Essay about Mary Stuart Was a Good Queen in Scotland: How about England?

Essay about Mary Stuart Was a Good Queen in Scotland: How about England?

Length: 1119 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the 1500s, many great Kings and Queen existed of whom a few will go down in history as some of the greatest leaders of all time. Elizabeth I being the queen of England during 1533-1603 and Mary Stuart ruling Scotland for the years of 1542-1567, Mary Stuart was always eager to take Elizabeth I’s spot, and she was always trying to find new ways to try to take the throne. Yet, if Mary Stuart was successful in taking the throne would she be a good queen? Although Mary Stuart was educated and had strong views on religion she was emotionally unstable, she showed neglect to her country, and had a terrible relationship with the people of Scotland showing that she would be unable to reign as queen of England.
Mary’s strong view on religion came mainly from being born in a time filled with religious turmoil. She was raised with many things going on around her which affected her view and stance of religion tremendously. Mary was a strong Catholic and did not budge about what she believed in. Her strong beliefs led to many assassination attempts toward her from the Protestants. This happened because Mary, the Catholic queen, had the support of all the Catholics in England so at any time they could rise up against Protestants. Also many Catholics tried to assassinate Elizabeth I because of the same reasons the public were attacking Mary just vice versa because Elizabeth was a Protestant queen. Also not only was Mary a threat because she had the support of the Catholic population in England, she also had the support of the Pope (Trueman). Being Catholic and having the help of the pope showed that choosing one side, and sticking with it, of the religious battle can have many positive effects on trying to take the throne. Many Protestants fea...

... middle of paper ...

...raits are brought up she is compared to Elizabeth I so Mary Stuart was a bad queen but was it doubly noticeable when living in the same age as, the great, Elizabeth I.

Works Cited

Grendler, Paul F. "Mary Stuart." Encyclopedia of the Renaissance. Ed. Grendler. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 2000. N. pag. World History in Context. Web. 17 Mar. 2014. .
"Mary, Queen of Scots." Encyclopedia of World Biography. Detroit: Gale, 1998. N. pag. World History in Context. Web. 17 Mar. 2014. .
"The Scottish Itinerary of Mary Queen of Scots." Abstract (1987): n. pag. PDF file.
Trueman, Chris. "Mary Queen of Scots." History Learning Site. History Learning Site, n.d. Web. 2 Apr. 2014. .
Weir, Alison. Mary, Queen of Scots, and the Murder of Lord Darnley. N.p.: Ballantine, 2004. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Mary Stuart, Queen of Scots Essay

- Mary Stuart, Queen of Scots She became queen when she was only 6 days old. She was sent to France at age six to get married. She is the cousin of Queen Elizabeth I. Who is this elegant, yet struggling woman. Mary Stuart, Queen of Scotland. Beautiful and brave, Mary Stuart was known for being the Queen of Scotland, France, and was in line for the throne of England and she was also considered the true queen of England. Mary Stuart was born on December 8, 1542, in Lithingow Palace, Scotland. She was the daughter of King James V of Scotland and Mary of Guise....   [tags: Biography]

Powerful Essays
1110 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Queen Elizabeth : The Queen Of England

- Queen Elizabeth was born on September 7, 1533 in Greenwich, United Kingdom. ( The queen was recognized most by her nickname “The Virgin Queen.” Elizabeth I was the long filling queen of England, the Elizabethan era is actually named after her. Elizabeth governed with relative stability and prosperity for 44 years. ( In Elizabeth 's early life she was a princess, but declared illegitimate through political machinations. She was perhaps England 's most famous monarch, but grew up in complex and sometimes difficult circumstances....   [tags: Elizabeth I of England, Mary I of England]

Powerful Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

A Royal Catfight: The Battle Between Queen Elizabeth I and Queen Mary Stuart

- The reign of Queen Elizabeth I was known as the Elizabethan Age. At this time, the Renaissance had spread to England. As a ruler, she was well educated, speaking about four different languages (Beck 963). However, it was not just her knowledge that made her into a popular monarch. Her personality helped her to become a successful politician as well. In a documentary about Queen Elizabeth I, it was stated, “She was vain, spiteful, arrogant. She was frequently unjust, and she was often maddeningly undecisive....   [tags: british royalty, history]

Powerful Essays
1473 words (4.2 pages)

Biography of Queen Elizabeth Essay

- Queen Elizabeth I. Introduction Queen Elizabeth had never married, and remained as the virgin queen throughout the many years of her ruling. According to Judith Richards, Queen Elizabeth was the youngest sibling of several others in her family. Queen Elizabeth I of was born in fifteen thousand fifty three in Greenwich and was also born in England. In the amount of bills that were created on few were passed to become laws for England (R.E Foster). Doctor Simon Adams states that Queen Elizabeth had full control of the second half of the sixteenth century....   [tags: virgin queen, golden age, catholics]

Powerful Essays
1106 words (3.2 pages)

Mary, Queen of Scots by Gordon Donaldson Essay

- The biography that is being reviewed is Mary, Queen of Scots by Gordon Donaldson. Mary Stuart, was born at Linlithge Palace on December 8, 1542, sixs days later she became Queen of Scotland. Mary became Queen of France and soon her greediness grew and she wanted to take over England. Mary was unwilling to stay in France, so she went back to Scotland. There her second husband died and she was imprisoned in England for the suspicion of the murder. Mary had a bad ending to her life. Mary got caught in attempting an assassination of Queen Elizabeth for which she was beheaded on February 8, 1587....   [tags: Mary, Queen of Scots Gordon Donaldson]

Powerful Essays
1753 words (5 pages)

Essay about Mary Queen of Scots

- During the 1500’s war and sickness were common. War alone took many men including Mary Stuarts father, James V, who was unable to accept the humiliation of his defeat against England and underwent a complete nervous breakdown (Fraser, 11). Previously two of Mary’s older brothers died in infancy only adding to James V’s sorrow which Mary’s birth did not even begin to alleviate (Fraser, 11). Five days following Mary’s birth King James V of Scotland died. Mary Stuart Was crowned as the Queen of Scotland within a year of her birth and though she tried her hardest to be a great leader, many things obstructed her path....   [tags: War, England, English History]

Powerful Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)

Queen Elizabeth, One of England´s Most Influential Leaders Essay

- Queen Elizabeth had a hectic childhood which was the key in Establishing her determined nature, which helped her later to return England to its previous position of power. This determination was vital for Elizabeth to become a successful queen in a male-dominated world. During the 16th century, women were not equivalent to men. Women were rarely educated and had only a few rights. The woman basically got marry and had children, or had simple jobs. Certainly, they were viewed as weak individuals and inferior to men....   [tags: England, women rights, royalty]

Powerful Essays
862 words (2.5 pages)

Queen Elizabeth Essay example

- Her father and mother where King Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn and had one brother and sister, Edward and Mary. But Queen Elizabeth had troubles of her own. She was abandoned by her own father, locked away by her own sister, but that didn’t stop her to become the greatest queen we know. Elizabeth father had some crimes on his own. When Elizabeth was only three he beheaded her mother, Anne Boleyn because she did not give him a baby boy; she gave birth to a girl. Soon after Elizabeth wasn’t raised in a palace with her father she was sent away....   [tags: Queen Elizabeth Essays]

Free Essays
924 words (2.6 pages)

Uniting Scotland and England Essay

- Most Queens have dramatic and scandalous events happen in their lives, as well as accomplishments. Mary, Queen of Scots had many of both of these things and a big accomplishment. Before she was even two years old, a war had started because of her. Her biggest accomplishment was giving birth to her son because it resulted in the union of Scotland and England. Even though this might sound interesting, she lived a short and tragic but memorable life. Mary is known by many different names. She is known as Mary Stuart, Mary I, Mary Stewart, Queen Mary, Queen Mary I, and her full name Mary, Queen of Scots (“Bio”)....   [tags: mary queen of scots, life, church]

Powerful Essays
1057 words (3 pages)

Queen Elizabeth Essay

- Queen Elizabeth I Queen Elizabeth, the first, proved to be a very good and loyal monarch to England. She brought about many changes, both good and bad. On September 7, 1533 a baby girl came into the world. Back then many parents would have been greatly disappointed to have had a baby girl, rather then a boy. However these parents were glad by the birth of their first child together. These proud parents were the king and queen of England, King Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn. The girl child was named Elizabeth....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
1231 words (3.5 pages)