Managerial Motivation

  • Length: 1397 words (4 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

Motivation is the process of stimulating people to act in ways which serve the needs of the organization providing the stimulus. Simply put, motivation is discovering and applying whatever is needed to get the employee to carry out designated activities in specified ways. However, a clear distinction is made between attitude, which is a state of mind, and behavior, which is a state of action.

A milestone in the relationship between the behavioral scientist and the manager was the "Hawthorne Experiments". In that project, behavioral scientists were invited to a large plant to help explain some employee behavior phenomena which were baffling to the managers. The success in this collaboration was achieved in a setting which included the following elements:
1) The study was a joint undertaking between behavioral scientists and practicing managers.
2) The locale of study was the factory, not the psychological laboratory.
3) The problem studied was not staged; it consisted of real life.
4) The tools used for study were the analytical tools of the behavioral scientists, not the empiricism of the managers.
Motivational Theories
All behavioral scientists agree that human beings act in response to stimuli which appeal to their internal needs and drives. Obviously, it is important to understand just what kinds of stimuli are effective. While the behavioral scientists agree the needs are multiple and that they are unequal in importance, they do not agree on the order of priorities or on the relative importance of potential stimuli.

According to Maslow, people have and tend to satisfy the following five basic needs:
Physiological: food, clothing. Shelter, which people satisfy before all others.
Security: safety and stability, absence of pain, Threat and illness.
Affiliation: desire for friendship, love, and belonging.
Esteem: self-respect, personal achievement, and recognition from others.
Self-actualization: personal growth, self-fulfillment, and realization of ones own full potential.

Although Maslow's theory helps considerably in understanding the growth processes of individuals from birth through maturity, the relevance of his model to the workplace seems somewhat questionable. By the time most employees begin working, many of their lower-order needs already have been fulfilled. Moreover, the nature of many jobs makes it almost impossible for many employees to achieve self-actualization, the highest need in the hierarchy, on the job. The strongest criticism of Maslow's approach is that it was developed from Maslow's clinical experience, and that empirical work has consistently failed to find major support for the theory. These critics argue that while the theory may have described Maslow's patients, it does not reflect the realities of people at work.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Managerial Motivation." 23 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Managerial Communication in the Workplace Essay - INTRODUCTION In this present century the corporate world is moving towards turning into one entity with all the progressions and advancements in the innovation and exchange. The spine to this is been the corporate world, which runs all the organizations ranging from the large companies to small scale with enormous number of its representatives. I firmly accept that achievement of corporates lies in overseeing its representatives for which incredible managerial correspondence expertise is an absolute necessity....   [tags: Employee, Motivation, Human Resources] 789 words
(2.3 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Essay on Motivation in the Workplace - All employees analyze their environment and strive to be recognized and rewarded for their hard work and dedication they put into the company, in a word they are seeking justice. Justice can be defined as a person receiving what they feel they are entitled to and if they do not receive what they deserve the situation may board on injustice. Unfortunately in today’s society justice and appreciation are not given out to all those deserving (Pinder, 1998). A major problem to address is how to keep the motivation level high in a company when the employees do not feel appreciated....   [tags: Motivation & Work Behavior]
:: 7 Works Cited
1182 words
(3.4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Motivation and Hygiene Factors in Indian IT Sector Essay - Motivation and Hygiene Factors in Indian IT Sector SYNOPSIS 1. Descriptive title of the study This study is based on the Herzberg’s Motivation –Hygiene Theory. In this study we try to understand the Herzberg’s theory based on changing environment of Indian IT sector. 2. Nature of the study o Problem to be examined With the changing economic and social values and status in India, we here try to find the current motivation and hygiene factors prevailing in the Indian IT sector. o Significance and need for the study As we all know that the IT sector constitutes a large portion of the Indian economic developments that we all had seen in the recent times....   [tags: Motivation Study IT] 934 words
(2.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Motivation At Work Essay - To commence, this essay will explore how the different aspects of expectancy theory and goal theory explain motivation within the workplace. Vroom and Locke crafted these theories to understand the deeper significance of motivation. This analysis will not only encompass the juxtaposing concepts, but also the resemblance of the philosophies put in place by the academics. These models are known as process theories of motivation, emphasising the immediate connection the two engage as they both contain decision-making responsibilities....   [tags: Expectancy Theory, Goal Theory]
:: 7 Works Cited
892 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay about Evaluation of Managerial Skills - Evaluation of Managerial Skills By analysing my personality I will be able to discover whether or not I have certain attributes within my personality to perform a managerial type job by using set theories, such as Cattell and the Backs analysis. Management skills ================= In order to perform the functions of management and to assume multiple roles, managers must be skilled. Robert Katz identified three managerial skills that are essential to successful management: technical, human, and conceptual....   [tags: Papers] 1814 words
(5.2 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Employee Motivation is the Key to Success Essay - Employee Motivation is the Key to Success MEANING OF MOTIVATION Motivation is an aspect of managerial function of directing under execution. It is necessary as a means to induce people to work, as they are able and trained to do, willingly. The job of a manager in the workplace is to get things done through employees. To do this the manager should be able to motivate employees. But that’s easier said than done. Motivation practice and theory are difficult subject, touching on several disciplines....   [tags: Business Management Employees Workplace] 1396 words
(4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Managerial Roles Essay - Henry Mintzberg took a live study of five CEO’s of a company and came up with ten managerial roles that best reflected all the daily tasks a manager performs. These ten tasks or roles are broken up to in groups called interpersonal, informational, and decisional. The groups are managerial behaviors the manager would go through on the job. The interpersonal managerial roles have three roles within it figurehead, leader, and liaison. A figurehead role was obliged to perform a number of routine duties of legal or social nature....   [tags: essays research papers] 401 words
(1.1 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Employees Motivation Essay - Employees Motivation A business seeks profit by provided customers with goods and services (Schoell, et al 15). There are various types of businesses that differ according to their ownership. The three basic forms of private ownership businesses are the sole proprietorship (i.e. sole trader), partnership, and corporation (Schoell, et al 132). The type of ownership that a business organization would apply is dependent on the owner's financial status and objectives. Apart from the different types of ownerships, there are various styles of management and leadership....   [tags: GCSE Business Marketing Coursework] 1043 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay about Motivation - Motivation is one of the most discussed topics in the present era’s organisations, especially since renowned psychologists like Maslow and Herzberg are dedicating their efforts to understanding it. Companies are investing a significant amount of resources in improving productivity in order to maximise profits. One of these important resources is of human nature. In order to get the very best out of employees, some motivational approaches need to be used. But what is motivation and how do I successfully motivate....   [tags: Psychology, Maslow, Hertzberg] 2396 words
(6.8 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Motivation of Workers Essay - Motivation of Workers Having a motivated workforce is vital for most businesses, since it can lead to higher rates of productivity, better quality output, and low rates of absenteeism and labour turnover. The main factors which affect the motivation of workers are pay levels, job security, promotional prospects, being given responsibilities, working conditions, fringe benefits, participation in decision-making and working in a team. Motivational Theories --------------------- There are two basic theories of motivation; content theories and process theories....   [tags: Papers] 1058 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]

Furthermore, it is not clear that deficient needs are the strongest motivators. In Maslow's defense, Maslow did not originally intend his theories to be applied to the workplace; rather, management specialists such as Douglas McGregor popularized his ideas in the management literature.

David C. McClelland, professor of psychology at Harvard University, is also credited with extensive contributions to motivation theory. McClelland identifies three needs:
1. NEED FOR ACHIEVEMENT. The desire to accomplish some goal or task more effectively than has been the case in the past.
2. NEED FOR AFFILIATION. The desire to have close, amenable relations with other people.
3. NEED FOR POWER. The desire to be influential and to have impact on a group.

Much of McClelland's early work suggested that the need for achievement was important to business people, scientists, and professional persons. A later report restricted to managers concluded that the need for power was most important to management. McClelland identifies three types of managers:

1. AFFILIATE MANAGERS (affiliation greater than power, high inhibition).

2. PERSONAL POWER MANAGERS (power greater than affiliation, low inhibition).

3. INSTITUTIONAL MANAGERS (power greater than affiliation, high inhibition).

He concluded that the institutional managers, who were high in the need for power and self-control, but low in the need for affiliation, were typically the most successful leaders.

Many managers prefer Herzberg's theory because:
1. Easy to understand, the motivators and hygiene factors are easily identified.
2. Provide actions required to improve employee performance that are straight forward.
3. Herzberg model underpins the importance of intrinsic factors in the job and lead to the need to improve job-related content, re-design or re-structure the current job in order to improve motivation and job satisfaction.

The motivators are typically intrinsic factors, largely administered by the employee. The hygiene factors are extrinsic factors, under the control of the supervisor or someone else other than the employee.

1. Herzberg implies that satisfaction and motivation are essentially the same. We know, though, that motivation is often the result of dissatisfaction. So, it is dangerous to draw conclusions about what motivates employees on the basis of what satisfies them.
2. Herzberg's findings appear to be tied to his critical-incidents methodology. That is, the two factors revealed by Herzberg only-show up when employees are asked to recall satisfying and dissatisfying events. We are likely to attribute good things to internal factors and bad things to external factors. Herzberg's results may just be a reflection on this self-serving bias.
3. Herzberg classified items as satisfiers or dissatisfiers on the basis of the relative number of times they were mentioned as causing satisfaction or dissatisfaction.

There is much similarity between Herzberg's and Maslow's models. A close examination of Herzberg's ideas indicates that what he actually is saying is that some employees may have achieved a level of social and economic progress such that the higher-level needs of Maslow (esteem and self-actualization) are the primary motivators. However, they still must satisfy the lower-level needs for the maintenance of their current state. So we can see that money might still be a motivator for non management workers (particularly those at a low wage level) and for some managerial employees. In addition, Herzberg's model adds to Maslow's model, because it breaks down the five need levels into two job-oriented categories: maintenance and motivational.

The figure compares the structure of the two. The table shown on the nest page compares areas in which they differ.

1. Relevance

2. Impact of needs on behavior

3. Role of financial rewards

4. Perspective

5. Type of theory People in society in all types of jobs and in retirement.

All needs can motivate behavior.

Financial reward can motivate.

Applies to all people and their lives.

Descriptive (what is).
Most relevant to white-collar and professional employees.

Only some intrinsic needs serve as motivators.

Financial reward is not a key motivator.

Is work centered.

Prescriptive (what should be).

According to McGregor, theory Y managers would seek to motivate their subordinates through the goals of achievement, self-esteem and (possibly) the prospect of self-actualization. Theory X managers, on the other hand, would limit subordinates' abilities to exercise discretion and use incentive schemes and penalties as primary inducements for increased effort.
Theory X and Theory Y
According to McGregor, a manager of the Theory X model views his or her subordinates as by nature
disliking work
lacking in ambition
resistant to change
preferring to be led than to lead

Theory Y, by contrast, involves an alternative set of assumptions. A manager operating under a Theory Y perspective views subordinates as naturally
willing to work
willing to accept responsibility
capable of self-direction
capable of self-control
capable of imagination, ingenuity, creativity.

Motivation in Real Life.
Example: A salesperson has worked hard to consistently achieve a 125% sales quota. She was given a $200 per month raise in recognition of her achievement by her boss. However, she discovered that a salesperson with no previous experience had been hired into the organization by her boss for $100 more a month than she was making. This resulted in a loss of motivation for the salesperson and her performance began to drop. In my opinion, this loss of motivation can be seen in Maslows' theory under esteem because she wasn't receiving the recognition, in the form of higher pay, for her outstanding sales. The difference in salary was very small, but having a history of working hard and great performance and not receiving recognition for it would make most people lose heart and possible seek employment elsewhere. Money can be a big motivator when trying to get the most from an employee. But I think it's also very important to look at all the other qualitative needs employees have that fill their emotional needs as well.

Boone, Louis E., David L. Kurtz, "Principles of Management", (2nd edition), Random House, Inc., 1984.

Carlisle, Howard M., "Management: Concepts, Methods, and Application", (2nd edition), Science Research Associates, Inc., 1982.

Hellriegel, Don. Jackson, Susan. Slocum, John (2005). Management: A Competency-based Approach (10th ed.) Canada: Transcontinental Interglobe.

Beamish, Paul. Morrison, Allison. Inkpen, Andrew. Rosenweig, Philip. (2003) International Management (5th ed.) Iowa: R.R. Donnelly

Return to