Miranda vs. Arizona and the Fifth and Sixth Amendments Essay

Miranda vs. Arizona and the Fifth and Sixth Amendments Essay

Length: 838 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Fifth and Sixth Amendments like every other law out there is used in ways other than what it was initially for, by being interpreted by stretch provisions according to what feels right. What was it meant for? The brutality to suspects who we're being accused of their so called "wrong doing" dictated what would eventually change the way we work suspects. The police force had not been given what proper provisions to follow when interrogating suspects of criminal charges giving them disadvantages on many occasions though out the course of law. Many suspects essentially didn't know there rights along with police officers which in turn would cause a huge confusion. What are the rights that are supposed to be given to a suspect if they had any? The Fifth Amendment by then had never been truly understood to its full extent which would then be an excuse to brutally interrogate criminals as hostile and inhuman components to get confessions out that may not always seem to be true. Would major trails concerning the peoples Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights lead to a change in the way law enforcement works with suspects?
The Escobedo V. Illinois case had captured the grand stage in 1966 for, a man named Danny Escobedo was denied his rights to obtain a lawyer during questioning by the Chicago Police Department. Escobedo was convicted for shooting and was taken to the police department for questioning. Escobedo had made numerous attempts trying to request a lawyer, but was not provided one violating his Sixth Amendment Rights: “The right of a criminal defendant to have a lawyer assist in their defense.” Unfortunately, Escobedo had confessed to the murdering which also violated the Fifth Amendment of “self-incrimination” being forced a confes...


... middle of paper ...


...nforcement. Officers had an upper hand when suspects did not know their rights making it easier for them to sneak tactics through to get confessions. Another reason they it as a disadvantage was because according to the dissent “some cases cannot be solved without confessions”. Also they implied the “welfare” of our society was at stake because it would let criminals run free, if the Miranda rights weren’t stated to them correctly. This was a “hazardous” experiment which could have a dismal outcome and prove to be very ineffective in the future. Furthermore, the dissenting opinion on the way the police officers had treated suspects amendment rights were “exaggerated” and that the outcome was only to favor the accused more favorably.
Our Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights have changed since the Miranda v. Arizona case got brought to the attention of the Supreme Court.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Miranda Case Of Miranda V. Arizona Essay

- MIRANDA WARNING 2 The Duhaime’s Law Dictionary defines Miranda Warning as: “A requirement that police officers, in the U.S.A., before any questioning is so begun, warn suspects upon arrest that they have the right to remain silent, that any statement that they make could be used against them in a court of law, that they have the right to contact a lawyer and that if they cannot afford a lawyer, that one will be provided”. If an officer fails to read the Miranda warning prior to questioning, any confession or information that is obtained will not be admissible in court....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
1063 words (3 pages)

The Case Of Miranda V. Arizona Essay

- In the case of Miranda v. Arizona, the U.S. Courts describes the events as: “Ernesto Miranda, a native of Mexico, living in Phoenix, Arizona, was selected in a police grouping by a woman who implicated him of kidnapping and raping her.” In more detail, Robert Kenneth describes the events as: “Barbara Johnson, an 18 year old, was kidnapped and raped. Johnson was shoved into a man 's car, where he tied her hands and ankles and drove her to the edge of the city, where he raped her. The man drove Johnson near her home, asked her to pray for him and he let her out of the car....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
1104 words (3.2 pages)

The Miranda V. Arizona Case Essays

- The Miranda v. Arizona case not just for the case itself, but also for the significance of the case it had after the case. The Miranda is a nationwide that has changed law enforcement and has changed the rights of an individual. The Miranda rights law took affect after a man named Ernesto Miranda was under arrest by police officers. As police arrested Ernesto Miranda they didn’t read him his rights. Ernest Miranda lived in Phoenix, Arizona where he was charged with rape, kidnapping and robbery. Ernesto Miranda was a criminal, however he was not informed of his legal rights before the arrest....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
1709 words (4.9 pages)

Miranda Vs. Arizona Case Essay

- The landmark case, Miranda vs. Arizona is one of the most important legal cases in the United States. The decision of the case led to the creation of the Miranda Rights, which is still practiced to this day. Miranda Rights- “You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say or do can and will be held against you in a court of law. You have the right to speak to an attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you. Do you understand these rights as they have been read to you?” (Decision Date: June.13.1966)....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
735 words (2.1 pages)

Miranda Vs. Arizona Mexico Essay

- Miranda vs. Arizona Ernesto Miranda was born March 19, 1941 and died January 31st, 1976. He committed his first serious crime in eighth grade, and was convicted of felony burglary. He was sentenced to one year in reform school, in his case, Arizona State Industrial School for Boys. After being released from a separate sentence from the reform school, Miranda moved to Los Angeles. While in L.A. Ernesto was arrested for lack of supervision, violating curfew and being a “peeping tom”. He was in custody for forty-five days in the county detention home....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
813 words (2.3 pages)

Essay Miranda V. Arizona Case

- Miranda v. Arizona is a case that revolutionized the rights of an accused while in custody and interrogation. The Supreme court leaders based the rights of Mr. Miranda by the fifth amendment of the United States Constitution. The fifth amendment has been interpreted though the decision of supreme court rulings into the right to remain silent in an interrogation in order to prevent the accused to testify against himself. This amendment also protects any person from double jeopardy from the same crime, gives him or her a grand jury, and it requires for due process of law to come in effect in case a citizen is denied him or her from their right of life, liberty, or property....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
1071 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Miranda V. Arizona Supreme Court

- Miranda V Arizona was a supreme court case that was argued in the year 1966. Ernesto Miranda was charged with kidnapping and rape. When Miranda was arrested and questioned officers were able to get a confession from him. The question that was brought up to the supreme court was the fifth and sixth amendment. Miranda went on to win the case by majority opinion of 5-4. And this case formed the Miranda rights. Miranda and his lawyers argued that his fifth and sixth amendment was violated. Within the fifth and sixth amendment they argued that Miranda testified against himself and also that he asked for a lawyer....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
768 words (2.2 pages)

Ernesto Miranda From Phoenix, Arizona Essay

- Ernesto Miranda from Phoenix, Arizona was a poor man. He was arrested due to circumstantial evidence from a woman that recognized him in a police lineup for violently assaulting her. A few short days later, Ernesto Miranda was charged with the rape and kidnapping of the woman. Once in police custody, he was interrogated for about an estimated time of two hours with no attorney present. The police officers that questioned him did not inform him of his Fifth Amendment rights in contrast to self incrimination and the Sixth Amendment right to have an attorney present in the mist of being questioned....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Miranda Vs. Arizona Law Enforcement Essay

- Ever wonder how some laws come to be. Some laws are created from cases that have been to the U.S. Supreme Court and it was discovered that there was mistakes made on behalf of law enforcement. Take the case, Miranda v. Arizona, this is where the Miranda Warning came from. We are going to look at the chain of events that happened to Mr. Ernesto Miranda, what the outcome of the case was, and what exactly are the Miranda Warnings. Ernesto Miranda, since early childhood, after the death of his mother, and his father remarried, he began to get into trouble with the law....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
701 words (2 pages)

Outline Of Ernesto Miranda 's Speech

- Ernesto Miranda Ernesto Arturo Miranda was born in Mesa, Arizona on March 9, 1941. During his grade school years, Miranda began getting in trouble. His first criminal conviction was during his eighth grade year. The following year, now a 9th grade dropout, he was convicted of burglary. His sentence was a year in the reform school, Arizona State Industrial School for Boys (ASISB). After his release from the reform school, he got into trouble again with the law and was returned to ASISB. Once released for the second time, Miranda relocated to Los Angeles where a few months later he was arrested on suspicion of armed robbery and sexual offenses even though he was not convicted of these crimes....   [tags: Miranda v. Arizona]

Better Essays
1148 words (3.3 pages)