Leila And Soudabeh Case Study

1354 Words3 Pages

The witness is married and has three children. Her husband, Abdul Maroof, teaches literature. Two of her daughters, Leila and Soudabeh, died in the airplane crash on May 17, 2107, as they were flying from Kabul to Kunduz. All of her children were living with her at the time of the occurrence. She understands a little English, but she cannot read or write it. The witness works in the legal field for the Afghan government and “the people”, but she is not a licensed attorney. In this matter, she serves as the main contact person for the other families that filed the lawsuit. There are no attorneys in Afghan representing the Afghan families. They have attorneys in Chicago and New York, but she does not remember their names. According …show more content…

She would give some of her earnings to the witness, who used it to help pay the family expenses. Soudabeh would also pay for other family members’ needs. All of the family members contributed money toward the payment of the family’s expenses. According to the witness, Leila was born in 1980, and she was 29 on the date of the incident. (The plaintiffs’ answers to discovery list her date of birth as June 30, 1983, which would have made her 26 on the date of the occurrence.) Leila started working as an anchorwoman on local television in the tenth grade. At the time of the accident, she was an attorney and earned $600 (US) per month. Leila would spend $100 US, or about 6,000 Afghani, per month on herself and give the witness the same each month. Leila would contribute about $300 US, or approximately 18,000 Afghani, each month to the family. Leila was also giving Soudabeh money, but the witness did not know the amount. According to the witness, Leila was one month away from being a judge and would have earned 150,000 Afghani per month, which she estimated to be about $2,500 US. The witness felt that Leila would have kept 50,000 Afghani each month for her and her husband and she would have given the rest of her salary to the …show more content…

He was not married on in May 2010 and he was a student and worked part-time. Their other brothers, Abdul Latif (born in 1987) and Abdul Majid (born in 1989) were students and had neither married by the time of the occurrence. Pamir initially paid the family $10,000 for each daughter that died in the crash resulting in a total initial payment of $20,000. The Afghan government later paid the family an additional $13,636.36 from Pamir’s funds for each of their two daughters that died in the accident for a total second payment of $27,272.72. The witness testified that this was a pre-settlement payment from the airline to help pay for the expenses relating to the funeral and mourning period. According to the witness, this was not fair and reasonable compensation for the death. They have received no other payments. All of the other witness’ children are still alive and no one in her family has or had any serious illnesses or

Open Document