Machiavelli 's Views On The View Of An Ideal Society Essay

Machiavelli 's Views On The View Of An Ideal Society Essay

Length: 1552 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Machiavelli and More were both humanists and contemporaries of each other during the Renaissance and had witnessed political and religious turmoil in their respective states. Because of this, it led Machiavelli and More to write about how states should be run and how to maintain their societies. However, Machiavelli and More’s view of the relationship between human nature and the possibility of creating an ideal society contrasted one another. Machiavelli’s views in The Prince was more realistic because Machiavelli believed that the prince should regard the interests of the state, not the people and More’s Utopia was more idealistic because he believed that states should reform and regard the interest of the people. Machiavelli believed human nature is manipulative and unchangeable, the prince should only trust his ability, and in separating politics and ethics. More believed human nature can be improved and changed for the better, everyone is equal to one another, and in connecting Christian morals and politics. It can also be argued that Machiavelli and More’s view regarding human nature and creating an ideal community do not contrast each other at all, but are similar because both agreed that their government should be improved and reformed.
Machiavelli believed human nature is manipulative and unchangeable for the better, unlike More who believed human nature can be improved and changed for the better. For example, Machiavelli stated that a prince should be ruthless and use force to gain and maintain power because people in real life are vicious and selfish. In Chapter VI, he explained that people can easily be managed at first, but they are difficult to control over a period of time. He wrote “the nature of the people is...

... middle of paper ...

...s serve for a one-year term” (Utopia, pg. 96). This shows that More believed everyone are equals of each other and through this new political system, no one feels oppressed. This type of government More wrote in Utopia, is an alternative to Europe and England’s political system of feudalism where the nobles profited the most under the peasants’ labor. More’s views and beliefs on government favored the people in which he also cared about their interest and welfare. It can be also assumed that if the people’s interest and welfare are taken into consideration then they will be happier which the state can be maintained peacefully without force or violence. More’s viewpoint is seen as idealistic compared to Machiavelli because this shows that Utopia is a quasi-ideal community where there is no hardship or conflict, and where everyone is an equal to one another and happy.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Morality: Comparing Hobbes and Machiavelli

- One of the main premises of Leviathan and The Prince is morality. Where morality comes from, how it affects people under a political structure and how human nature contributes or doesn’t to morality. Hobbes and Machiavelli differ widely on each subject. Machiavelli’s views on morality, based upon a literal interpretation of the satire The Prince, is very much a practical and realistic approach to the nature of morality and human nature. Hobbes’ views, based in Leviathan, are of a more idealistic nature, and my views are a little in between the two....   [tags: Hobbes vs Machiavelli]

Strong Essays
1216 words (3.5 pages)

Comparing Thomas Hobbes and Niccolo Machiavelli Essay

- Thomas Hobbes and Niccolo Machiavelli Two of the greatest philosophers of all time are Thomas Hobbes and Niccolo Machiavelli. Hobbes was born in 1588 in England, when absolutism was taking hold in Europe. His most famous work was 'Leviathan', written in 1651. Hobbes discussed the ideal state and innate laws of man and nature, among other things. Machiavelli was born in Italy in 1469, a time when his home country was ruled mostly by foreign powers. His hometown, Florence, was still independent....   [tags: Compare Contrast Hobbes Machiavelli Essays]

Strong Essays
2258 words (6.5 pages)

Utopia by Thomas More and The Prince by Machiavelli Essay

- Utopia by Thomas More and The Prince by Machiavelli Thomas More’s Utopia and Machiavelli’s The Prince both concern themselves with the fundamental issues of how a society works and maintains itself. The goals behind the two works, however, differ considerably. The goal of Utopia is to illustrate the maintenance of an “ideal” society and the goal of The Prince is to instruct a prince, or ruler, on how to maintain his state. On the surface these two goals may seem similar but the difference lies in the way the authors handle the subject of power....   [tags: More Utopia Prince Machiavelli Essays]

Strong Essays
816 words (2.3 pages)

The Tao-te Ching by Lao-Tzu and The Prince by Machiavelli Essay

- “The Tao-te Ching” by Lao-Tzu and “The Prince” by Machiavelli Throughout history, it can be argued that at the core of the majority of successful societies has stood an effective allocation of leadership. Accordingly, in their respective works “The Tao-te Ching” and “The Prince”, Lao-Tzu and Machiavelli have sought to reach a more complete understanding of this relationship. The theme of political leaders and their intricate relationship with society indeed manifests itself within both texts, however, both Lao-Tzu and Machiavelli approach this issue from almost entirely opposite positions....   [tags: Tao-te Ching Lao-Tzu The Prince Machiavelli]

Strong Essays
1754 words (5 pages)

Analyzing Dante and Machiavelli´s Characteristics of a Good Leader Essay

- Dante and Machiavelli were both writers who felt that society and leaders were greatly mislead in their approach of operating the state. Yet even they had very contrasting beliefs in their view of what was ideal for a society to function properly. Machiavelli judges religious or political leaders is based there’s ability to maintain order and unity, regardless of whether one or not need these leaders put there morality and ethics aside for this greater benefit of one’s state. This differs greatly from Dante because his evaluation of the leaders of his time is based solely on how true they stay to moral and ethical virtues....   [tags: morality, ethics, leadership, politics]

Strong Essays
1807 words (5.2 pages)

The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli Essay

- Machiavelli’s The Prince has been widely interpreted as representative of political behavior that is violent and deceitful. As such, the term Machiavellian has to come to be associated with deviousness, ruthlessness, and power politics. The issue of whether or not Machiavelli can be considered a Machiavellian himself is difficult to resolve because of the complexity of the arguments he puts forth in both The Prince and Discourses. While the claims made in the former are more focused on the individual, namely the “prince,” those posited in the latter describe phenomena on a broader spectrum, having to do with human nature and society at large....   [tags: sociopolitical analysis]

Strong Essays
680 words (1.9 pages)

Aristotle, Machiavelli, And Hobbes Essay

- Theories of human nature, as the term would ever so subtly suggest, are at best only individual assertions of the fundamental and intrinsic compositions of mankind, and should be taken as such. Indeed it can be said that these assertions are both many and widespread, and yet too it can be said that there are a select few assertions of the nature of man that rise above others when measured by historical persistence, renown, and overall applicability. These eclectic discourses on the true nature of man have often figured largely in theories of political science, typically functioning as foundational structures to broader claims and arguments....   [tags: Political philosophy, Thomas Hobbes, Government]

Strong Essays
1286 words (3.7 pages)

Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, and Machiavelli Essay

- Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, and Machiavelli The thirteenth through the eighteenth century brought profound changes in the political realm of Western civilization. Beginning with the Scientific Revolution and only advancing during the Renaissance, secularization and skepticism lead to changes in not only the intellectual life of Westerners, but also to their politics. At the forefront of the political debate were well-versed men such as Machiavelli, Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau. The influences of these men, though often criticized, can clearly be seen in the centuries and decades following their noted works....   [tags: Politics Philosophy Sociology]

Strong Essays
1849 words (5.3 pages)

Comparison of Lao-tzu and Machiavelli Essays

- Comparison of Lao-tzu and Machiavelli Lao-tzu and Machiavelli are political philosophers writing in two different lands and two different times. Lao-tzu was an ancient Chinese philosopher from 6th century BC, the author of Tao-te Ching, and Machiavelli was an Italian philosopher who lived 2000 years after Lao-tzu’s time, author of Prince. They are both philosophers but have totally different perspective on how to be a good leader. While both philosopher’s writing is instructive. Lao-tzu’s advice issues from detached view of a universal ruler; Machiavelli’s advice is very personal perhaps demanding....   [tags: Political Philosophers Philosophy Politics Essays]

Strong Essays
726 words (2.1 pages)

Biography of Niccolo Machiavelli Essay

- Biography of Niccolo Machiavelli Machiavelli was born in 1469, into an Italy, which was probably less feudal than any other European country at that time. Europe at this time was in a state of political upheaval. The Church's power was in decline, losing its power as unifying government, Spain and France were pushing their way in Italy, and Italy itself was a melange of bickering city-states. This climate of political uncertainty greatly affected Machiavelli's political theories....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
847 words (2.4 pages)