My aim for this paper is to explain how a patient with an inorganic brain i.e. a digital computer in place for the original brain, who behaves normally actually has mental states. Further, I will also tackle the points raised by Doctor 1 and Doctor 3 to make my case stronger and the conclusion more apt.
First and foremost, it is important to have a clear understanding of what the scenario with the patient is and what stance each doctor is making.
So here is the background story: We have a patient in a certain hospital that has been behaving normally under all circumstances, but she doesn’t possess a regular organic brain built of tissues like mine and, I assume, yours. Her brain has been replaced by a digital computer that takes the feedback her nervous system, processes it and causes her to react.
Now, here is the take of each doctor on her mental states:
Doctor 1 (dualist), believes that she has no mental states as she now lacks a ‘soul’.
Doctor 2 (monist-functionalist), a more reasonable man, feels the causal power of the digital computer is similar to the human brain and hence is producing mental states as well.
Doctor 3 (monist-identity theorist), says that the mental states are directly associated with the brain and the absence of the organic brain implies the absence of the mental states as well.
Doctor 4 (monist-behaviorist), says that because the patient’s behavior and her disposition to behave hasn’t change...
... middle of paper ...
...fully capable of thinking and reacting to situations and is hence fully capable of having mental states. Therefore, it is more reasonable to claim that the patient has mental states.
Before citing sources I would like to thank Dr. Jillian S. McIntosh and Duncan Branhardt for the guidance they provided in understanding the topic, the material and on presenting the paper.
An overview on behaviorism: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/behaviorism/
An overview on functionalism: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/functionalism/
An overview on identity theory: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mind-identity/
Lecture Slides for Phil 100W-1141, Spring 2014, Dr. Jillian S. McIntosh © 2014
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Autism is a global mental phenomenon that is present within the minds of many, no matter the race, gender, age, or physical health of the person. Autism is a mental illness that affects a person's mind, modifying their social contributions, work, and just everyday life making simple days a struggle. The mental illness known as autism affects all of the people with autism and the ones around them. With no cure arising in the near future, people must continue to adapt and learn how to help these people who are “different” in their own way.... [tags: Psychology, Mind, Brain]
1001 words (2.9 pages)
- “Anatomically and functionally, the brain is the most complex structure in the body. It controls our ability to think, our awareness of things around us, and our interactions with the outside world” (Mattson Porth, 2007, p. 823). Carol Mattson Porth described it the best; the brain is the control room in our body. The brain is the organ in our skull that tells the rest of our body what to do; our lungs to breath, our eyelids to blink, and our heart to pump blood are just a couple examples of bodily functions our brain controls.... [tags: Human brain, Brain]
1221 words (3.5 pages)
- The relation between brain and mind is disputed over a long time. The debate is whether mind and brain are separate entities or not and if the mind is a separate entity, then how are mental properties, functions and consciousness in relation with the brain, being things which are non-physical. Consciousness helps to understand the relation between the brain and mind, by contemplating the reason or the source of it, if it’s a manifestation of the mind or just a by-product of brain activity.... [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Brain, Materialism]
1436 words (4.1 pages)
- Mental illness is a plague that incapacitates the human brain and corrupts people’s thoughts and feelings. “In the United States and internationally mental disorders are common.“ According to the National Institute of mental Health (Statistic, page 1) an estimated 26.2 percent of American ages 18 and older , that’s about one in four adults, suffer from diagnosable mental disorder in a given year”. Many people walk the challenges of mental illness without a proper diagnosis, or confirming their suspicion that something is wrong with how they are functioning on a daily basis.... [tags: Mental Illness]
1296 words (3.7 pages)
- The article, in a nutshell, talks about the placebo effect and the studies that were involved that proved that it, in fact, works with patients. Patients suffering from certain mental disorders (or physical) believed that they were being injected with a painkiller without them knowing it was in fact just a fake injection, however, giving the effect on the mind that it was a real injection to treat the disorder. Then, the article goes into the scientific explanation of how some of these effects actually work with the brain and our mental state.... [tags: Brain, Psychology, Mind, Thought]
734 words (2.1 pages)
- Weighing only 3 pounds, the human brain is the most complex structure known to man. It is what sets humans apart from the rest of the other animals. It is a powerful organ that allows us to learn, store memories, think creatively, and communicate with one and another. Physical damage to any organ in the human body can be detrimental and that is no different with the brain. However, once the brain is damaged, there is often nothing that can be done. Damage to the brain is not only done physically, but a person 's lifestyle, in particular, living in poverty has negative effects to the brain.... [tags: Brain, Nervous system, Neuron, Human brain]
1231 words (3.5 pages)
- Everyone gets sick sometimes. Some people get sore throats, fevers or break arm and they might need a cast, these illnesses require you to go to the Doctor to have it checked out, and are needed to buy medication to treat this sickness. While this is Physical illness there is also Mental Illnesses sometimes referred to as Mental Disorders. Being Mentally Ill can be psychologically painful but it can also be painful for your wallet or insurance. Getting treatment and medication is highly expensive.... [tags: Mental disorder, Psychiatry, Abnormal psychology]
2435 words (7 pages)
- In my opinion, mental states are not behavioural dispositions as described by behaviourists. Behaviourism originally arose to address the flaws of substance Dualism and present a solution to the mind-body problem. Since then many other philosophies have provided alternative solutions to the mind-body problem and exposed holes in behaviourism. Behaviourism states that behavioural dispositions are tendencies to react with a certain kind of stimuli. For example, if one is confronted with a tiger you would be disposed to; run away, shout for help and assert ‘there is a tiger.’ This is what is known as a mental state, a stimulus and the relevant dispositions.... [tags: behaviourism, argumentative essay]
1033 words (3 pages)
- Meningitis is an inflammation of the membranes (meninges’) surrounding the brain and spinal cord. Meningitis has several causes including bacteria, chemical irritation, drug allergies and most commonly viruses. Most cases of meningitis in the United States are caused by a viral infection not by bacteria. Viral meningitis accounts for around 25,000-50,000 hospital visits and more than 10,000 of those cases are diagnosed as meningitis annually. Around 4,000 Americans are diagnosed annually with bacterial meningitis, 500 of those cases ending fatally.... [tags: infection, brain, treatment]
1322 words (3.8 pages)
- Ride the Tiger: A guild through the Bipolar Brain Information Applied to Practice Compared to other areas of medicine, mental health is decades behind in finding and applying new intervention strategies that work to alleviate and sooth symptoms of mental health disorders. The use of therapy, medication and in extreme cases electroshock therapy has been used since the 1950s to aid patients in recovery. However, there are new advances in technology that are currently being developed to better understand and assist in the fight against mental health disorders such as bipolar (“Ride the Tiger, 2016).... [tags: Psychology, Mental disorder, Schizophrenia]
1021 words (2.9 pages)