Mental State Of The Trial Essay

Mental State Of The Trial Essay

Length: 969 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


When a person is accused of a crime, it is the responsibility of a judge to deem them competent to stand trial, mentally unstable to at the time of their trial, or not guilty by reason of insanity. This was something that was highly disputed during and after the case of John Salvi. John Salvi was an anti-abortionist of strong Catholic faith who shot and killed two people in attacks at Planned Parenthood clinics.

Throughout the trial, defense attorneys attempted to argue Salvi was suffering from psychological disorders that would make him incompetent for trial. Ultimately, however Salvi was found competent to stand trial. After reading Salvi’s full psychiatric interview, the official court transcript of the four-day competency hearing, and the day-to-day summary; I have come to agree that the defendant, John Salvi was competent to stand trial.
Competency to stand trial relates directly to the defendant’s mental state at the time of trial and during the proceedings. This does not directly relate to the mental state of the defendant at the time of the crime. This determination is left to the judge of the trial. One of the main ways that a defendant is tested for competency is by hiring a psychologist to perform a psychological evaluation on the defendant. Some of the things that are needed to proven to show competency are being able to communicate with the defense counsel, being able to understand and process information, understanding the elements of the charge, the gravity of the charges, and the possible outcome and being able to process information. Typically, intelligence, language difficulties, communication skills, and education level have little bearing on declaring incompetency.
John Salvi showed competency in not one, bu...


... middle of paper ...


...ns were elective and not an involuntary symptom of a psychological disorder.
Based off of these examples pulled from the competency trial and interview, I believe the judge was correct in ruling that John Salvi was competent to stand trial. However, based off of some of the things defense brought up it is easy to see how insanity defense still needs to be researched. There is still so much uncertainty of the scientific knowledge of abnormal behavior. Lastly, these interviews conducted by psychologists happen months to years after the crime occurred and these clinicians may not be able to one hundred percent assess the mental instability at the time of the crime. It is clear that this trial has opened the eyes of many when it comes to insanity and competency and hopefully the discussions will lead to more accurate scales for testing the competency of those on trial.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Hinckley Trial and the Insanity Defense Essay

- ... TREPANATION 20th century 3. ROTATIONAL THERAPY 4. MESMERISM (1734-1815) 5. LOBOTOMY 6. Electroconvulsive therapy 7.restraint 8. Strong drugs 9. Shock water treatment 10. Bleeding 11. Blistering salves. Such treatments often left patients severely damaged and not being able to function in society. New psychiatric drugs were developed in the 1950s, there was a new-found belief that people in mental institutions could be rehabilitated. Our current day treatments are rehabilitation hospitals, counseling, and medications....   [tags: symptoms of insanity, crime, trial]

Better Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

The Right For A Speedy And Public Trial Essay example

- The right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury is implicitly indicated in the Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution. A jury is a panel of citizens who hear and render a verdict in a case that is being tried in the community. Juries hear and render verdicts on both Civil and Criminal cases. Currently, juror qualifications are the following; are at least 18 years of age, a United States Citizen, reside in the location of jury service, are able to read and write in English, have no disqualifying mental or physical condition....   [tags: Jury, Jury trial, Law, Grand jury]

Better Essays
1052 words (3 pages)

A Real Twelve Angry Men and Jerry Sandusky Trial Essay

- As a juror in any court case it would be difficult to come to one conclusion with twelve different opinions. The fictional play Twelve Angry Men proved this to be true, however, the jurors in the Sandusky trial found it relatively easy to decide on a verdict. Jerry Sandusky, former Penn State assistant football coach and founder of the 2nd Mile charity, was convicted of fifty-two accounts of child molestation. Although members of the jury would like to discuss every aspect of the case, in the end, convicting Sandusky guilty would be a simple task....   [tags: sexual encounters, trial, abuse ]

Better Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about The Competency to Stand Trial

- The criminal justice system takes on a pivotal role in pursuing and preventing crimes in society. When a suspect is caught and then faced with charges for a violent crime, they legally have the right to a fair trial. In order for a criminal proceeding to successfully take place, the defendant must be fully aware of their surroundings, have a basic understanding of court procedures, as well as being capable of defending their one case. Competency to stand trial (CST) is essential for maintaining fairness in the courtroom and producing a just verdict....   [tags: criminal justice, crime, criminal, trials]

Better Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on The Competency to Stand Trial

- The Supreme Court of the United States interpretation of the Sixth and a Fourteenth amendment is that defendants, who do not fit the legal description of competence to stand trial, should not be tried while they are in such a condition. Competency to stand trial refers to a person being able to participate as well as assist in his or her own defense. It has to be determined inline with the legal definition given by the laws before an individual can stand trial. The Supreme Court set a specific standard when determining competency to stand trial....   [tags: supreme court, dusky standards, juducial system]

Better Essays
1388 words (4 pages)

Psychological Anthropology And Mental Health Essay

- Psychological anthropology is an interdisciplinary subfield of anthropology that studies the interactions between culture and mental process. This subfield tends to focus on the ways in which humans ' development within human perception, motivation and mental health. However we will focus on the subfield of mental health and how it plays a role in issues within anthropology and the public. Psychological anthropology is viewed by the public as the study of all mental issues and not the things that relate to it....   [tags: Mental disorder, Schizophrenia, Psychology]

Better Essays
1771 words (5.1 pages)

Mental Illness and Violent Crime Essay

- The stereotype that goes hand in hand with mental illness that though seems to have improved over the years is still pervasive. Teplin, Abram & McClelland (1994) state that people in general, believe that people with mental illness are more likely to commit violent crime with those without mental illness. In their study they seek to find evidence to that statement – to learn if having a mental illness increases the likeliness of violent crime and recidivism after release from prison. This author seeks to discover the same using similar data to learn if there is a connection between violent crime and mental illness....   [tags: mental disorders, types of crimes]

Better Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Public Rampage Killings And Mental Illness Essay

- Mass murderers are routinely diagnosed with mental illnesses. By that time, according to testimony at his trial, Jamie Rouse was working nights, taking Max Alert to stay awake and Sominex to get to sleep, and listening to heavy metal music cranked very loud because it drowned out the voices in his head that he later told psychiatrists he had been hearing at the time. Sylvia Seegrist’s mother in a recent interview, remembered the ' 'feelings of hopelessness, helplessness, despair, of incredible sadness ' ' as she and her husband watched their only daughter overtaken by schizophrenia....   [tags: Psychiatry, Mental disorder, Mental health]

Better Essays
1035 words (3 pages)

Mental Illness and Facilities Essay

- Madhouses, loony bins, insane asylums, monsters, witches, and lunatics. These are the terms that haunt both the mentally ill and the facilities that provide their treatment. The stigma of mental illness prevents persons in need of treatment from seeking help for their mental illnesses. Stigma has been reduced throughout the years due to mental health support groups and out-patient care; however, stigma is still a very prominent issue today. Stigma causes those with mental illness to feel isolated and alienated, so they may harm themselves, or be afraid to find help....   [tags: Treatment, Mental Health Support Systems]

Better Essays
1626 words (4.6 pages)

An Indictable Offence and How it is Brought to Trial Essay

- An Indictable Offence and How it is Brought to Trial An indictable offence is an offence that may be tried on indictment, i.e.- by a jury in the Crown Court. Most serious offences i.e. murder and rape are indictable offences. A judge and jury in the Crown Court try indictable offences, and the magistrates sit only as examining justices to decide whether the prosecution has sufficient evidence to justify a trial. In a Practice Direction issued in May 1995, Lord Taylor CJ defined the four classes of offence triable on indictment as follows: Ø Class 1: Offences carrying the death penalty, misprision of treason, treason felony, murder, genocide, offences under s.1 of...   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
3559 words (10.2 pages)