The structure of both texts utilize a framing narrative. The stories are both told from an unreliable, detached narrator. In Symposium, the framework is a bit more complex.
“‘I wanted to ask you what 's happened at that party which Agathon, Socrates, Alcibiades and all the other guests were at, and how their speeches on love went.’ [...]
‘It really was a long time ago, then,’ he said. ‘But who told you the story? Was it Socrates himself?’
‘Oh, good heavens, no!’ I exclaimed. ‘It was the same person who told Pheonix about it. He’s called Aristodemus -- from the deme of Cydathenaum, a little fellow, never wore shoes. He’d been there at the party since he was one of the greatest lovers Socrates had at the time.’”(Plato 4)
Plato uses this frame story to freely embellish and fictionalize the account, and spea...
... middle of paper ...
...day. This paralyzing darkness Mel experiences is symbolic of how ignorant the characters are to love and how helpless they are to it.
In “What We Talk About When We Talk About Love,” Raymond Carver borrows structure, narrative, dialogue, and archetypes from Plato’s Symposium. Carver, however, does not simply borrow from Plato. He takes from it, twists it, and drops it into our dark, modern times. Carver 's characters can not discuss love like Plato and Socrates do. There is no spiritual side to love like Socrates (55) or Mel (137) suggest. This modern love is carnal, aggressive and a force to be reckoned with. In “What We Talk About When We Talk About Love,” the characters are not Plato’s classical, big-name philosophers. They are insignificant everymen, in the constant pursuit of love. Love is not personified. Love is a force of destruction for all those involved.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The meaning of love is as intricate and unique as the purpose that it serves. It seems that the nature of love is found in the mind, the body and the soul. In Plato’s Symposium each member of the drinking party gives their own interpretation of love. As each speaker engages in their discourse, the concept of love is evaluated from different angles. According to Phaedrus, homoerotic love is the highest form of love and that sacrificing oneself for love will result in a multitude of rewards from the gods, while Pausanias believes that there are two forms of love: Commonly and Heavenly.... [tags: homoerotic love, aristophanes, zeus]
1776 words (5.1 pages)
- ... The word organ itself is derived from “organon” which means “tool.” Essentially, by referring to the body as the “natural organic body” he is saying that the body is a vessel for the soul (our actuality) and a tool for living. This second definition is saying what he claimed before which in short is that the soul is the purpose and therefore the potential of the body. Aristotle claims that there is a distinction between the body of a living thing from the matter of an artifact. To understand what makes living matter, we can look at Aristotle’s account of the activity of the soul.... [tags: Soul, Life, Socrates, Love]
1892 words (5.4 pages)
- ... As he gives a elucidates on his relationship with Socrates, he continuously asks Socrates to correct him if he says anything of untrue nature. Although it could be that Alcibiades solely uttered the truth, it is highly uncharacteristic of Socrates in a Platonic dialogue to simply agree with whatever someone is arguing. Yet, even Socrates, who is clever with the ways he conceals his love for Alcibiades, is unable to contradict him, manifesting his love for him. Upon establishing that Callicles will do whatever to please one of his loves, the Athenian people, Socrates demonstrates how philosophy is his more reliable and loyal love, surmising that his love for philosophy may in fact be a s... [tags: Plato, Philosophy, Socrates, Love]
1282 words (3.7 pages)
- ... All you need to do is walk outside, take a look around you. I’m sure you’ll find something that you believe is beautiful. Once you do that, look in the mirror. Everyone has something beautiful about him or her. Everyone is beautiful. Foundations of relationships create a beautiful image in which a connection between people is made deeper than life itself. By examining these three forms and describing how each is shown to be beautiful the definition of love will be seen to be a personal reflection of experiences and values.... [tags: Love, Human, Thought, Interpersonal relationship]
1237 words (3.5 pages)
- Drinking: A Love Story (1996) is a memoir by Caroline Knapp where she shares her experience of gradually becoming an alcoholic. She found drinking to be the most important relationship in her life; she loved how it made her feel, how it coped with her fears and worries. She chronicles some of the effort and self-realization required for recovery from this addiction, but her primary focus is on the charm, seductiveness, and destructiveness that she was able to find in two decades as an alcoholic, hopelessly in love with liquor.... [tags: Alcoholism, Alcoholic beverage, Drinking culture]
1471 words (4.2 pages)
- ... In Aristotle discussion On the Soul he talks about the kinds of souls possessed by different living things such as plants, animals and, beings. Aristotle then goes on describing the substance that makes up the soul, the first is matter which is not this in its own right, the second is form which makes matter this and the third form is the compound of matter and form. Every living body is a substance and the soul is the actuality of the body. The soul is not some sort of activity but the ability to engage in some sort of activity.... [tags: philosophical discussion and analysis]
1431 words (4.1 pages)
- “Love is difficult to define, and there maybe different definitions. But one definition of love, is an utter, absolute, and unqualified wish for the other’s happiness” (). One of the most important Greek philosophers in Western history, Socrates contributed to many theories, and impacted the field of ethics throughout his life. He was well known in Athens for his knowledge and teachings to the youth. He was the creator of Socratic irony and the Socratic method, both used to convey his lessons to the Athenians.... [tags: Socrates, Plato, Philosophy, Symposium]
721 words (2.1 pages)
- In the Symposium, written by Plato, Socrates and others engage in a dialogue in the home of Agathon on love. Instead of "singing the honours" (94) of love like the other participants, Socrates uses a retelling of a discussion that he had with a woman named Diotima to tell the audience of what he perceives to be the truth of love. He first speaks to Agathon in order to be on the same wavelength with him. Socrates asks Agathon a series of questions - which leads to Agathon being thoroughly confused and completely re-thinking his entire speech he just made.... [tags: Philosophy]
925 words (2.6 pages)
- Socrates Socrates was a Greek philosopher and teacher. His teachings, life and death have made him one of the most admired people in history. Although he wrote no books or developed a regular school of thought, his influence inspired others to. Socrates affected the entire course of Western thought. I believe Socrates to be one of the most important philosophers ever. Born in Athens, Socrates (470-399 BCE) was the son of a wealthy sculptor. There he received the regular elementary education in literature, music, and gymnastics.... [tags: Papers]
653 words (1.9 pages)
- Socrates Socrates, as known by Renault, was a beautiful creature. Not physically beautiful, but internally and fundamentally beautiful. It was he who said: When you assume the show of any virtue, you open a credit account, which one day you will have to meet or go broke (pp. 398). According to Renault, Socrates taught children free of charge. He often walked and talked with children and young men in the market. They discussed, or more accurately argued in a calm manner, various issues ranging from the sciences to religion.... [tags: essays research papers]
677 words (1.9 pages)