The Many Sides of Dr. Melvin R. McGinnis Essay

The Many Sides of Dr. Melvin R. McGinnis Essay

Length: 1483 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Raymond Carver's short story “What We Talk About When We Talk About Love” leaves the reader feeling as if they have sat down at the table with a bottle of Gin and experienced first hand the effects of alcoholism and depression. In the original version of this story the “Beginners” Carver carefully crafts the many sides of an alcoholic personality developing strong knowable characters. The fundamental personalities are left fairly intact from the original version. It should be noted that the feelings that the reader are left with are due at least partially to the severe editing of the “Beginners” done by his editor and friend Gordon Lish. With this collaboration Carvers personal struggles still shine through but his intent of hope and recover from alcoholism were left mostly on the chopping block. Through many interviews and articles Raymond Carver make clear his personal struggles with alcoholism and how it has had an effect on his writing. INTERVIEWER: Where do your stories come from, then? I'm especially asking about the stories that have something to do with drinking. Carver: “At the very least it's referential. Stories long or short don't just come out of thin air.” (The Paris Review) The inner dialog and downward spiral of an alcoholic is experienced through the interaction between these personalities while discussing the topic of love. JA: I noticed recently you're using cliches in your characterizations, and I wonder if you're just observing, or recording the way a mind works. RC: It's there for a purpose; it's working for me, I think, not against me. Or at least I hope and assume this is the case!
Nick is the narrator and observer of the story. The only information about him is that he is Mels best friend, Laura...


... middle of paper ...


...imately failing to do so. Maybe there is a gem that you hold up as a standard for what you are looking for. Carver never describes self love, maybe it is left out because that is the elusive love the Mel McGinnis is struggling to find and in this story at least fails to find. Finding only self hate instead. The last two sentences suggest this story could be about anyone including yourself. “I could hear my heart beating. I could hear everyone’s heart. I could hear the human noise we sat there making, not one of us moving, not even when the room went dark.” “What creates tension in a piece of fiction is partly the way the concrete words are linked together to make up the visible action of the story. But it's also the things that are left out, that are implied, the landscape just under the smooth (but sometimes broken and unsettled) surface of things.: (ShopTalk)

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Choosing Sides: Being a Child of Divorced Parents Essays

- “Hey Alexander, I have a question to ask you. Have you ever considered living with me?” These are the words that my dad spoke to me on a scorching June day in 2005. I was paralyzed, not knowing quite how to respond to the question. The question was not shocking to me; my dad had hinted it for a while. What I did not know, however, was that this question was going to impact my life. Divorce is an awful thing. One of the only things worse is being a child of divorced parents. The concept that my parents no longer wanted to be with each other was heart-breaking to me....   [tags: divorce, parents, kids, sides]

Powerful Essays
675 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Powers And Mcginnis

- Powers and McGinnis: Love Leads to Death In 1900, the homicide rate in the United States of America was 3.4% and it increased to 10.1% in 1923 (Mortality Statistics). The United States was undergoing a change in lifestyle and culture during the 1920s with the idea of “flappers”, prohibition, and female empowerment. Chicago was no exception to this change in culture and increase in homicides. Chicago had its fair share of homicides in the city and two homicide victims that stood out the most were Alice Powers and Michael McGinnis....   [tags: Murder, Homicide, Crime of passion]

Powerful Essays
1681 words (4.8 pages)

As Good As It Gets By Melvin Udall Essay

- As Good as It Gets Melvin Udall is a successful author who lives the life of a recluse. All the neighbors in his Greenwich Village apartment building avoid him like the plague. He is a cantankerous bigoted, homophobic, dog hating, racist jerk. who does not care much for people any more than they care for him. Melvin, diagnosed with OCD (obsessive-compulsive disorder), avoids stepping on sidewalk cracks and touching other people, wears gloves, wipes off door handles, has to eat at the same restaurant every day, sit at the same table, insist on the same waitress Carol, and always orders the same meal....   [tags: Psychology, Anxiety]

Powerful Essays
1523 words (4.4 pages)

The Movie, As Good As It Gets, By Melvin Udall Essay

- The movie, As Good As It Gets, is about a romance novelist, Melvin Udall. He is grumpy, rude and has absolutely no empathy. He also has Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). The movie is based in New York City, and the plot is based around three people, Melvin, Carol, a single mother and waitress, and Simon, a self-supporting artist, who all come together and become unlikely friends. The character I felt the most interested in analyzing is Melvin Udall. I think OCD is a very interesting, yet complex disorder, so I thought he would be the perfect character to look more into....   [tags: Body dysmorphic disorder, Psychiatry]

Powerful Essays
1152 words (3.3 pages)

Melvin B. Tolson : An African American Modernist Poet Essay

- Melvin B. Tolson was an African American modernist poet. Tolson is compared to the likes of Langston Hughes, Ralph Ellison and Gwendolyn Brooks, some of the biggest names in African American literature during the realism, naturalism and modernist era. Melvin B. Tolson was born February 6th although his true birth year is unknown. Tolson was raised in a Methodist Episcopal church and his family moved around quite a bit. Beginning his career very young, Tolson’s first poem was published at the age of 14 in the local newspaper....   [tags: Black people, African American, White people]

Powerful Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about The Two Sides

- The Two Sides The views we have are what shapes us, sometimes we have vast knowledge of ideas. Other times we are limited in what we can understand. We are given the choice of seeking out more of said idea or choosing to remain as is. Cathedral by Raymond Carver is a story that gives us a look into what it is like to have our views challenged through experiencing them first hand. We are introduced to the story by narration and we are given a brief summary of how his wife and the blind man had met from the narrrator....   [tags: Cathedral, Raymond Carver, assumption, blindness]

Powerful Essays
1376 words (3.9 pages)

Escape from Reality: Melvin Burgess's Smack versus Holly Black's Valiant

- Escaping from reality is something that most humans desire. Some people cannot handle their existence and they revert to drugs or self-destruction as a way to escape for a short time or even permanently. In Smack by Melvin Burgess and Valiant by Holly Black, the main characters try to escape their reality through drugs and self-destruction. Teenagers need an outlet of hope when there is none in an endless sea of darkness. Valiant arguably offers a more hopeful outcome for young adults because of its message, character depth and likeability while Smack offers no hope for its far-fetched characters and oftentimes over-the-top storyline....   [tags: drug abuse, character analysis]

Powerful Essays
1352 words (3.9 pages)

Taking Sides: Inclusion Essay

- Taking Sides: Inclusion According to Stout (2001) the concept of inclusion can be differentiated into mainstreaming, inclusion and full inclusion each describing the amount of time special education students become part of a normal education classes. “Inclusion is a term which expresses the commitment to educate each child, to the maximum extent possible, in the school and classroom he or she would otherwise attend” (definitions section, para. 2). This commitment is based on the belief that special needs students would profit from the regular classroom environment (Noll, 2014, p....   [tags: Mainstream, Special Education, differentiation]

Powerful Essays
605 words (1.7 pages)

Two Sides Essay

- Pablo Neruda’s Sonnet XLIV “You Must Know That I Do Not Love And That I Love You” clearly illustrates that love has two sides. Neruda uses the text as an example throughout his poem to explain that love has two sides. These two sides are that he loves and that he does not love. This is explained through Neruda’s words: You must know that I do not love and that I love you, because everything alive has its two sides; a word is one wing of silence, fire has its cold half. (107) This statement separates Neruda’s poem into two parts....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
647 words (1.8 pages)

Essay on Abortion: Different Sides

- Abortion: Different Sides When the topic of abortion is brought up, many people have different opinions. The only way we can have a sense of how the situation feels and the circumstances are from someone who has experienced it themselves; the mother. Here is a true story from Becca and her fight for life: “I write to you as an abortion survivor. My mother went to a clinic at 22weeks to get rid of me, most were appalled that she waited so long. Well to make a long story short they gave her the saline solution...or gave it to me rather....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Free Essays
1096 words (3.1 pages)