Media Discourse Involving First Nations Peoples Essay

Media Discourse Involving First Nations Peoples Essay

Length: 2002 words (5.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the article Media Discourse Involving First Nations Peoples by Frances Henry and Carol Tator, the authors attempt to convince their audience that Canadian English-Language print media are biased in their portrayal of Native Canadians. They attempt to do this by referencing two different cases in which First Nations peoples were involved in law suits. One involved an alleged sexual assault on a young Cree girl by a former Mountie, the other involved fishing rights of First Nations peoples. Although the authors analyze each newspaper article in depth, and thereby show that there is some bias through the use of stereotypes, Henry and Tator distort some of the evidence presented to make it sound in favor of their argument. As such, while their argument is deductively valid, it is unsound.
Media Discourse Involving First Nations People written by York University professors brings up a very serious topic concerning the discrimination of Native People in the Canadian press. The main point of their article is the fact that the majority of “white people’s newspapers” are biased toward Native Canadians. It is not of course as discriminative as it used to be, but the Canadian media in any of its manifestation still use certain stereotypes on the daily basis. The media, according to Tator and Henry, as a very strong manipulative tool, does give wrong ideas about Natives to the rest of the Canadian population. And they seem to have a lot of quite strong evidences for this topic. More particularly, the examples were taken from two major newspapers: The Globe and Mail and The National Post. The first one focuses on the case of sexual assault of a young women by Jack Ramsay, another one have a series of articles and editorials about fishi...


... middle of paper ...


...his at all. This confuses a lot while reading. Also, authors do use some definitions throughout the text, but they did not include this into references either. Technically, they refer only to the usage of a few articles and editorials from five newspapers, but even here, for some reason it appears that they presented each article with a wrong title. The majority of them exist in the archives under completely different titles than Tator and Henry made readers believe. This fact rises up a lot of questions about the reliability of the information. Again, authors make their argument very dubious by presenting neither footnotes, nor proper information. Readers left with the feeling that the whole paper was based solely on the personal opinion and experience of the authors which will not lead to anything good in the case when they attempting to show serious studies.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Western And Eurocentric Mentality Towards Indigenous Peoples Essay

- I worry that the western and Eurocentric mentality towards Indigenous peoples has not changed as much as we would like to say. Modern-day schools still ignore Indigenous ways and therefore, portray them as lesser and attempt to remove them. If Indigenous philosophies and pedagogies are not part of the curriculum (and not a sidebar or merely reflected if you look closely), then “this creates tensions and adjustment problems for students, which may contribute to high dropout rates (Schissel & Wotherspoon, 2003).” (Overmars, 2010, p....   [tags: Indigenous peoples, Indigenous Australians]

Powerful Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Decolonization and Indigenous Peoples of Canada

- First I will define the definition of terms used in this paper. When I use the word Aboriginal, I understand this as a label given from the colonizers/ Europeans to identify Indigenous peoples. Canadian legislation defines Indigenous peoples as Aboriginal, I understand this as indifferent from the dominant ideology, therefore, the colonizers named Indigenous peoples as Aboriginal. According to teachings I have been exposed to it’s a legal term and it’s associated with discrimination and oppression....   [tags: First Nation, Aborigine, discrimination opression]

Powerful Essays
2326 words (6.6 pages)

Essay about Conflict between Canada and the First Nations

- ... The men as well as the women were romanticized, where they fall in love with a white person and leave their own people for theirs. Media like this effects everyone, but the people who are most effected are the children. Both aboriginal and non-aboriginal children see these stereotypes in the media and it creates a false image of what reality really is. They will grow up believing these things and might feel bad about themselves and even begin to partake in things like gangs, drugs, alcohol, and abuse....   [tags: fight for equality, discrimmination]

Powerful Essays
1149 words (3.3 pages)

What Area Of Journalism Or Communication Studies Do You Think You Would Enjoy Learning More About?

-  1. What area of journalism or communication studies do you find particularly interesting and think you would enjoy learning more about. (simple statement) The area of communications that I find particularly interesting is mass media, and it’s role in developing opinions on disenfranchised groups of people and their struggles, especially the first nations. 2. Why do you find this topic interesting and important. (500 words) There are many interesting aspects of this, like what kinds of stories get published where, for example Aboriginal stories are generally much easier to come by in the Globe and Mail than they are in the Calgary Sun, and why stories in those papers would be much more lik...   [tags: First Nations, Aboriginal peoples in Canada]

Powerful Essays
1313 words (3.8 pages)

Favour We Were Children Questions Essay examples

- Name: Favour WE WERE CHILDREN QUESTIONS Initial thoughts. What do you think. When we first watched the movie, I was very prejudice, and had a small understanding of the cruelty in Residential schools. I had no idea such things were done to innocent children. Initially, I had a general thought of Aboriginals as I did with other people Historians, I believed they helped Canada. But now I see the significance in their lives more, and I see their sacrifices and sufferings in order to “assimilate” into Canadian society....   [tags: First Nations, Aboriginal peoples in Canada]

Powerful Essays
720 words (2.1 pages)

Analysis Of James Frideres Chapter On The Historical Roots Of Canadian Colonialism

- When someone has a mind frame that the world is neutral and everyone has the same opportunities, they develop a prejudice when looking at those in struggles and tend to put fault on the individual themselves. This is called blaming the victim. This occurs in many Aboriginal societies, it sees the problem as people as being solely responsible for their own issues, nobody takes on responsibility for institutional racism caused by cultural difference. One does this by glancing at society through a Micro or Individual approach, there are three levels to this approach....   [tags: Racism, Indigenous Australians, First Nations]

Powerful Essays
1174 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Nations Should Promote Globalization, Not Localization

- Globalization and localization are two conflicting trends in international politics today. Globalization is the spread of peoples, activities, norms, ideas, goods, services, and currencies from one area of the world to another. (Rosenau 15) Localization is the narrowing of horizons and the confinement of peoples, activities, norms, ideas, goods, services, and currencies to a particular geographic area. (Rosenau 16) Globalization and localization affect the world’s countries in three main areas, politics, economics, and culture....   [tags: Globalization vs Localization]

Powerful Essays
1079 words (3.1 pages)

Residential Schools On First Nations Children Essay

- During the late 1800s and early 1990s, over 100,000 First Nations children in Canada attended residential schools. At the schools, the children were subjected to emotional, physical, and profound sexual abuse. This led to children growing up without any recollection of whom their families were. Furthermore, they were isolated from both their cultural and spiritual roots. The course of action was to teach the Natives as young children, so that once they became adults, they would run with the Jesuits back to their gathering and help the clergymen with teaching the Nation....   [tags: First Nations, Aboriginal peoples in Canada]

Powerful Essays
1001 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Red Rising Magazine By Kevin Settee

- Red Rising Magazine is a grassroots magazine started by a group of Aboriginal young people and Aboriginal allies living in Winnipeg. In a presentation by Kevin Settee, one of the creators of the Magazine, he shared his disappointment and anger about how he saw Aboriginal peoples portrayed in the media and his own interactions with the media (Settee, personal communication, September 17, 2015). He and his friends desired to publish a magazine that counters the media’s portrayal of Aboriginal peoples by portraying them accurately (Larrivee)....   [tags: Indigenous peoples, Indigenous Australians]

Powerful Essays
1039 words (3 pages)

Essay about The Role of the Media in Australia

- The Role of the Media in Australia Osborne and Lewis state that [a] preeminent theme in Australian thinking about the use of communication is the extent to which it has been viewed as a form of control. There has been concern in recent times of the enormous power communication holds as an agent of societal control. This is due to a number of factors, such the media mogul dominated media, which promotes a very conservative view and does not allow for alternate opinions to be voiced. The wide-reaching capabilities of the media, particularly electronic media via the Internet allows for the influence to spread across the entire country to remote areas and therefore heightens a sense of societal...   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
2453 words (7 pages)