Essay on The Media 's Misrepresentation Of The Criminal Justice System

Essay on The Media 's Misrepresentation Of The Criminal Justice System

Length: 1822 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview



During the 2006 Canadian election, the Conservative party proposed a series of crime reduction strategies in their political platform in order to respond to public discontent (Doob & Webster 2016, p. 359; Piquero & Blumstein 2007, p. 267). The media’s misrepresentation of the criminal justice system – such as highlighting serious crimes, lenient sentences, and high profile cases – distorted and diminished public confidence (Tonry 2013, p.246-247). In light of their limited understanding of the justice system, the populace began to support punitive sentencing (Tonry 2013, p. 246-247). In a recently online article, Conservatives Want Mandatory Minimum Sentences for Fentanyl Crimes (Vice 2016, September 21, p.2), Rachel Brown describes how the recent media coverage of fentanyl related deaths has caused a moral panic in the community. Brown notes that recent conservative moral entrepreneurs – “individuals, groups, or organizations that seek action against certain groups of people or certain behaviours and bring pressure on the legislators to enact criminal statutes”(Griffiths 2014, p.15) – are pressing for mandatory minimum sentences on fentanyl trafficking crimes despite the ample empirical data that suggests mandatory minimums are ineffective and unconstitutional.
Consequently, upon their appointment to Parliament, the Conservative government, led by Stephen Harper, passed their tough on crime policy that stressed prison, incapacitation, and punishment; this included the introduction of mandatory minimum sentences (Doob & Webster 2016, p. 359; Piquero & Blumstein 2007, p. 267). However, Tonry (2013, p.247) has questioned the reasoning behind the government’s policy as crime rates in Canada have been decreasing since the 1990s. Gr...


... middle of paper ...


...es were unsuccessful as a means of reducing crime – such as producing rigid and unconstitutional legislature. Instead, they adversely effected sentencing disparity (Tonry 2013, p.474) by removing the human mechanisms that could gauge the complexity of aggravating and mitigating factors. The only thing certain regarding mandatory minimums, is that they provided Parliament with more power over the criminal justice system. As of recent, (The Globe and Mail 2016, November 01, p.1) Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould announced that the government will be removing the tough on crime and mandatory minimum policies in order to increase judicial discretion. In this news article, (The Globe and Mail 2016, November 01, p.1) Sean Fine reports that the government plans to concern itself more with marginalized groups, “mental illness, addiction, poverty, and indigenous issues”.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Media 's Misrepresentation Of The Criminal Justice System

- During the 2006 Canadian election, the Conservative party proposed a series of crime reduction strategies in their political platform in order to respond to public discontent (Doob & Webster 2016, p. 359; Piquero & Blumstein 2007, p. 267). The media’s misrepresentation of the criminal justice system – such as highlighting serious crimes, lenient sentences, and high profile cases – distorted and diminished public confidence (Tonry 2013, p.246-247). In light of their limited understanding of the justice system, the populace began to support punitive sentencing (Tonry 2013, p....   [tags: Mandatory sentencing, Crime, Judicial discretion]

Better Essays
1822 words (5.2 pages)

Critique on the Criminal Justice System and Social Media Essay

- 1. Interesting Points: a. An interesting point I found was the contribution of the criminal justice system to an ideology. The ideology is explained as the set of beliefs that formulate and justify the existing state of affairs and its unfairness. The message being conveyed by the criminal justice system is that the result of criminality is from a single persons weakness versus the inequities of the social class (177, 2). I find this interesting that the failures of the individual is being the pinpoint of criminality and that social inequity is being preserved in the doing so....   [tags: sociological analysis]

Better Essays
755 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on The Ethics Of The Criminal Justice System

- Have you ever thought about the world you live in, on how its structure for humans in America. The only society who system and laws were establish by the founding fathers over a century ago. Throughout the century many laws have change but many of the amendments that we follow we interpret through the criminal justice system. As today the laws that are enforced by the government, the media, and political correctness play a major role and also impact the criminal justice system. We are a nation of laws because we have to build a foundation to strengthen the government and be well run country....   [tags: Police, Crime, Criminal justice]

Better Essays
1542 words (4.4 pages)

Crime And The Criminal Justice System Essay

- Criminality is any act that is deemed criminal by a society. There are two types of crime, mala in se and mala prohibita; the former being crimes that are bad in and of themselves, whereas the latter are crimes that are criminal because they have been prohibited by a society. The social construction orientation is more aligned with the mala prohibita section of criminality (Kraska 162). In the words of criminologist Howard Becker, “social groups create deviance by making the rules whose infraction constitutes deviance,” (162)....   [tags: Sociology, Crime, Criminal justice, Criminal law]

Better Essays
840 words (2.4 pages)

Relationship Between Criminal Justice And The Media Essay

- The theoretical model I believe encapsulates the relationship between criminal justice and the media the best is the Hypodermic Syringe model because the public often believes and accepts the message the media is trying to send, which allows the media to have a direct effect on the behavior of the criminal justice system. This is exactly what the Hypodermic Syringe model is defined as. When the media has a new story, people automatically accept it as the way the news reported it and they spread the message around to anyone they can talk to....   [tags: Police, Crime, Criminal justice, Constable]

Better Essays
1696 words (4.8 pages)

Public Confidence Within The Criminal Justice System Essay

- In many western democratic countries, maintaining public confidence in judicial administration is regarded as a critical issue across the whole of government, especially in the criminal justice system. The judiciary consists of many organizations, such as police, the courts, prison service and correlations, that is centrally concerned with controlling crime and protecting community by the exercise of power (Snowball & Jones, 2012). However, a system fails to command public trust may also fail to establish its legitimacy and function effectively (Hough & Roberts, 2004 cited in Jones et al., 2008)....   [tags: Crime, Criminal justice, Police, Law]

Better Essays
2199 words (6.3 pages)

Essay about The Problems Within The Criminal Justice

- Many of us have ideas about different races and cultures before we meet anyone from that culture or race. Many of those ideas are shaped by what we see and hear in the media. The media is an easy place to get information so many people take that information, and do not further research the topics discussed. The media has made people believe that African Americans and other minorities are more involved in violent crime. The problem with media it that it also influences police officer’s opinions, and can change how they react to crimes (McNamara, 2009)....   [tags: Crime, Police, Race, Criminal justice]

Better Essays
1036 words (3 pages)

Criminal Justice Trends Essay

- The criminal justice system is a group of institutions that work together to protect a society, prevent and control crime, and maintain justice; enforcing the laws regulated by society. As the years have gone by and society has evolved; so have the criminal justice system and its methods to accomplish its role in society. This short analysis will evaluate the main facts that have been affecting the criminal justice system for decades and have influenced the evolution the justice system is enduring in a changing society (Muraski, 2009)....   [tags: Criminal Justice]

Better Essays
1561 words (4.5 pages)

The Crime Of The Criminal Justice System Essay

- Today in our society, the criminal justice system appears throughout mass media. Everyone can see crime by looking in magazines, newspapers, books, and watching television shows. The media in the past years has crossed a fine line between crime information and entertainment. This can be seen by shows like the People’s Court or Judge Judy. The amounts of criminal images that people come in contact with on a daily basis suggest or influence fear to people. From the late 1970’s where westerns were traded in for crime shows like Perry Mason and even today shows like COPS or Gangland....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Penology, Criminal law]

Better Essays
1169 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Gender And The Criminal Justice System

- Gender and the Criminal Justice System: The politics of labor in prisons has a large societal impact, and the gendering of this labor is just as critical. The way women are socialized in prisons reflects larger societal inequalities and problems. In comparing two radically different prisons, Haney (2010) illustrates the difficulty in viewing prison work as wholly exploitative or abusive, as they both reinforce and subvert the wide-ranging social meanings that can be ascribed to women’s work. The U.S....   [tags: Prison, Penology, Criminal justice]

Better Essays
1075 words (3.1 pages)