The first proposal from Jane Austen 's Pride and Prejudice demonstrates the use of marriage as mainly a method to further one 's social standing regardless of the love involved. Throughout the proposal, Mr. Collins has weak and ineffective arguments, incorrect assumptions, a pompous and degrading attitude, and unorganized and flustered diction. Mr. Collins begins his proposal poorly when he lists his "reasons for marrying (Austen 1)." He states it is his duty to set an example as a clergyman, marriage will make him happy, and lastly, Lady Catherine de Bourgh, his patroness, believes he should marry. This exemplifies marriage as solely a social device because Mr. Collins is only proposing because he feels obligated to satisfy what society and Lady Catherine expect of him. Even his assumptions have social aspects to them. Mr. Colin 's assumes that because of his connection to Lady Catherine women will want to marry him to enhance their social status; however, that is assuming the woman he is proposing to knows of Lady Catherine and would value her ...
... middle of paper ...
...s. The differing arguments, assumptions, attitudes, and diction used by the men in these two novels demonstrate the shift in social views of marriage. While Mr. Collins’s proposal from Austen’s novel embodies the belief of marriage as a social device, the proposal in Dickens’s novel embodies the romantic and more modern view of marriage as the intimate and passionate action it is. “You know what I am going to say. I love you. What other men may mean when they use this expression, I cannot tell; what / mean is that I am under the influence of some tremendous attraction which I have resisted in vain and which overmasters me (Dickens 1-5).” The man in Dickens’s classic proved this statement to be sincere through his arguments, attitudes, assumptions, and diction used throughout the proposal while all Mr. Collins proved was his dedication to Lady Catherine and society.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- A Comparison of Charles Dickens and Jane Austen ADVANCED ENGLISH LANGUAGE ESSAY Of the many authors to emerge during the nineteenth-century, Charles Dickens and Jane Austen were among the few who would make a lasting impression on the literary world for generations. Hard Times, often referred to as Dickens’ ‘Industrial novel’ and Austen’s Pride and Prejudice have been much read and well-loved classics for many years. It is the purpose of this essay to compare and contrast the different worlds depicted in both Hard Times and Pride and Prejudice.... [tags: English Literature]
2442 words (7 pages)
- Throughout the early 1800s, British women often played a subordinate role in society, flexed by many obligations, laws, and the superior males. A young woman’s struggle for independence and free will can often be compared to a life of servitude and slavery. Women were often controlled by the various men in their lives; whether it be father, brother or the eventual husband. Marriage during this time was often a gamble; one can either be in it for the right reasons such as love or for the wrong reasons such as advancing social status.... [tags: Jave Austen]
1688 words (4.8 pages)
- Charles Dickens was one of the best writers of his time in light of the fact that his composition was not at all like anything anybody had ever seen. He utilized his own backgrounds and consolidated them into his books. Charles John Huffam Dickens was conceived on February seventh in 1812. His guardians were John and Elizabeth Dickens. Charles ' initial youth was a fairly harsh one in light of the fact that his father was sent to imprison on account of his obligation. After his father went to prison his mom did not have enough cash to keep him in school so at twelve years old he began working in an industrial facility (Warren 's Blacking Factory).... [tags: Charles Dickens, A Christmas Carol]
1727 words (4.9 pages)
- Hard Times Charles Dickens was known to be very controversial and outspoken in his books and Hard Times was no exception. Hard Times takes place in the industrial-centered city of Coketown, England where Dickens’ clearly attempts to expose the massive inequality between economic/social classes as well as the outright narcissism of the middle to upper classes who are only concerned with making a profit in the most practical/efficient way. Charles Dickens is in no way subtle throughout this book and attempted to repeat his main theme constantly in order for the reader to quickly understand what was trying to be said.... [tags: Hard Times, Charles Dickens, Gradgrind]
1146 words (3.3 pages)
- A FEW NOTES ABOUT THE AUTHOR CHARLES DICKENS DICKENS, Charles (1812-70). On a pier in New York Harbor in 1841 a crowd watched a tall sailing ship from England being towed to the pierhead. There was no ocean communication cable as yet and the ship brought the latest news. A question was yelled from the pier to the ship: "Is Little Nell dead?" Little Nell was the heroine in a serial called 'Old Curiosity Shop '. The latest installment was on the ship, and the people were anxious to learn how the story came out.... [tags: Charles Dickens, The Pickwick Papers]
1129 words (3.2 pages)
- Hard Times by Charles Dickens is a book that dives into the world of Coketown, a fictional town that has a lot of interesting characters. Each character gives you a unique perspective towards any situation that happens in the book. Whether Mr. Gradgrind is shoving facts down your throat or Mr. Boundarby boasting about his rise to riches; the novel will keep you wanting more. With that said, Hard Times makes you feel different emotions. I know that when I was reading the novel I felt angry, sad, joyful, and was honestly relieved towards the end of it.... [tags: Hard Times, Charles Dickens, Gradgrind, Family]
1341 words (3.8 pages)
- The Fiction and Journalism of Charles Dickens Readers of Charles Dickens' journalism will recognize many of the author's themes as common to his novels. Certainly, Dickens addresses his fascination with the criminal underground, his sympathy for the poor, especially children, and his interest in the penal system in both his novels and his essays. The two genres allow the author to address these matters with different approaches, though with similar ends in mind. Two key differences exist, however, between the author's novels and his journalism.... [tags: Charles Dickens]
4560 words (13 pages)
- Charles Dickens' Hard Times There are a huge variety of characters in Hard Times, ranging from the good to the unnaturally cruel. The novel is full of extremity in its characterisation; cruel, bitter and selfish characters such as Mrs. Sparsit contrast dramatically with characters such as Stephen Blackpool and Rachael, who are benevolent and altruistic. Among the cruellest and most villainous characters in the novel is James Harthouse, who is completely ammoral, and therefore rendered very dangerous by Dickens.... [tags: Charles Dickens Hard Times Essays]
1104 words (3.2 pages)
- Charles Dickens' Hard Times Charles Dickens’s novel Hard Times critiques the use of extreme utilitarianism as an acceptable means to governing a society in which citizens are able to lead happy, productive, flourishing lives. “Just the facts,”19th century English utilitarianism argued, are all one needs to flourish. Those answers that we can arrive at by way of mathematical, logical reasoning are all needed to live a full human life. Hard Times shows however that a “just the facts” philosophy creates a community inhospitable to the needs of one another, a society nearly void of human compassion, and one lacking in morality.... [tags: Charles Dickens Hard Times Essays]
1105 words (3.2 pages)
- Charles Dickens Charles John Huffam Dickens was born February 7, 1812, in Ports Mouth, Hampshire. In his infancy his family moved to Chatham, where he spent his happiest years and often refers to this time in his novels (1817-1822). From 1822 to 1860 he lived in London, after which he permanently moved to a quiet country cottage in Glads Hill, on the outskirts of Chatham. He grew up in a middle class family. His father was a clerk in the navy pay office and was well paid, but his extravagant living style often brought the family to financial disaster.... [tags: Biography Charles Dickens Papers]
2088 words (6 pages)