Lael Matthews is facing an ethical dilemma issue. She need to decide which of three managers to promote. Each manager has their advantage and disadvantage own, and Lael’s superior has his or her own preference and concern as well. Lael have to make a decision that is moral, and hopefully can satisfy all the parties involved.
According to the article, “Thinking Ethically: A Framework for Moral Decision Making”, developed by Manuel Velasquez, Claire Andre, Thomas Shanks, S.J., and Michael J. Meyer, there are five different approaches to values to deal with moral issues, which are:
The Utilitarian Approach: the ethical decision should provides the greatest good for the greatest number;
The Rights Approach: the decision should respect the moral rights of everyone;
The Fairness or Justice Approach: the decision progress should treats everyone the same unless there is a justifiable reason not to, and does not show favoritism or discrimination;
The Common-Good Approach: advances the common good because individuals whose own good is inextricably linked to the good of the community;
The Virtue Approach: assumes that there are certain ideals toward which we should strive, which provide for the full development of our humanity.
This is the framework I am going to use in my paper.
Lael is going to review the following three manager in the company: Liz, Roy, and Quang Yeh. Below is facts that I think might have a bearing on this problem, show as a table so make us easier to compare their difference, which is good for making utilitarian approach.
Liz Roy Quang Yeh
Race African American White American Asian
Age 34 57 27
Marriage Divorced Married single
Children 1 (medical problems) 3 0
... middle of paper ...
...er Workers”, by Stephen Bastien, hiring older workers can help company maintain a reliable, dedicated workforce and provide a significant cost savings for both the short and long term. Roy’s unique skills are valuable. Many in the company fell he has earned it and this is important.
The operational goal of the choice should satisfy most people in the company, and the action should be moral. Lael should let everyone in the company understand how she made this decision. According to “Create a Culture of Trust”, by Noreen Kelly, communication and transparency is one of the key to create a culture of trust.
Following is the specific action steps:
Make sure everyone understand what the company is looking for.
Explain to everyone why he earned it.
Give Liz a reasonable amount of financial aid to show company’s support for Liz and her family.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- In order to beat its competitors, Under Armour Company can engage in market sensitive fresh product invention. New products are more likely to draw curiosity amongst the populations especially if they commensurate well with the prevailing trends (Hill & Jones 2009, p. 308). UA concentrated on the outside-in (market responsive) approach to carry out its strategies. It is reported that it sourced unique synthetic materials and employed on field product development. This enabled it to create the performance apparel segment in the athletic apparel market.... [tags: Case Study]
1299 words (3.7 pages)
- "Harley-Davidson: At Last" as presented in Hartley's Marketing Mistakes and Successes presents the circumstances around HD's near collapse and since rinse to near mythic success. This case is a great example of marketing myopia; HD saw them-selves as full-size motorcycles' manufactures, not in the transportation, or even the entertainment industry. They believed no one bought motorcycles for transportation, but rather for leisure time use. Like the automotive industry of the time, Harley-Davidson thought its cure customers would buy its products versus those of any of its major competitors, chiefly because they were all foreign.... [tags: Business Case Study]
1355 words (3.9 pages)
- MAKING DECISIONS: A CASE STUDY OF INCLUSION, COMMUNICATION AND WELL BEING Introduction and rationale Communication is the sharing of information and it is needed to confirm our identity and our individualism. Allan and Killick (2008, p.212) describe the relationship we have with others in “As social animals, we conduct our lives in the context of relationships which rely on communication”. A person with dementia can often be excluded from the communication process through many internal or external barriers.... [tags: Inclusion, Communication, Well Being]
1907 words (5.4 pages)
- Various Expressions of Grief Heaney’s lyric poem “Mid- Term Break” is filled with various expressions of emotions caused by the death of a loved one. Robert Stecker in, “Expressiveness and Expression in Music and Poetry” stated that, “It is also virtually impossible to read a lyric poem without taking it to express and attitude toward (a possibly fictional) someone or some (possibly fictional) state of affairs.” (89). In the case of this lyric, it is the reactions of the loved ones left behind after the unexpected death of a four year old little boy that are expressed in this poem.... [tags: Mid Term Break, Heaney, Lyric Poem, Poetry]
1697 words (4.8 pages)
- The two poems I am going to compare are Mid-Term Break by Seamus Heaney and Death Be Not Proud by John Donne. The first poem I am going to study is a poem by Seamus Heaney called Mid-Term Break. Seamus Heaney was born in County Derry into a farming background. He attended St. Columb’s College in Derry where he was a border. Heaney went on to win the Nobel Prize for Literature. The poet’s title Mid-Term Break is somewhat ambiguous as it would suggest a holiday of some sort, whereas, the poem is actually about the death of Heaney’s young brother who was killed in a tragic accident.... [tags: English Literature]
1432 words (4.1 pages)
- The luxury of being able to feed the world is overwhelming, more so that it blinds one 's judgment. The long term effect of GMOs are unpredictable; they impose serious threats to health and people should have the right to determine whether they want to consume them or not. Putting one’s health into the hands of production companies does little to assure safety. The public is not aware of the dangers they are exposed to or the fact that they are potentially putting their life at risk. GMOs have been around since the early ‘80s, between then and today no one is certain of the long term consequences that follow the consumption of genetically modified food.... [tags: Genetically modified organism]
1028 words (2.9 pages)
- Krispy Kreme Case Study Question 1. The chief element of Krispy Kreme's strategy is to deliver a better doughnut and to appeal to customers in new ways. They have taken great steps to insure customer satisfaction from the use of their proprietary flour recipe to their automated doughnut making machines. They have chosen to target mainly markets with 100,000 households. They also were exploring smaller-sized stores for secondary markets. Krispy Kremes's strong brand name, highly differentiated products, high-volume production capability and multi-channel market penetration strategy has worked well.... [tags: Business Analysis Strategy]
1002 words (2.9 pages)
- “Sustainability is a matter of long term development” (Fowler, J., Sept.24th), this is the simplest statement describes the word “sustainability” till the end of the third week lecture. After two weeks’ lecture class and ESS lecture classes, the concept that “sustainability” is not a certain technology or policy (Introduction to Environment, Sustainability and Society, slide79) is founded in my mind. Mind Shift organization and professor Matthew Schnurr’s research taught me more specifically that sustainability is not just about environment.... [tags: Genetically modified organism]
1016 words (2.9 pages)
- This case study explores how a sudden life change affects certain behaviors and psychological changes in an individual. In the film, “John Q.”, the main character, John Q. Archibald, who is played by Denzel Washington, experiences a sudden life change when his son, Michael Archibald, is suddenly diagnosed with cardiomegaly. Cardiomegaly is an abnormal enlargement of the heart and requires a heart transplant for long term survival. In the beginning of the movie, John Q. Archibald’s wife’s car was repossessed due to non-payment, his hours were reduced at work, and he could not find a second job to support his family.... [tags: Psychology Case Study]
866 words (2.5 pages)
- “ All who have meditated on the art of governing mankind have been convinced that the fate of empires depends on the education of youth” (Aristotle) Albert Einstein once said “Information alone is not knowledge” and therefore I believe turning students into data storage devices and asking them to restore the information back on an assessment paper is not education. Our school’s perspective of education is closer to OSHO’s (2004, p. 117) vision “children should be helped to be more inventive not repetitive” The School The school I work in, as most schools in Abu Dhabi, the capital of the United Arab Emirates is under the supervision and regulations of Abu Dhabi Educational Council (ADEC).... [tags: Education]
1005 words (2.9 pages)