Like Water For Chocolate - Movie versus Book Essay

Like Water For Chocolate - Movie versus Book Essay

Length: 1224 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Like Water For Chocolate
“Like Water for Chocolate” by Laura Esquivel, is a beautiful romantic tale of an impossible passionate love during the revolution in Mexico. The romance is followed by the sweet aroma of kitchen secrets and cooking, with a lot of imagination and creativity. The story is that of Tita De La Garza, the youngest of all daughters in Mama Elena’s house. According to the family tradition she is to watch after her mother till the day she does, and therefore cannot marry any men. Tita finds her comfort in cooking, and soon the kitchen becomes her world, affecting every emotion she experiences to the people who taste her food. Esquivel tells Titas story as she grows to be a mature, blooming women who eventually rebels against her mother, finds her true identity and reunites with her long lost love Pedro. The book became a huge success and was made to a movie directed by Alfonso Arau. Although they both share many similarities, I also found many distinct differences. The movie lost an integral part of the book, the sensual aspect of the cooking and love.

The story begins with Titas birth prematurely when Mama Elena was chopping onions. Tita grows up with Nacha the most dominant figure in her life, and follows Mama Elenas routine of cooking, cleaning and sewing. At every incident she can, Mama Elena criticizes Tita and even beats her if she tries to speak up. One day Tita tells her mother that Pedro wants to come and ask for her hand, but according to the family tradition she cannot marry because she is the youngest daughter. Mama Elena tells Pedro he can marry Rosaura- one of her older daughters, and Pedro agrees to the arrangement just to be closer to his true love- Tita.
Preparing food for the wedding Ti...


... middle of paper ...


...d coloring of certain images. The novel, however, puts much greater emphasis on the imagination and creativity, and on the main character Tita. The novel really makes the reader feel Titas pain and grow with her as she discovers her freedom, whereas the movie failed to achieve this. Moreover, the movie tends to ignore the significant of 3 integral motifs, cooking, tears and sensuality.

Both book and movie capture good moments and ideas of Esquivel. I would say the book was more entertaining and memorable for me. The novel never rests or drags on, and although it evolves around many tragedies a dying love and lovers, in the end you truly feel happy for the way things turn to be. So does the movie, the end of it is very powerful, I might have not got attached to its characters but I fell in love with the magical fairy tale and romance of Like Water For Chocolate.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Laura Equirel's Like Water for Chocolate Essays

- Laura Esquirel’s, Like Water for Chocolate, is a modern day Romeo and Juliet filled with mouthwatering recipes. It has become a valued part of American literature. The novel became so popular that it was developed into a film, becoming a success in both America and Mexico. Alfonso Arau directs the film. After reading the novel and seeing the movie, I discovered several distinct differences between the two as well as some riveting similarities. The novel begins with the main character, Tita, being born on the kitchen table....   [tags: Esquivel Like Water Chocolate Movie Essays]

Strong Essays
1322 words (3.8 pages)

Blue Gold : World Water Wars Essay

- Blue Gold: World Water Wars, was an informative movie that explored various aspects of water issues around the world. Based off the book, written by Maude Barlow and Tony Clark, Water Wars first investigates what our current water problems are and how they affect the human race on a global scale. Next, the movie examines how both corporations and politics influence water rights. The documentary then researches water wars, as a basic human rights violation and finally looks at possible solutions to this global water crisis....   [tags: Water, Water resources, Water supply]

Strong Essays
1441 words (4.1 pages)

Essay The Blue Gold Film On Water Wars

- This Blue Gold film on Water Wars, directed by Sam Bozzo, has some very important messages; water is a necessary component for all human beings, its supply is running out faster than we are able to replenish the source. In my opinion, this video encourages us to save water, to understand the politics, and to help out in this water crisis. This reminds me of the book Mockingjay part 1. It 's seems like we are district 13, and the government is the capitol. They don 't care about who dies, and will do anything to make everyone follow their rules....   [tags: Water, Water resources, Water cycle, Rain]

Strong Essays
1249 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on The Book is Better than the Movie: What is a Bad Movie?

- ... In the book we can see that she uses her critical thinking to interpret all her situations and figure out why things are happening, based on the knowledge she already know. Using this skill helps her overcome her struggles, for example, during the beginning days of the Hunger Games Katniss almost died of dehydration. For the first two days she spent all her time trying to find water and collapses on the ground thats when she starts thinking of a reason why Haymitch won't send her any water and she sees it as a message that the only “one good reason Haymitch could be withholding water from [her] is because he knows [she’s] almost found it.”(169) Besides the book showing her skills it also...   [tags: the hunger games, control the people]

Strong Essays
1275 words (3.6 pages)

Like Water for Chocolate Essay

- Alfonso Arau’s film version of his ex-wife’s novel is like a loving painting of what she was thinking when she wrote the novel. A general criticism of the film version is that it is dark and hard to view. I would argue that this was done deliberately by the director and his cinematographers (Emmanuel Lubezki and Steve Bernstien) to enhance certain scenes. As you progress through the film you notice that emotionally dark moments are dimly lit and fantasy scenes filmed through warm fuzzy filters....   [tags: Alfonso Arau, Film Analysis]

Strong Essays
972 words (2.8 pages)

Spare Parts : Book Vs. Movie Essay

- Spare Parts: Book vs. Movie It has always been said that books are better than their movies. Books give you more descriptive information of the plot. In other words, a book can give you an open imagination than the movie. Anyway, the book has many important elements, while the movie only focuses on one thing. The book Spare Parts contains a chapter per character in where it contains a biography about them, focuses on immigration, and talks somewhat about race and wealth, while the movie only focuses in assembling a water robotic out of spare parts with a low budget, and winning against colleges....   [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]

Strong Essays
1061 words (3 pages)

The Big Sleep: Novel or Movie? Essay

- The Big Sleep: Novel or Movie. Architects forever changed the urban landscape when they began building skyscrapers. After only a short while they turned away from the burdensome load-bearing walls and opted for a thin, geometric steel skeleton. The skeleton allowed more glass and embellishments; businesses could have huge windows to display their wares on bustling city streets. Raymond Chandler creates a strong skeleton of figurative language in his novel, The Big Sleep. Howard Hawks piles the importance of his movie on his famous duo, Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Free Essays
1672 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on Being There: Comparison of Book and Movie

- Being There: Comparison of Book and Movie The book, "Being There," is about a man named Chance, who is forced to move out of the house he lived in his whole life and his experience in the outside world. Based on the success of the book, the movie, "Being There," was made. The author of the book, Jerzy Kosinski, also wrote the screenplay for the movie. I think the major difference between the book and the movie is that in the book, we get to read what Chance is feeling and thinking, but in the movie, we only get to see his actions....   [tags: Being There Literature Movies Essays]

Strong Essays
1118 words (3.2 pages)

Jaws: The Movie versus the Book Essay example

- Summary by Eric Dillon Steven Spielberg’s Jaws was a branch off the novel Jaws written by Peter Benchley . The Novel was written in 1974 receiving a best sellers award and therefore setting up for a movie just one year later in 1975, which soon invented the phrase “blockbuster”which simply is to gross over 100 million dollars. Since this was a highly publicized and successful novel Steven Spielberg was held to a high expectation for this movie to be an ultimate hit. The book and the movie have a lot of differences....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
893 words (2.6 pages)

The Ten Commandments Movie vs The Book of Exodus Essay

- The Ten Commandments is a movie about the book of Exodus and Moses. The movie began at the first order to kill all Hebrews under the age of two. Here Moses is cast off into the Nile and the story begins. It ends with the end of Moses’s life and Joshua taking over. The movie, for the most part, stayed true to the book of Exodus, but some detail and major plotline were different. The movie was good, but the added love story and power struggle made the movie a little off topic. The story itself, Moses being adopted, raised, sent away, and then came back and freed the people is the same, so Exodus is followed in a general way....   [tags: film review and comparison with the original]

Strong Essays
1013 words (2.9 pages)