“No-no. There be no unnatural case here.” (Parris, The Crucible Act 1 Line 34) The Crucible is a play written by Arthur Miller about the Salem Witch Trials. Miller wrote this play as a critique of McCarthyism, but distanced it by using the Salem Witch Trials as the setting. McCarthyism is the practice of making accusations of treason without proper evidence. Using the Trials as the setting has strong suits, such as allowing him to compare McCarthyism indirectly and the events related strongly with society, and weaknesses, including the time period being so long-standing that it is not a modern example in their era and the idea of witches is farfetched compared to Communism.
Allowing Miller to relate McCarthyism in a roundabout approach is a huge strength of using this situation. “I would say, you know, McCarthy is actually saying certain lines that I recall the witch hunters saying in Salem.” (Arthur Miller, The Telegraph) In The Crucible, people were going wild to find out everyone who was or could have been witches. Similarly, America was trying to find anyone who could have been a Communists sympathizer. This quote is equating the way McCarthy talked about finding possible Communists to the way the Salem witch hunters talked about witches. There is also a significant parallel between the characters in this play and Americans involved with the hunt for Communists. For example, Abigail Williams could be compared to Joseph McCarthy in that they were the driving force of accusing others. They also had no evidence for accusing. The girls in Salem had no proof of the countless accusations, much like McCarthy with his claims of Communists infiltrating the United States. Miller linking the two is a major asset to using Salem as the...
... middle of paper ...
...ure. Nonetheless, the search for witches is associated with the devil and religion. Americanism is more of an accepted concept than witches. The knowledge of witches being nonexistent makes this comparison seem unbelievable and a weak point of the setting.
The Salem Witch Trials as the setting for The Crucible as a critique of McCarthyism has weaknesses, like the farfetched idea of witches and the time period being so far away, and strengths, such as indirectly comparing the two and relating to society. Witches seemed incomparable to Communists then and the difference in time periods was plenty. He could indirectly compare the trials to McCarthyism through the search for witches and it was relatable to events in society then. These reasons provide examples of the advantages and disadvantages to have the Salem Witch Trials as the setting for a critique of McCarthyism.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- “No-no. There be no unnatural case here.” (Parris, The Crucible Act 1 Line 34) The Crucible is a play written by Arthur Miller about the Salem Witch Trials. Miller wrote this play as a critique of McCarthyism, but distanced it by using the Salem Witch Trials as the setting. McCarthyism is the practice of making accusations of treason without proper evidence. Using the Trials as the setting has strong suits, such as allowing him to compare McCarthyism indirectly and the events related strongly with society, and weaknesses, including the time period being so long-standing that it is not a modern example in their era and the idea of witches is farfetched compared to Communism.... [tags: Salem witch trials, The Crucible, McCarthyism]
895 words (2.6 pages)
- McCarthyism Within The Crucible As stated in a 1952 New York Times article, “if we lose our freedom in the effort to guard our security, then security is useless” (Oakes 5). The United States of America is a country with a history of always protecting its citizens’ rights and liberties, but it also contains a past where other matters interferred. There are many contributing factors that can alter a person’s perspective on a particular idea such as religious views, or fear. In 1692, Puritan Salem, Massachusetts believed there were witches within the town after girls in the town confessed they had been victims of witchcraft.... [tags: Salem witch trials, The Crucible, McCarthyism]
1539 words (4.4 pages)
- In the 1950s, Arthur Miller was accused of being a sympathizer to communism, and was one of the three hundred and twenty artists blacklisted by Congress (Arthur Miller: McCarthyism). Arthur Miller was angered by the accusations without evidence to back them up, and hit a boiling point after famed director Elia Kazan went in front of House Un-American Activities Committee and named some of his peers as communist sympathizers (Arthur Miller: McCarthyism). After a meeting with Kazan to discuss why he did what he did, a tumultuous relationship between the direction and playwright began, and Miller began research on the Salem witch trials (Fisher 255).... [tags: injustice, unfair trails, communism]
1395 words (4 pages)
- Authors used their literary work to get a point across to the public in the story The Crucible; Arthur Miller used events and characters to show the similarities to McCarthyism which was prevalent in the 1950s. McCarthyism was associated with the period in the United Sates also known as the Second Red Scare. McCarthyism is very similar in the way that Joe McCarthy accused Americans of being communist and in The Crucible people were being accused of being witches. It is known that Arthur Miller wrote this story as a reaction to a tragic time in our history.... [tags: Compare/Contrast, Communism]
457 words (1.3 pages)
- They want to destroy private enterprise and white supremacy’” (qtd. Williamson-Lott 884). The mistreatment of African Americans in connection with communism did strong nationalists a disfavor when many actual Communists won black followers by advocating “civil and social equality,” which only pushed the prejudiced into believing that if the communism succeeded, so would an end to white supremacy (Williamson-Lott 882-883). Like the racist public of the South, the whole town of Salem was in uproar over the witch hunt, but it was the individuals charged that had the most to worry about.... [tags: white supremacy, communism]
1467 words (4.2 pages)
- In 1692, a group of girls living in Salem Massachusetts fell ill. Suffering from seizures and hallucinations, in extremely religious Puritan New England, the only cause seemed to be the work of the devil or his servants. The sickness ignited fears of witchcraft, and it was only a matter of time until not only the girls, but many other residents of Salem, started accusing other villagers of conspiring with the devil, and casting dark magic. By the August of 1962, nineteen people were executed by the Massachusetts government and judicial system, who were heavily influenced by religion.... [tags: communists, allegory, witch trials]
662 words (1.9 pages)
- “I visited Salem for the first time on a dismal spring day in 1952….” (Miller 1095) that’s what started it all. Arthur Miller was motivated to write The Crucible due to the trauma done to the liberals during the McCarthyism trials. The question is, was he a little too motivated to write it. Could his thirst for vengeance for those accused fuel him to over-exaggerate what happened in order to prove a point. Arthur Miller overused his artistic license because Joseph McCarthy was accusing important people of being communists, he wasn’t exactly like Danforth, and some of the accused in the McCarthyism trials were actual communists.... [tags: communists, trial, vendetta]
516 words (1.5 pages)
- Telling lies, making false accusations, having suspicion, betraying others and creating fear in others are just some of the factors that caused McCarthyism in the United States. Named after Joseph McCarthy, McCarthyism is the false accusation of someone being a communist. Numerous playwrights are recognized as an allegory for McCarthyism. Arthur Miller, born in 1915, was one of America’s greatest writers for his diversity, his courage, and the influence that he has made on readers all around the world.... [tags: Communism, Play]
672 words (1.9 pages)
- The play “The Crucible”, written by Arthur Miller, used The Salem Witch Hunt trials as an allegory of the McCarthy hearings and the true horrors behind how America dealt with attempted Communism. Tension is evident throughout the play, and each character participates in intensifying it which entangles them into the extreme consequences of the tension they helped to circulate. The significance of Salem is that the tension can be sourced from within every character as they are engulfed in hidden and publically known feuds.... [tags: Essay on The Crucible 2014]
2025 words (5.8 pages)
- "Reasonable doubt" was all that was necessary to accuse and sometimes convict someone of un-American activities in the late 1940's, early 1950's. This period of time was known for McCarthyism--a time of extreme anticommunism, lead by Senator Joseph McCarthy (McCarthyism). The United States pledged to contain the spread of communism globally, as well as locally, and did what it could to keep this promise. Americans began to fear that communism was leaking into the media, government, arts, schools, and other areas.... [tags: Compare Contrast Papers]
1171 words (3.3 pages)