If humans were living in a state of nature, according to Marx, are naturally drawn to one another because our collective nature is more important than our individual nature. In living in nature and trying to survive we are required to make something out of our surroundings. In essence humans produce a material world out of nature and here is where we differ from the animals. “But an animal only produces what it immediately needs for itself or its young. It produces one-sidedly, whilst man produces universally.” (266) Humans have a propensity to create more things than we need simply because we like to make things. We value ourselves as producers because it sets us apart and it demonstrates that we are free thinking. Also what we produce gives us a concept of ourselves, meaning that we can see ourselves in what we make. “Thus it is quite obvious from the start that there exists a materialistic connection of men with one another, which is determined by their needs and their mode of production and which is as old as men themselves.” (273) For as long as humans have been around we have been producing things. That production leads to connection because it shows that all of humanity has something in common. That we are all un...
... middle of paper ...
...ary in a communist world. All that matters to communism is the collective, not the individual.
This causes me to think that Marx’s view of human nature isn’t correct, or at the very least isn’t complete. I believe that while humanity may be drawn to communities, we also value individuality. Marx puts too much emphasis on community in saying that human nature is a collective thing and not an individual one. Individuality and creative thinking is how societies progress and how new discoveries are made. If every single person simply works for the common good then nothing of that sort is going to happen. Communism and thinking that our base nature is collective limits people in what they can accomplish. I believe that it would create resentment in how restrictive it is.
Loptson, Peter. Readings on Human Nature. Peterborough, Ont.: Broadview, 1998. Print.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Understanding Marxist Historiography: An Overview Wherever one stands on the ideological scale, it is hard to refute the influence Karl Marx, and his subsequent theories and doctrines, have had on the world at large. Some, like Vladimir Lenin, took Marx’s ideals and turned it into a political party and system of government, while others, like Mao Zedong, have simply used it as a basic foundation to further their own ideological and political ambitions. But in its truest essence, based on the writings and subsequent comments made by Marx and others, Marxism is a view of the world, offering both resources to scholars and laymen alike.... [tags: Communism]
741 words (2.1 pages)
- A definition, by way of contrast, of the key features of Marxism and functionalism will precede an application of each theory in turn to health. Functionalism developed out of the positivist observation that 'all positive speculations owe their first origin to the occupations of practical life' (Comte, 1865, pg 11) and the boundaries of scientific knowledge can not go further than empirically observable truths and views societies as holistic systems where 'the whole is greater than the sum of its parts' (Taylor et el, 1997, pg 662).... [tags: Health Care]
1031 words (2.9 pages)
- The Wars written by Timothy Findley shares a great relation to many of the ideas surrounding postmodern society, thus implementing many of the prominent ideas of the time around politics and societal norms into the plot of the story itself. Findley successfully depicts the plot of the novel taking place in the early 1900's; a time in which the western world was emerging from an industrial revolution, bringing radically foreign ideas on politics in the world, including the materialization of the Marxist political theory.... [tags: theory, economic, revolution]
1907 words (5.4 pages)
- Hamlet by William Shakespeare is one of the most complex plays in the English language. By approaching Hamlet from different perspectives, one can come to realize the subtle meanings interworked with this entertaining play. Two such perspectives are the Marxist view and the deconstructionist view. Marxism refers to the plays social impact and ability to undercut the foundations of government; deconstructionism attempts to show the inability of language to support the intricacies of human life. Hamlet is the tale of Denmark’s royalty and the “tragedy” that struck the Prince of Denmark, the play’s namesake, Hamlet.... [tags: Critical Approach, Shakespeare]
951 words (2.7 pages)
- A Marxist Reading of Native Son In the Communist Manifesto Karl Marx states clearly that history is a series of class struggles over the means of production. Whoever controls the means of production also controls society and is able to force their set of ideas and beliefs onto the lower class. The present dominant class ideology is, as it has been since the writing of the United States Constitution, the ideology of the upper-class, Anglo-Saxon male. Obviously, when the framers spoke of equality for all, they meant for all land-owning white men.... [tags: Native Son Essays]
4812 words (13.7 pages)
- ... Marx applies this theory on issues of production, the powers of production and the ideology of the organizational structure. Marx’s theory deduces how all labor purposes, exploitation and alienation of the proletariat was all aimed at maximizing output and profits by generating more capital. The capital owners would try to justify their materialistic ways but Marx worked at exposing them all in the name of bringing dignity and equality among all (Leszek, 1985). Marx did make predictions of what would come about from industrial revolution which would be the loss of employability of the proletariat due to technology being introduced in industries.... [tags: promoting equality among society]
1444 words (4.1 pages)
- Marxist Locke Karl Marx and John Locke both place a great deal of importance in both labour and property in discussing their political philosophies. At first glance, the two thinkers seem to possess completely different ideas on property, its importance, and the form of society which should grow from it. The disparity in their beliefs is evident, but they share a similar approach to labour and acceptable conditions while constructing philosophies which inherently attack each other. Locke’s suggestion that capitalism is a natural political progression can only be accomplished when the worker himself becomes a commodity to be traded, a transformation which Marx identifies as a major problem... [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Essays]
2535 words (7.2 pages)
- Although there is a strong diverse controversy tied with the name of Karl Marx, he was concerned primarily with human freedom, stimulating the ancient concept of Communism, in which human beings might fulfill their cooperative roles within society, without the fear of exploitation. He saw the historical period of capitalism as the "menacing" antagonist of such freedom; menacing because unlike serfdom (the predecessor of capitalism in the evolution of social relations), capitalism enabled the illusion of freedom even though it relied on those who have nothing to sell but their labor and those, who through the power of capital and property, exploit such labor for profit.... [tags: Philosophy]
2238 words (6.4 pages)
- There are many theories on why crime exists as well has who is committing the crimes and the underlying reasons behind it The two main perspectives being Traditional Marxist and Functionalist both with different views they share very little in common, however they do agree that society shapes the individual and not the individual that shapes society. What is meant by that is that we are all products of our upbringings and learn through socialisation what our beliefs are, what we agree on personally and often shared beliefs and the understanding of what is 'the norm; through our primary interaction with others beginning at home and continuing onto schooling and w... [tags: Compare Contrast Nature Nurture Essays Crime ]
2326 words (6.6 pages)
- While literary critics do attempt to elaborate or develop ideas articulated by Karl Marx, it is important and necessary to make a distinction between Marx's specific socio-economic and political agenda and the body of literary theory which emerged years later. Marxist literary criticism proceeds from the fundamental philosophical assumption that "consciousness can never be anything else than conscious existence...Life is not determined by consciousness, but consciousness by life" (Marx 568-9).... [tags: Literature Essays Literary Criticism]
460 words (1.3 pages)