Milton 's Paradise Lost, The Predicament Of Adam And Eve Essay

Milton 's Paradise Lost, The Predicament Of Adam And Eve Essay

Length: 1652 words (4.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Milton’s God’s design flaw in creating inequality and division between Adam and Eve set the stage for the Fall of Mankind to occur. Arguably, perhaps Satan was not even needed as mankind was intended to fall from the beginning. In John Milton’s Paradise Lost, the predicament of Adam and Eve was a Catch-22 from the get-go, as sin was present in the Garden before Adam and Eve even eat from the Tree; even before Satan planted his dream inside of Eve’s mind. In this paper, I will attempt to refute the gender argument that Adam was at greater fault for the events that transpired by reasoning that the Paradise that was lost was never there in the first place, by showing that Sin had already existed in Adam and Eve since both of their creations.
To begin explaining why this theory is not the truth of the text, let us begin with said theory. Gender Studies and Feminist critics have rhetorically argued for the culpability of the disobedience to God belonging more so to Adam than Eve. Scholar Rachel Russo argues that because Adam and Eve are clearly not created as equals, and Adam distinctly treats Eve as his inferior prior to their transgression [...] it is apparent that Adam’s suppression of Eve clearly affected her decision to violate the Prohibition, thus causing the Fall of Man.” (Russo 1). In her analysis, Russo shifts all of the burden to Adam, accusing him of “constant depreciation of Eve’s meritorious qualities.” Russo claims that, “the hierarchy in which [Eve] is placed does not allow her to form the connection that the reflection she sees in the water is herself,” disputing the meaning of Eve’s “vain desire” in Book 4 and re-directing it as “simply intellectually curious about her own existence and sense of self, a...

... middle of paper ...

...tempted, self-deprav 'd: Man falls deceiv’d” (Milton 3.130).
God allows for the opportunity to either stand or fall; in essence free will, despite his acknowledgement of Fate, and foresight. This acknowledgement of Fate, thus confirms that God already knew Satan was inside the Garden; that Sin had already gotten through; and that the hierarchy imposed and the inequalities in the Garden already existed, if at the very least, in God’s foresight. Does this mean that we should not study Milton anymore? Does it mean that nothing we do has purpose? That nothing Adam does, nor Eve, carries any kind of weight? I would argue that it indubitably calls for the opposite; that we should maximize every opportunity we can get, to choose, to make decisions, and fulfill that sense of agency within ourselves. And in the end of Paradise Lost, isn’t that what Mankind does?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Analysis Of John Milton 's ' Paradise Lost '

- The role of a tragic hero is not necessarily always a good person in it’s self, Shakespeare 's character Macbeth from "The Tragedy of Macbeth" and Batman from the DC comics are both examples of a tragic hero that was truly villains. Milton’s main character in his epic poem Paradise Lost is a prime sample of how a tragic hero may not be an actual hero. Satan, known from the Bible 's geneticist, is the actual root of all evil, he is the being that waged war against God and tricked the first humans into eating the forbidden fruit, the being that wishes death to heaven and earth....   [tags: Paradise Lost, Adam and Eve, John Milton]

Better Essays
1114 words (3.2 pages)

Adam and Eve: Breaking the Social Construct With John Milton's Paradise Lost

- Man above woman, or woman above man. For the entirety of human civilization, this question of gender hierarchy has been divisive issue. Regardless, Milton does not hesitate to join the heat of the battle, and project his thoughts to the world. Since the publication of Paradise Lost, many of Milton’s readers have detected in his illustration of the prelapsarian couple, particularly of Adam, a powerful patriarchal sentiment: “he for God only, and she for God in him” (Milton, IV.299). In essence, this idea declares that Adam and Eve possess unequal roles – Adam is better than Eve, as men are better than women, in accordance to the deeply conventional reading of the relations between the sexes....   [tags: Human Civilization, Gender Norms]

Better Essays
1316 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Milton 's Reformation Of The Epic Tradition

- Milton’s Reformation of the Epic Tradition The epic genre has existed for centuries and it isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. However, as culture and values change so does the epic tradition. Milton played a large role in introducing the Christian worldview to the epic tradition through the epic poem Paradise Lost. Instead of continuing the tradition through humanistic values, Milton applies his faith to the epic genre and allows Christian values and truths to permeate through the text of Paradise Lost....   [tags: Paradise Lost, John Milton, Adam and Eve]

Better Essays
1262 words (3.6 pages)

Book VIII of John Milton's Paradise Lost Essay

- Book VIII of John Milton's Paradise Lost As Book VIII of John Milton’s Paradise Lost begins, the “new-waked” human Adam ponders the nature of the universe and the motion of the stars (ll. 4-38). When Adam has finished his speech, Milton takes the opportunity to describe Eve, who is listening nearby. We find Eve reclining in the Garden, but with grace, not laziness: “she sat retired in sight,/With lowliness majestic from her seat” (41-42). This “lowliness majestic” is the central phrase to understanding Eve’s character—she is both humble and glorious....   [tags: VIII Milton Paradise Lost Eve Adam Essays]

Better Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)

Analysis Of The Hammer Of Witches That Was Created By Two Inquisitors Essay

- Identify 1. Malleus Maleficarum a. A publication that was published in 1486 also known as the Hammer of Witches that was created by two inquisitors. This book almost outsold any other book that was in publication except for the Bible, even though the book was about witchcraft. This book was considered to be the manual on witch hunting during that time. 2. Spirit/flesh a. 3. Ahriman a. Ahriman was the first real Devil in the standards of the world of religion. Ahriman was one of the two spirits the other was Ohrmazd, they were separated by a void....   [tags: Adam and Eve, Paradise Lost, John Milton, God]

Better Essays
1768 words (5.1 pages)

Paradise Lost By John Milton Essay

- John Milton was a Puritan poet and author who started writing in 1658. One of his most renowned works was his epic, Paradise Lost, which was published in 1667. In Paradise Lost, Milton describes and tells the story of how paradise slipped from the hands of Adam and Eve and how they were dismissed from the Garden of Eden. Divided into 12 books, the epic starts by stating the purpose of the epic: to describe the loss of mankind’s spiritual innocence. Then, it goes into the very start of evil in the world with the fall of Satan and his self-appointment as ruler of hell....   [tags: Garden of Eden, Paradise Lost, Adam and Eve]

Better Essays
1476 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Paradise Lost By John Milton

- Milton’s poem Paradise Lost tells the story of Adam and Eve’s creation and how they came to their fall from innocence in the Garden of Eden. The poem does not start from the beginning but rather in the middle of the current action. At this point of the plot, readers already know why God has created Adam and Eve. It appears that God’s ultimate purpose for creating Adam and Eve was so he could pass on his greatest traits into physical form. Adam was created first which led to Eve’s creation for the sole reason that Adam needed a companion....   [tags: Adam and Eve, Garden of Eden, Paradise Lost]

Better Essays
1621 words (4.6 pages)

Essay about Milton 's Paradise Lost

- Milton’s “Paradise Lost” refashions the falls of Satan, Adam, and Eve to create characters that better fit Milton’s own modern opinions. Although the Garden of Eden in “Paradise Lost” initially resembles a patriarchal society to the reader, it can be concluded that Adam and Eve each have an equality in the form of the free will they are gifted with from God. Adam and Eve work together as a unit to achieve the rules put forth by God, and they each have their own perspectives and roles in their partnership....   [tags: Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve, Paradise Lost]

Better Essays
786 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Milton 's Theodicy On Paradise Lost

- Milton’s Theodicy (Milton’s Theodicy in Paradise Lost) In John Milton’s Paradise Lost, he makes God the all-powerful, trusted and feared force. His theodicy creates God as a good force, not an evil one, but the way he writes Paradise Lost and the fall of mankind suggests that either Milton did not think God was all that powerful or turned his cheek when evil plotted against Him.God is trusted by humans in this epic poem because Milton writes that Adam and Eve pray often and trust all God has done for them....   [tags: Paradise Lost, Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve]

Better Essays
1030 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on John Milton 's Paradise Lost

- John Milton’s Theodicy works well, the story is very well presented through this story of Man’s first fall, although, there are many things that are flawed in Milton’s story. Some examples of his flaw are from his views on Eve, as a woman who is easily persuaded, and as a female who must be constantly monitored because if she is not watched she may be easily tempted, which is not the case. He is also flawed in his account of Adam, that Adam does not know about the creation in the garden, which is not the case....   [tags: Paradise Lost, Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve]

Better Essays
1015 words (2.9 pages)