“The Magic Barrel,” is a short story about a man named Leo Finkle. Leo is young man who struggled immensely when it came to finding love. After hardly finding time in his hectic schedule, he meets with Pinye Salzman, a self-proclaimed match-maker. Salzman devotes his time to choosing a woman for Finkle. Finkle seemed to have a problem with all the women selected. Finally, Finkle finds a woman who happens to be Salzman’s daughter. After much debate, Salzman reluctantly agrees to let Leo have a shot with her. It turns out to be all a setup, and we don’t really know how the pair end up.
Although the idea of arranged marriage that is reflected in the story isn’t the kind we see projected in movies, it still raises a lot of questions. The first thing I thought about when I read the story was whether or not arranged marriages are morally correct. In my opinion, they are not. I think people should have a choice in everything they do in their life. As Christine Rogers points out, “The preferences in the relationship seemed to be what the man wanted.” (Rogers, ““The Magic Barrel” Response” October 15, 2016) These marriages that Salzman were arranging seemed to be very one...
... middle of paper ...
...ks. Maybe if someone had chosen a fit mate for Hulga, it wouldn’t of been someone who was actually so wrong for her. Leo went through many different women throughout his selection process, but eventually landed one whom he couldn’t get his mind off of. If Leo had taken a traditional route, he may of never met the girl he imagines to be “the one.” If my final decision was based solely between the two stories, I’d say that the arranged marriage actually brought greater success.
Overall, “The Magic Barrel,” made me think more than any other text we’ve viewed this semester. It challenged my beliefs, morals, and ideas all at once. The story made me question my original stance and encouraged me to look deeper into the subject. By the end of the reading, my opinion had mostly changed and that is why I think that Malamud’s short story was the best choice for this response.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- At the beginning of Bernard Malamud, “The Magic Barrel,” starting off with a children’s book style as if it was going to be a fairy tale. This is not the case whatsoever, however, each character plays the role of one. Love and finding who himself is the theme of the story, a young man Leo searches for a love that doesn’t exist. Not searching at all for what he desired, but changing his whole understanding on who he is after every experience, a love that he needed was never searched for, but finding it caused him to find himself.... [tags: fairy tale, world war II, hocaust]
1419 words (4.1 pages)
- That what love is has always been a question satisfied completely by no answer. Some have their own definitions and draw in their minds images of ideal lovers, while others just simply follow what the hearts dictate. Through the spiritual journey to seek for love of Leo, the main character of 'The Magic Barrel' by Bernard Malamud, the author gives us his undeniable declaration of love. Leo, who has a matchmaker find for him a wife, after all his choices falls in love with the one he does not choose, yet he loves her at the first sight.... [tags: essays research papers]
1081 words (3.1 pages)
- In the traditional Jewish community, the arranged marriage is the approved model for marital relations. Arranged marriages still continue to exist today in modern orthodox Jewish communities. The shadchanim, or marriage brokers, were respected members of society. Often, the shadchanim were the Rabbis, who viewed the arranging of marriages as one of their duties to the community. Through time, however, the arranging of marriages lost its distinction and became the livelihood for the lower classes in the Jewish community.... [tags: American Literature]
900 words (2.6 pages)
- Most people spend much of their life looking for love. They look for love in many different people. Some people believe that love finds its way to where it needs to be, and some believe that love must be sought after. In Malamud’s story, “The Magic Barrel” one of his characters says “Love comes with the right person, not before” (Malamud 49). This implies that when two people find the right person, they will find love. Defining love has been one of the most difficult words to define in the English language.... [tags: essays research papers fc]
620 words (1.8 pages)
- An Analysis of "The Magic Barrel" Bernard Malamud's short story The Magic Barrel takes place in uptown New York and is centered around Leo Finkle, a rabbinical student who is about to be ordained. In hopes that being married may help him win over a congregation, Finkle solicits the help of a marriage broker by the name of Pinye Salzman. Salzman presents Leo with card after card each representing a potential marriage candidate. The number of possible suitors is so great that Salzman claims to have a barrel filled with these cards.... [tags: American Literature]
715 words (2 pages)
- The mysterious woman Why does Harriet Bird shoot Roy Hobbs. This is the core question in the book, The Natural, by Bernard Malamud. Harriet Bird, the woman who shoots Roy Hobbs, covers less than one tenth of the book. However, she is definitely a major character since she affects Roy’s entire life. Malamud depicts Harriet as a special and mystical woman. Such portrayal creates tension throughout the novel. The suspense is formed as the author describe the costume and behaviors of Harriet Bird.... [tags: Baseball, Bernard Malamud, The Natural]
1364 words (3.9 pages)
- In life, there are times when every human being will face challenging obstacles. In the beginning of the novel The Natural, by Bernard Malamud, demonstrates a theme that heroes are not always what we expect them to be as people, and more often than not their flaws bring their personal tragedy. Roy’s life changing experience happen when he was in Harriet’s hotel room and was shot in the stomach by her. At that moment, of course Roy has struggled with keeping up with his baseball career but, toward the end not only that heroes have their priorities straight in life: they become a better human being once they have overcome the traumatic experience. It took Roy years to overcome his difficult ex... [tags: Baseball, Bernard Malamud, Double play]
1053 words (3 pages)
- Symbolism in Bernard Malamud's The Natural The role of symbolism in Bernard Malamud's The Natural is important in helping the reader understand the theme and meaning of the novel as well as the time period in which it took place. Malamud¡¦s use of symbolism defines the character of Roy Hobbs and shows how the events occurring around him affected his decisions and, eventually, his career. Symbolism in The Natural takes the form of characters, such as women who strongly influenced Roy; historical events, such as the infamous 1919 World Series scandal; and even Greek and Roman mythology. All forms of symbolism used by Malamud are woven into the life and career of Roy Hobbs.... [tags: Bernard Malamud The Natural Essays]
2419 words (6.9 pages)
- Every individual has two lives, the life we live, and the life we live after that. Nobody is perfect, but if one works hard enough, he or she can stay away from failure. The Natural is a novel written by Bernard Malamud. It is Malamud’s first novel that initially received mixed reactions but afterwards, it was regarded as an outstanding piece of literature. It is a story about Roy Hobbs who after making mistakes in his life, he returns the bribery money and is left with self-hatred for mistakes he has done.... [tags: Malamud, Hobbs, baseball]
1043 words (3 pages)
- In the story, The Natural, certain characters and events are portrayed in a distinctive way that makes this story unique to other books and shows the typical writing style of the narrator. The author uses a repetitive writing technique that is impossible to overlook. The writer of this book is able to catch the reader’s eye with his concept of the importance of beautiful description. The Natural, by Bernard Malamud, uses great imagery that makes the story appealing. In the beginning of The Natural, Roy Hobbs is a young man who has his whole life ahead of him.... [tags: Impact of Imagery, Analysis]
1196 words (3.4 pages)