Essay on Legal Issues in Healhthcare

Essay on Legal Issues in Healhthcare

Length: 933 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the case of Michael T. Vandall, M.D., Plaintiff and Appellant v. Trinity Hospitals, a corporation, and Margaret C. Nordell, M.D., the issue is about retaliatory discharge. It deals with problems with Trinity Hospital in North Dakota, Dr. Margaret Nordell and Dr. Michael Vandall, both physicians working in the OB-GYN department.
Dr. Vandall was hired in 1996 by Trinity Hospital under the Physician Services Agreement. The Physicians Services Act, or PSA is a contract that establishes terms of engagement, such as responsibilities, scheduling, salary and insurance. PSAs are a form of alignment between hospitals and physicians that falls just short of full employment. Hospital contracts physicians for certain, outlined professional services, and the hospital directly employs the group staff and takes care of the administrative costs (Herman, 2012).
While working at the OB-GYN department in the hospital, Dr. Vandall, as a Vice Chair of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, learned that another employee of the hospital, Dr. Margaret Nordell was engaged in a level of treatment that was unethical and violated accepted standards of care. It was his duty to the hospital and to the patients, to monitor the competence of his staff members. Although he tried to take the proper steps to deal with it within the hospital, he ended up reporting this to the North Dakota Board of Medical Examiners. It was concluded by the Board that the treatment of Dr. Nordell was gross negligence and they suspended her license to practice medicine.
Dr. Vandall did what the law required him to do when he learned what was going on. After that, Dr. Nordell began filing many complaints against Dr. Vandall, stating that he was "looking at her patient's...


... middle of paper ...


...s concern for the patients. There was no danger to his life, no person was getting threatened in front of him or property being destroyed, as what happened in the staged films, but I'm certain he was aware of the legal proceedings that would occur. He still went through with his decision to do the right thing. Dr. Vandall was living up to his ethical duties by reporting the actions of Dr. Nordell and followed thorough with his rights to protect himself when dealing with the hospital. Sometimes the simplest and best intentions end up turning into complicated matters, but that is a risk we need to take. When it comes to legal proceedings, it is best to know as much as possible in order to have a favorable outcome. I believe that starts with doing the right thing in the first place. But if that isn't possible, make sure you know your resources to get the help you need.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Ethical And Legal Issues Of Healthcare

- Introduction Managed care plans present as forms of health insurance covers. These plans have contracts with medical facilities and health care providers to offer care for clients at decreased costs (Dixon, Greene & Hibbard, 2008). This paper will discuss the criticisms that have been addressed regarding managed care, and the different features that are included in a CDHP. Additionally, it will discuss the existing differences between the choice of providers, cost sharing, and covered benefits of HMOs and CDHPs....   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health economics]

Better Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Healthcare Associated Infections (HAIs) Essay

- Healthcare-associates Infections (HAIs) are infections that patients acquire during the course of receiving healthcare treatment for other conditions and can be devastating or even deadly ("CDC - HAIs the Burden - HAI", 2013). An HAI was defined as a localized or systemic condition that (1) results from an adverse reaction to the pres¬ence of an infectious agent(s) or its toxin(s), (2) that occurs during a hospital admission, (3) for which there is no evidence the infection was present or incubating at admission, and (4) meets body site-specific criteria (Klevens et al., 2007, p.2)....   [tags: legal issues, direct legal issues]

Better Essays
1930 words (5.5 pages)

Legal and Ethical Issues Encountered in Health and Social Care: Elderly People with Dementia in Residential Home.

- This assignment will identify and evaluate the legal and ethical issues within the health and social care for elderly people with dementia and living in residential homes. It will address the difference between the legal and ethical issues and the impact it has on the person suffering from the disease, their family and the role that the professionals have in decision making for the individual’s wellbeing. Dementia is a disease which causes mental debility and affects one’s way of intelligent, attentiveness, recollection and problem-solving (NHS, 2013)....   [tags: health, social, cause, ethical, issues. legal]

Better Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Legal, Regulatory, And Ethical Issues

- Legal, regulatory, and ethical issues in healthcare administration are similarly misinterpreted with the words, morals, beliefs, or even opinions. This student has learned throughout her studies Polk that every healthcare issue has more beneath the surface than it seems. Thus, every healthcare issue that deals with regulatory and legal issues will also have an ethical component as well. One of the bachelor’s courses taken in this program (HSA 4553-Legal and Ethical Issues in Healthcare) has taught this student how there is always two sides to every dilemma, even though it might seem as there is only one....   [tags: Ethics, Philosophy, Morality]

Better Essays
701 words (2 pages)

Essay about Legal Issues In Reduction Of Workforce

- July 2007 Legal Issues in Reduction of Workforce Candidates Key Concepts of employment law Brian Carter Discrimination based on disabilities: The Americans with Disabilities Act prohibits employer discrimination against job applicants or employees based on whether the employee had a disability in the past or whether the employee has any disabilities or is being regarded as having a disability. Physical and mental impairment includes physical disorders or conditions, disease, disfigurement, amputation affecting a vital body system, psychological disorders, mental retardation, mental illness, and learning disabilities....   [tags: Legal Case Study]

Free Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

Legal, Financial And Ethical Issues Essay

- “Meaningful Use” implemented in July, 2010, set criteria’s for physicians and hospitals to adhere, in order to qualify for certain financial incentives and to be deemed meaningful users (MU) of the EMR. Meaningful use in healthcare is defined as using certified electronic health record to improve quality, safety, efficiency, and reduce mortality and morbidity. There are 3 stages of meaningful use implementation. The requirements for the 3 stages are spread out over a period of 5 years. MU mandates that physicians meet 15 core objectives and hospitals meet 14 core objectives (Hoffman & Pudgurski, 2011)....   [tags: Health care, Electronic health record]

Better Essays
1274 words (3.6 pages)

Marijuana Should Be Legal Essay

- Marijuana is the fifth most addicting drug in the United States (Henningfield). An even more shocking fact is that two states, Washington and Colorado, have made it legal for recreational use. Just like alcohol. Marijuana used to be legal, up until 1937 when it became illegal with the Marijuana Tax Act. It was only in March 2011 that medical marijuana was legalized in Washington, Colorado, and Alaska because of sick people who had a variety of sick diseases ("Legal History of Cannabis in the United States")....   [tags: legal issues, drugs]

Free Essays
964 words (2.8 pages)

Marijuana Should Be Legal Essay

- America’s controversial debate over whether marijuana should be legalized has been baffling many communities and citizens for some time now. Due to the vital decision being made by the government, many political and federal aspects are being considered. Marijuana has been used pharmaceutically tracing back all the way to ancient times and is legal to use for medical purposes in the United States. Marijuana’s medical uses should be enough to have the plant considered a legal substance. Medicinal use of cannabis has been unearthed for thousands of years as treatment for whooping cough, constipation, lower fevers, and rheumatic pains, to induce sleep, and reduce headaches....   [tags: legal issues, marijuana]

Better Essays
1788 words (5.1 pages)

Legal Tension, Social Issues, and the OJ Simpson Trial Essay

- ... It’s the kind of trial that books are written about. A celebrity football player charged with murder is brought to trial for the world to see. In the 1990s, there was a vast amount of tensions in the legal system, which not only affected this case, but was also planted in the minds of every person familiar with the trial. Illegal immigration was a hot topic; race riots were on the rise, and instances of police brutality were hot button topics as well, in addition to the typical political topics including war overseas....   [tags: homocide, trail issues, society]

Better Essays
785 words (2.2 pages)

Overview of Data Encryption and Legal Issues Essay

- Overview of Data Encryption and Legal Issues What is encryption and why do we need it. The concept of encrypting information has been popular for hundreds of years. Revolutionaries, scientists, political activists and lovers have utilized this technique to maintain privacy and confidentiality in their communications. As kids, we would take our secret messages and shift the letters of the alphabet by a specific number to create an encrypted message. For example, by shifting the letters of the alphabet by three we could change the word cyberlaw to fbehuodz....   [tags: Privacy Legal Essays]

Better Essays
2221 words (6.3 pages)