Literate or Culturally Literate Essay

Literate or Culturally Literate Essay

Length: 1187 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

To be successful in the world today literacy is vital. But what is the definition of Literacy? According to Merriam Webster it is “the quality or state of being literate”, but can it also be expanded and redefined as Culturally Literate “the ability to understand and appreciate the similarities and differences in the customs, values, and beliefs of one’s own culture the cultures of others? This essay will utilize the writings of Fishman, Mary Ann Zehr, and Jean Piaget to compare the definition of literacy by mainstream society to that of the Amish culture.
Literacy by mainstream society standards includes having the freedom to choose what to read and write, and the use of critical thinking to evaluate what has been read. But it can also be defined, as in the Amish culture, as being culturally literate by the standards of your own culture.
Typically to be considered literate one must possess the ability to read, write and comprehend what has been read. But what if within your culture the ability to read, write and comprehend only extends to being able to read a recipe, or to read correspondence from distant family members, or to be able to comprehend the latest farming tip in The Dairy? To the Amish reading and writing are only a small part of the definition of literacy, they are not nearly as important as the ability to plant crops and tend to animals, or prepare a meal for a large family. To be literate in the Amish culture, one needs to be literate enough to read the hymnals during church services, to correspond by writing traditional Amish letters, and to read the Bible (Fishman). But, to be literate in the Amish culture also means as an Amish man, he would also need to know when to plant his crops, what to plan...


... middle of paper ...


...elieve to be success, they trade within our community, they learn just enough to coexist on the fringes of our society, but generally don’t seek to become the next CEO of General Motors. By comparison, how successful would the typical mainstream man or woman with an MBA be trying to exist within the Amish culture? Literacy is vital to success, but it is being culturally literate, by the standards of your own culture that is by far, the determining factor in those successes.






Works Cited

From Literacies: 1. Becoming Literate: A Lesson from the Amish Andrea Fishman
Other Sources: 2. -- Amish Literacy: What and How It Means by Andrea Fishman Sep 1989
3. Zehr, Mary Ann. Amish Teaching Is Diverse, Author Discovers. Education Week 26.14 (2006): 11.Academic Search Premier. EBSCO. Web. 30 Sept. 2010.
4. Piaget, Jean The Origins of Intelligence in Children

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Learning to Become Literate

- Learning to Become Literate “In any literate society, people constantly see the best way to teach children how to read and write so that the younger generation can become fully functioning members of that society.” (Savage 15) This is obviously an important goal of any society that wants their children to be well educated and succeed in the world. Learning to be literate is a very important developmental milestone that is recognized cross-culturally. Its social importance is shown in the fact that in school; literacy makes up 2/3 of the three “R’s”....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
2981 words (8.5 pages)

Essay on The Literate Arts Are Not Needed: They Are Wanted

- An illiterate person can be successful and live a productive life, a high school dropout can make a respectable wage, a person with a college education can be underemployed, and many people with doctorates who are unemployed. The literate arts do not guarantee success and money. What the literate arts do offer a person, are tools that make gaining knowledge and wisdom easier, both during and after their formal education. The gaining of this knowledge and wisdom offers other tools that make success easier – whatever success may be....   [tags: Education]

Strong Essays
1919 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on The Different Sides to the Literate Arts

- In “The Dark Night of the Soul,” Richard Miller attempts to find the purpose of the humanities. Miller argues that the humanities give access to the best ideas of human beings. He discusses the positives and negatives of literature, from the common idea that reading is a sure way to improving one’s quality of life, to the unintended consequences of taking the ideas of others to the extreme. If the written word can be used for both good and bad, then what is the purpose of the humanities. The humanities are made up of disciplines that make up human culture, from law, history, philosophy, literature, and the fine arts....   [tags: education, humanitites, knowledge]

Strong Essays
1679 words (4.8 pages)

Becoming Information Literate in the Digital Age Essay

- Having been working in academic libraries for several years, I noticed college students rely heavily on the Internet for research. For most people, opening a browser means connecting to the world wide library of information. At the same time, some college students are not aware of the risk of using online information without evaluation (Gross and Latham, 35). They tend to focus on relevancy more than the quality. That is the reason why so many professors are surprised to see how much information their students used is from biased, inaccurate, and commercial websites....   [tags: data and communication technology]

Strong Essays
625 words (1.8 pages)

Literate and Illiterate World in Our Society Essay

- In America, we are split in two different worlds, meaning there are two lifestyles in our society. One lifestyle is where America is more focused on the literate world. This lifestyle finds it important to understand and read things thoroughly in order to understand life. This side of America is capable to detect from what is right and what is wrong for our society. They firmly believe that education is an important factor in life. On the contrary the other lifestyle of America is the non-reality based belief system....   [tags: politics, decisions, advertisement]

Strong Essays
837 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Analysis: Becoming School Literate Parents

- The two articles I have chosen to discuss in this assessment task are Chen,H. & Harris, P.(2009), Becoming school literate parents: An ESL perspective and Thurston, J. (2004) Teaching and learning the reading of homepages. Research shows that parents’ involvement into their children’s literacy learning has a significant impact on the children’s literacy development. The first article by Honglin Chen & Pauline Harris discusses the stages of development of an ESL parent into a school literate parent who understands the school’s expectations for English literacy; it analysis the process of identity formation of this ESL parent through the three powerful sources: access, negotiation and particip...   [tags: ESL, Education, Teaching ESL]

Strong Essays
1219 words (3.5 pages)

Teaching Culturally Diverse Classrooms Essay

- America now is a very culturally diverse nation; most of the minority and immigrant population lives in cities, which indicates that the public school classrooms in urban areas are full of versatile cultural identities. According to the 2000 Census record, minority and immigrant populations has grown in increasing numbers, and most of those people live in urban areas and attend public high schools; also, the level of residential segregation still remains as high as in 1990, which proposes new problems for immigrants and minorities....   [tags: Education, Multiculturalism, Diversity]

Strong Essays
1806 words (5.2 pages)

Now Is The Time To Be Computer Literate Essay

- Now Is The Time To Be Computer Literate Now is the time to become computer literate. Now is the time to become familiar and comfortable with the computer because in the future we will become virtually a paperless society and many daily activities will be linked to the computer. Mail delivery to the home and business will be almost entirely phased out and e-mail will replace it. Bills will come via the computer and paid the same way. Pay checks will be electronically deposited to your bank account....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
844 words (2.4 pages)

How I Learned To Become Literate Essay

- How I Learned To Become Literate As a six-month-old baby books had opened up a whole entire new world of experience for me. My inspiration to learn how to read and write was encouraged by my Mother and Grandmother. This is because they read out loud to me before bed occasionally and gave me the best time of my life by introducing me to a library. By two years of age I developed speech and other communication skills. This helped me understand and develop a favorite book, “PJ Funny Bunny,” and I would stare at the pages pretending I was reading them....   [tags: Personal Narratives Literacy Reading Essays]

Strong Essays
1537 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on How Morality is Culturally Relative

- How Morality is Culturally Relative Abstract Within this world that we live in, there is an enormous amount of people. Each of these people belongs to different cultures and societies. Every society has traits and customs that make it unique. These societies follow different moral codes. This means that they will may have different answers to the moral questions asked by our own society. What I am trying to say is that every society has a different way of analyzing and dealing with life's events, because of their cultural beliefs....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1471 words (4.2 pages)