), as well as “the right to use the weapon of the law to enforce it” (376). In this essay, I argue that Devlin’s legal moralism is unacceptable on the basis of committing cultural relativism, and that its application is problematic due to its inconsistent, arbitrary and biased nature.... [tags: Morality, Ethics, Religion, Moral]
1272 words (3.6 pages)
- Judgments of the heart between good and evil, right and wrong that is moralities purest form. Morality is a misleading mistress because, whatever is decided as moral and immoral can be just as easily justified as the opposite in a new era. Many with a rationalist view will describe morality as a virtue which allows for laws and justice to take place. An immoral action is an action taken through the perpetrator believing they will receive no punishment. A question is then presented why are there such distinct classifications of morality and immorality.... [tags: good and evil, philosophy, plato]
1357 words (3.9 pages)
- Moral or Immoral In Martin Luther King Jr.’s essay, A Letter from Birmingham Jail he compares the issues of Moral acts verses Immoral acts. This essay was written in response to a letter some clergymen had written after a direct action march Dr. King had participated in. In their letter the clergymen had praised the local police officers and media for the nonviolent and calm manner in which the situation was handled. It was this praise that prompted Dr King to write: “I have tried to make clear that it is wrong to use immoral means to attain moral ends.... [tags: Martin Luther King Essays]
659 words (1.9 pages)
- Morality Moral philosophy is very important to the success of an individual. But, before I tell you why moral philosophy is so important, and how it has helped me in my life, let me give you a little background knowledge. Rational knowledge has two components. These components are material and formal. Formal knowledge is not object oriented, and is based on reason. Formal knowledge is logic, or the laws of thought. Material knowledge is object oriented, and has two components. These two components are natural and moral.... [tags: Moral Ethics Philosophy essays]
1214 words (3.5 pages)