The Legal Systems Of A Common Law System Essay

The Legal Systems Of A Common Law System Essay

Length: 1402 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Worldwide, the legal systems of nearly all countries are generally modelled upon five main types: civil law, common law, customary law, mixed or pluralistic law and religious law (CIA, 2015). In the CIA’s listing, Australia’s legal system is described as a “common law system” based on the English model.
Historically, the common law system began in England in the 11th century with the establishment of Kings Courts by William the Conqueror. The courts presided over local disputes where local customs were applied to make decisions. Over time, these customs became rules and were the basis for later courts to make decisions on similar disputes. As the range and type of dispute broadened, so did the range of decisions. The accumulation of judges’ decisions over time is what is called ‘common law’ (James, Muston & Rice, 2014). As such common law is often referred to as ‘judge-made’ law (Public Interest Advocacy Centre, 2011 )
Judges are required to give reasons for their decision. These decisions have been recorded over many years and published as law reports (Barravecchio, 2016). These form the body of prior knowledge, which common law judges read as the primary source of common law.

When Australia became federated in 1901, the role of government increased in the area of law making. This developed into our current system where there are three main ways that laws of Australia are made. These are: 1) Parliaments pass Acts known as ‘statute law’; 2) the executive develops ‘delegated legislation’, which is, regulations, rules, ordinances etc, under the authority of parliament and statute law; and 3) courts interpret the law, and decide cases on the basis of how similar cases have been decided in the past and apply those decisions to th...

... middle of paper ...

...ers (The News Manual, 2008)
Also, the English doctrine of stare decisis compels lower courts to follow decisions rendered in higher courts. This establishes an order of priority by “reason of authority“. Stare decisis is unknown to civil law, where judgments rendered by judge are the “authority of reason“(Tetley, 1999).
While both legal systems, civil and common, are tasked with the same purpose, it is clear that the process used by each is different. The civil law with its top down approach, legislature written laws, rigid application to rules and processes and an inquisitorial style is in stark contrast to the common law system in which Australia operates. Here there is an adversarial style, a bottom-up case driven system, where judges determine the laws under the doctrine of precedent and principles of stare decisis to create a system that is fair and consistent.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Social Justice Systems And Civil Law System Essays

- If I was wrongfully accused of a crime, I believe that the Civil Law system would allow better opportunities for me to be properly acquitted. Today, there are two major social justice systems: Common Law system and Civil Law system. Although both systems have a desire to ultimately restore peace, serve justice, and punish offenders, the Civil Law system is more advantageous and equitable for its followers. The Common Law system is primarily used in English-speaking countries and societies. Originally, credited to be primarily established in England it has had great influence on America through its constitution....   [tags: Common law, Law, Adversarial system, Civil law]

Better Essays
827 words (2.4 pages)

Common Law : Common And Civil Law System Essay

- 1.a What is the meaning of the term common law and what are the characteristics of a common law system. Throughout the world there are two types of legal systems; common and civil law. The most prevalent is the Civil law system, which grew from Roman law. The less frequently occurring of the two systems is the Common Law system, with only 27% of the world’s 320 legal jurisdictions using Common Law. Common law can refer to any legal jurisdiction that is using the English system. Common law is case law, a more flexible system of law by contrast to civil law....   [tags: Common law, Law, Civil law, Statute]

Better Essays
1537 words (4.4 pages)

Comparing Justice Systems And American Justice System Essay examples

- When it comes to comparing justice systems, it’s common to compare America and Singapore to one another. Singapore is considered a sterile country with one of the lowest crime rates in the world, but is known for its seemingly strange laws and harsh punishments. America, on the other hand, has a rather high crime rate as well as incarceration rate despite having a gentler justice system in comparison. Despite portraying both as opposites, both are based on English common law, and there’s more focus on punishing criminals instead of rehabilitating them....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Common law]

Better Essays
923 words (2.6 pages)

Benefits of the Common Law legal System Essay

- A legal system is a system used for interpreting and enforcing the laws. The most original or commonly know legal system that has shaped much of what exists today is know as the Common Law. There are three major legal systems of legal procedure; each having their own set of rules called criminal procedure guidelines. These three systems are the adversarial, inquisitorial, and popular (mixed) systems of criminal procedure (Dammer & Albanese, 2011). The adversarial system is a legal system used in the Common Law countries, such as England and the United States, where two advocates represent their parties’ positions before an impartial person or group of people, usually a jury or judge, who att...   [tags: politics, legal system]

Better Essays
2129 words (6.1 pages)

Differences Between The Libyan Legal Systems And The Uk Legal System Essay

- THE SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE LIBYAN LEGAL SYSTEM AND THE UK LEGAL SYSTEM. Rabi. H. Khamis.   There is no doubt that the legal system is the only way to organize the societies as well as it is different from country to another , in addition a significant role has been played to developing and dominating the relationship between countries .furthermore ,the organization of relations between people At the present time approximately all countries a following specific legal system and that trapped between two type systems, namely the Latin and the Anglo Saxon....   [tags: Law, Common law, Court, Appeal]

Better Essays
1207 words (3.4 pages)

The Common Law And Criminal Justice System Essay

- The criminal justice system, prisons being part of it has made a huge impact on those be convicted for the use or possession of drugs. However, with the help of resources and influence there are ways to get off or have a less of a sentence by money and power. Though if money and power isn’t an option for them art is a way to provide prisoners rehabilitation and healing who have been involved by the criminalization of drugs. The Common Law, Criminal Justice System is one of three types of legal systems....   [tags: Criminal justice, Prison, Law, Crime]

Better Essays
1353 words (3.9 pages)

The Law And Civil Law Systems Essay

- Deciding Cases in the Common Law and Civil Law Systems I Problems with Retroactive Rule-Making Retroactive rule-making is applying a legal rule or law to conduct that has already occurred before the making of the rule. What makes the rules of a legal system legitimate is justice. People need to know the law and what it is so they can follow it. Legal systems frown upon or may prohibit retroactive rule-making because it does not enable people to predict the legal implications of their actions or behaviour....   [tags: Common law, Law, Appeal, Judge]

Better Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)

Essay On Common Law And Civil Law

- Vanessa Covarrubias Dr. Kopp CRJU 360 26 November 2017 Common and Civil Law Traditions Every nation has their own set of legal strategies they use to guide them in making important decisions. Each nation has its traditions and policies they follow. Through the world, there are two main types of legal systems that are used; most nations follow either common or civil law. Both the common law system and the civil law system share similarities in having courts, judges, and comparing cases to laws....   [tags: Common law, Civil law, Law, Codification]

Better Essays
1207 words (3.4 pages)

The Civil Law And Common Law Tradition Essay

- Legal codes in the judicial system is the key distinction between the civil law and common law tradition. It is the supreme source of justice in a society and is meant to provide the common good for a society. Whether or not a country is governed by a civil or common law code greatly influences the role of the judiciary system. Including the presence and role of judicial review. Given these points, civil law clashes with the theory of individualism, therefore this tradition could not work in the American system....   [tags: Common law, Law, Civil law, Judge]

Better Essays
703 words (2 pages)

Differences and Similarities between the Civil and Common Law Judicial System

- ... Another fundamental difference between these two legal systems is their trial system. The civil law uses an inquisitorial system that is based on investigation, and the common law system uses an adversarial system that is based on the dispute where two opposing lawyers represent their parties in front of the decision maker. In an adversary system the judge and jury as decision makers have a passive role in investigating and gathering evidence and are responsible solely in deciding the case. In contrast, in an inquisitorial system the judge holds a very active role in the process, by choosing which evidence to accept and applying the law to the evidence in deciding the case....   [tags: achieving justice through the legal system]

Better Essays
1122 words (3.2 pages)