Missouri's Nonpartisan Selection of Judges Court Plan Essay

Missouri's Nonpartisan Selection of Judges Court Plan Essay

Length: 1409 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

During the 1930’s, the community became more and more displeased with the growing role of politics in judicial selection and judicial decision-making. Judges were inundated by outside pressures due to the political features of the election process, and dockets were overcrowded due to time the judges spent campaigning. In November 1940, voters amended the Missouri constitution by adopting the Nonpartisan Selection of Judges Court Plan. This plan was placed on the ballot by initiative petition. The acceptance of the plan by initiative referendum resulted from a public repercussion against the widespread abuses of the judicial system by the political machine in Kansas City and by the political control exhibited by ward bosses in St. Louis (Missouri Nonpartisan Court Plan, n.d.).
The Missouri Plan is a judicial selection process utilized by certain States in the US. The Plan unites an appointment procedure with the popular vote. Under the Plan, a selection committee offers the Governor of the state with the names of three candidates for office. If the Governor selects one of the candidates within sixty days, that person is appointed to the bench one year; if not, the committee makes the selection and appointment. After a year, the justice runs unopposed on the next general election ballot. If the voters support their retention, then the justice serves the number of years specified for the position in that state's constitution. If the voters contest retention, the selection process starts over. In the beginning “twelve states used the Missouri Plan to fill appeals-level judicial vacancies: Alaska, Arkansas, Colorado, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming. Tennessee, Florida and California ...

... middle of paper ...

...hat would work any better. Those who are in favor of merit selection offer it as a preferable option to the politics and fundraising intrinsic in judicial elections, while those against it uphold that the appointive process itself is political, and that, in addition, people have a right to elect their judges.
It seems that no matter what plan is used to select judges there is so element of politics and partisan that creep into the process. The question comes down to how much politics and partisan is wanted. It looks as if the more politics and partisan there is the worse the outcomes appear to be. The Missouri Plan appears to limit the politics that are involved and thus is the best plan that there is to select judges to the bench. This plan should be more widely adopted in order to limit the prejudices that are obviously everywhere in the system today.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

California State Legislature Essay

- 1. LA Department of Water and Power The Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (DWP) is the largest municipal utility in the United States. It is serving over four million residents. It was founded in 1902 to supply water and electricity to residents and businesses in Los Angeles and surrounding communities. 2. Missouri Plan The Missouri Nonpartisan Court Plan or Missouri Plan for short is a method of selecting judges. It originated in Missouri in 1940 and several other states have adopted the same policy....   [tags: Missouri Plan, California, Prop 140, ]

Powerful Essays
1324 words (3.8 pages)

The Missouri Plan Of Judicial Selection And Evaluation Essay

- The Missouri Plan of judicial selection and evaluation has been heralded as a model for the nation. Missouri employs both a non-partisan and partisan judicial selection process; for the purposes of this paper we will address the non-partisan selection process and the non-partisan evaluation process. The non-partisan judicial selection and evaluation processes in Missouri include the citizenry in their work. However, the limited scope of the plan presents its biggest weakness. The Missouri Bar association plays a significant role in the selection and evaluation of judicial appointees under the non-partisan system....   [tags: Judge, Law, Court, Retention election]

Powerful Essays
1083 words (3.1 pages)

The Criminal Proceedings Of State Of Missouri V. Essay examples

- The criminal proceedings of State of Missouri v. Rucker was held on 2-9-16 at the Cape Girardeau County Courthouse, 100 Court Street, Jackson, MO 63755 (573) 243-1755. This trial was for possession of a controlled substance. Criminal court proceeding have a specific order which they follow and I was fortunate to witness the defenses witness testifying, and the final stages of the trial. Watching the jury, the audience and noticing all the key personnel who were in the courtroom was as interesting as the sequence of events....   [tags: Jury, Prosecutor, Lawyer, Court]

Powerful Essays
1795 words (5.1 pages)

Analysis Of Reyes V. Missouri Pac. R. Co. Essay

- Lord In Reyes v. Missouri Pac. R. CO., the appellant, Joel Reyes, sought rehabilitation from the defendant, Missouri Pacific Railroad Company, after being run over by one of the defendants trains while lying on the tracks. The appellant claims the defendant was negligent due to its inability to see the plaintiff in time to stop the train. The defendant refutes the plaintiffs claim by blaming the plaintiff for contributory negligence because the plaintiff was believed to be drunk on the night in question based off of pass arrest records ....   [tags: Law, Court, Appeal, Evidence law]

Powerful Essays
818 words (2.3 pages)

Sexual Selection and Natural Selection Essay

- Selection is the functional relationship between phenotypes and fitness. Natural selection is the production of organisms according to their physical attributes whereby off springs of the younger generations takes the strong, desired and inheritable aspects of their parents. They become more adapted to the environment although some does well than others according to their individual traits which are attributed to their phenotypes (Sinervo, 1997). According to Charles Darwin, fitness can be described in three different forms of selection which interferes with the mean of phenotypic traits in a population....   [tags: Natural Selection, Evolution Essays]

Powerful Essays
538 words (1.5 pages)

Essay Artificial Selection And Natural Selection

- Evolution is the heart of life. Without it, life could not be sustainable. When the environment changes and the species within the environment fails to adapt or change, then all living organisms would perish over time. Charles Darwin, a biologist and naturalist, is known worldwide for his contributions to science for the extensive research and experiments conducted to help support the theory of evolution and how it worked. One basic mechanism that can be used to understand evolution is natural selection....   [tags: Natural selection, Evolution, Biology]

Powerful Essays
716 words (2 pages)


- REPORT ON MISSOURI GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS Missouri has had four constitutions: 1820, prior to statehood; 1865 and 1875, in the aftermath of the Civil War; and 1945. Amendments to the constitution may be proposed by a majority of the legislature or by petition signed by 8% of the voters in two-thirds of the state's congressional districts. Proposed amendments must be approved by a majority of the voters in a statewide election. A constitutional convention must be called every 20 years to review the constitution for possible changes....   [tags: essays papers]

Free Essays
1661 words (4.7 pages)

The Spanish Influenza in Missouri Essay

- The Spanish Influenza in Missouri Reports of the Spanish Influenza continue to bombard us from St. Louis, Missouri, as inhabitants of that fine city take many precautions to safeguard themselves and their families against this incendiary malady currently sweeping our great nation. At a time of war when our country needs our strength the most it is important that we fight this Influenza head on, taking whatever actions necessary to eradicate it from our fine shores. Let us take a page from St. Louis's book on how to prevent this illness from spreading....   [tags: Journalism St. Louis, Missouri Health Essays]

Free Essays
797 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about Jury Selection Research

- Famous writer Robert Frost stated, “A jury consists of twelve persons chosen to decide who has the better lawyer.” While selecting a competent lawyer is important, in the court of law, the process of jury selection is easily one of the most important factors. While many elements are considered during the process of jury selection, the most valuable is the use of psychology. Psychology is used by lawyers during the process of jury selection to choose the best possible jurors to decide the fate of their client....   [tags: Jury, Voir dire, Jury selection, Prosecutor, Judge]

Powerful Essays
2734 words (7.8 pages)

The Supreme Court Essay

- The Supreme Court At the apex of our federal court system stands the United States Supreme Court. It stands as the ultimate authority in constitutional interpretation and its decision can be changed only by a constitutional amendment. Two documents are responsible for its creation which is the Constitution, which explicitly creates the Supreme Court, and the Judiciary Act of September 24, 1789. The Supreme Court is the only court named in the constitution laying out the Courts basic jurisdiction, identifying the mode of selection and tenure for justices....   [tags: Supreme Court Governmental Congress Essays]

Powerful Essays
3505 words (10 pages)