Essay on Medical Practices And Objectivity : The Universal Goal Of Medicine

Essay on Medical Practices And Objectivity : The Universal Goal Of Medicine

Length: 1464 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Medical Practices and Objectivity
Evaniya Shakya

The universal goal of medicine is to intervene in the progress of disease and sickness in the human body. Though the intention of medicine is the same for all doctors, the methods by which they practice this interventionist discipline is vastly different. Good argues that studying medicine is a “process of coming to inhabit a new world” (Good 70). However, this process of deconstructing “reality” (Good 67) and integrating yourself into the “medical world” (Good 71) is a process heavily tainted by political views, cultural influences and beliefs we embody in reality. This “new world” founded on a curriculum made by medical institutions is influenced by the biases and prejudgments in society and, therefore, determines how medicine is taught, practiced and perceived. In this paper, I argue that medical knowledge is focused and filtered through the lens of the dominant sociocultural views prevalent in a particular region or a point in history but its non-objectivity is disguised by the “formative practices” (Good 67) of medicine.
The interventions that are allowed and required by medicine are so radically deviant from the rules of the nonmedical world that it requires a new realm or space that is seemingly impenetrable by reality. An example of a smaller scale manifestation of this medical realm is the anatomy lab. Interviews of Harvard medical students conducted by Good show us that “intrusion of the ordinary reality into this space are experienced as violation.” (Good 72) In the lab, students are taught to hone their “medical gaze.” (Good 73) to perceive the body “anatomically.” (Good 73) Exposed and trained to handle the body in “unnatural” ways, students ar...


... middle of paper ...


...lish safe drug use centers. This may be because her “gaze” (Good 69) is not fully confined to medical institutions.
The privileging of certain practices in medicine makes the hospitals more effective and standardized. However, at the same time, it ignores a large pool of knowledge that doesn’t fit its model for what the practice of medicine should be. To produce objective knowledge, medical students must be made aware of the social influences that affect the interpretation of data. Schools like Cornell University now require pre-med students to take social science classes. The view that the medicine is completely separate from practices like midwifery is not beneficial to either discipline. When “neither group creates a world the other recognizes as real.” (Wendland 227) the intersection of knowledge between disciplines becomes difficult.











Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis Of The Film, For Profit Hmo 's And The Universal Healthcare System Of Other Industrialized Countries

- 1. In the film, for profit HMO’s in the U.S are a stark contrast against the universal healthcare system of other industrialized countries. Our insurers are not so much concerned with your health but with minimizing the amount spent on their customers. They deny coverage based on pre-existing conditions because it may be too costly for them. The film highlights examples of startling reasons for being denied such as being too skinny or fat. We see whistleblower Dr. Linda Peeno reveal that Doctors are incentivized to deny claims to increase profits especially if they wish to rise within the industry....   [tags: Health care, Universal health care, Medicine]

Better Essays
1158 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The American Medical Student Association

- The American Medical Student Association It is your junior year of college. You are in a practice interview to prepare you for your MCAT and clinicals- your palms are sweaty, your foot is involuntarily tapping 90-to-nothing, and your mouth feels like you have swallowed a tablespoon of alum. The board calls your name and you walk in. Minutes pass where you daze off but, suddenly regain awareness. They ask you what volunteer service or internships have you participated in. panic runs through your mind because you have not done anything....   [tags: Medicine, Universal health care, Physician]

Better Essays
1075 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Goal Of Health Care

- The goal of health care today is to be universal, to be able to speak one common language despite of location, to have interoperability. By doing so less time will be spent on obtaining document and asking the patient redundant question once they move from one location to the next and more time will be spent on actual patient care. By having to focus switch to more patient care it will guarantee more patient satisfaction, faster recovery time and less medical or financial error. The focus of this paper is to gain knowledge of ICD-10 as well as HL7, and see if there is any relation between the two....   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health care provider]

Better Essays
1758 words (5 pages)

Essay on Access Of The Universal Health Coverage

- Topic: Access to Hard to Reach Groups in Indonesia Introduction The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) put much emphasis on the attainment of the universal health coverage, globally (1). However, ensuring that health services are accessible to the geographically hard to reach groups remain a critical challenge for most countries (2). Health services in many countries contend with extensively large geographical distances, impassable roads as well as completely isolated islands from the mainstream country and important cities (3)....   [tags: Medicine, Health care, Health, Healthcare]

Better Essays
1650 words (4.7 pages)

Should Researchers be Upheld to Universal Standards? Essay

- Offering the rarest of human conditions, third world countries have become the new proverbial Petri dish of biological experimentation. Researchers working in remote locations with impoverished populations would never be able to find in their home countries, but this only serves to highlight the problem that inherently faces all research studies, the protection and rights of research subjects. The Belmont Principles were intended to provide ethical standards that apply universally to all research subject regardless of where they were located....   [tags: belmont principles, medical ethics, tuskegee]

Better Essays
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Importance Of A Medical Office Administrator

- Socrates was a man of many questions; seeking answers to better his self and society. Socrates strongly believed in living the best life possible life and encouraged his students to do the same. Socrates believed in three ideas: living right, never doing wrong and keeping agreements. Medical office personnel have an enormous ethical responsibility to the patients they work with, the facility they work in, and to themselves. A medical office administrator’s duties include interacting with patients, answering phones, scheduling appointments, organizing and updating medical records, process insurance forms and bookkeeping....   [tags: Ethics, Medicine]

Better Essays
1366 words (3.9 pages)

Should The United States Move A System That Truly Provides Universal Health Insurance Coverage?

- Should the United States move to a system that truly provides universal health insurance coverage. What are the key arguments in favor and against. The extremely high costs of health care and the continuing rise of these costs is the key argument against universal care. Critics maintain that this country simply can not afford to open the gates of care to each and every individual. However, this country is one of the wealthiest and has a substantial amount of resources and technology within the area of health care....   [tags: Health care, Health economics, Medicine]

Better Essays
864 words (2.5 pages)

The Tuskeee Study: Radically Changed the Views and Practice of Medicine and Ethics

- The Tuskegee Study has radically changed the views and practice of medicine and ethics. The 40 year long study impacted 600 African American men and their families. It began as a scientific investigation of syphilis as it affected black men. Back in the 1930’s, it was thought to be true that black men were genetically different from white men and that black men’s bodies reacted differently to syphilis. The goal was to see what would happen to the men who had syphilis if they were left untreated (CDC, 2009)....   [tags: Medical Ethics]

Better Essays
1005 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Health Care Reform: Was Universal Health Care the Answer?

- What is universal health care. Universal health care is a form of health coverage which is provided by a government so that all of its citizens have access to health services. In the universal health care is a system of providing health coverage for any and all willing participants. This is usually through a government program, funded by taxes. The United States is the only developed country in the world to not have a universal health care system for its citizens. Medicaid and Medicare do not count because they target a select group of citizens....   [tags: Healthcare Reform, Obama Care]

Better Essays
2330 words (6.7 pages)

The Current State Of Health Essay

- The current state of health in India is tied directly to the country’s history. While traditional medicine, specifically Ayurveda, has existed in India for thousands of years, the subcontinent lacked a formal health system until the arrival of the British in the 17th century. The first Western medical professionals arrived on British East India Company ships in 1608, and in 1664 the Madras General Hospital opened as India’s first hospital, serving only British soldiers. The East India Company established colonial rule in 1757 then founded the first medical department seven years later....   [tags: Medicine, Universal health care, Health economics]

Better Essays
893 words (2.6 pages)