Essay on Legal Case Analysis

Essay on Legal Case Analysis

Length: 1839 words (5.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Legal Case Analysis

1. In this matter I am asked to advise those instructing me as to whether the prosecution can adduce evidence of a written statement of a witness unwilling to testify at trial and secondly how her evidence might be presented if she decides to give evidence at trial.

2. I understand that Chrissie lives within close proximity to the scene of the crime and is in fact a ‘next door neighbour’.


3. Anterior to Chrissie’s involvement, the victim, Bella, was attacked in her bedroom by an intruder wearing a balaclava. The intruder broke into the house through the kitchen window and repeatedly stabbed her with a ‘large knife’.

4. Bella did not see the attacker’s face, but perhaps by serendipity, Chrissie caught a ‘brief glimpse of the attacker’s face’ when the attacker ran out of the house, taking off his balaclava and running away in the opposite direction.


5. I was initially inclined to address the evidential issue of suspect identification, encapsulated in the Turnbull principles as Chrissie caught only a ‘brief glimpse’ of the attackers face. However, instructing solicitors have advised that presently, this is not germane.

6. This antecedent opinion was made admittedly extemporarily. I have since engaged in more prodigious and thorough research of relevant case law and statutes and will advise instructing solicitors accordingly.
7. Chrissie gave a full statement to the police and identified Alex at a ‘properly conducted identification procedure’ prima facie in conformity with section 9 of the Criminal Justice Act 1967.

8. Consequently, Chrissie has since received a number of threatening telephone calls, and remains obstinate about giving evidence against Alex at trial. The most pertinent...


... middle of paper ...


...-Taylor [2006] EWCA Crim, (2006)
13) R-v-Thomas [1998] Crim LR 887, CA
14) R v Turnbull 1976, 63 Cr App R 132
15) R-v-Xhabri [2005] EWCA Crim 3135
16) Riat [2013] 1 Cr App R 2
17) Shabir (Mohammed Hanees) [2012] EWCA Crim 2564
18) Teper v R [1952] ac 480

Statutes
1) Criminal Justice Act 1967
2) Criminal Justice Act 2003
3) European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms 1950
4) Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999

Secondary Sources
Journals and text books
1) Adam Webster, ‘International Journal of Evidence and Proof: Horncastle v R: statements from witnesses absent at trial.’[2009]
2) Collin Tapper, Cross &Tapper on Evidence (12th Edition, Oxford University Press 2010)
3) Liz Hefernan, ‘Hearsay in Criminal Trials: the Strasbourg Perspective’ [2013]
4) Roderick Munday, Evidence (7th edition , Oxford University Press, 2013)

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Article 15 ECHR: Derogation in Case of Emergency, Lawless v Ireland (1961)

- Critical Assessment Innovations The judgement of the Lawless case was the ECtHR’s first one. Since the Convention remains silent on many organisational aspects, the first hearings before the Court gave rise to many procedural questions. Ireland raised several objections regarding the procedure, which were rejected by the Court. Another aspect that was not yet regulated was the judgement style. The ECtHR adopted the French style, where the judgement is basically structured along one long sentence....   [tags: Legal Case Analysis]

Strong Essays
1760 words (5 pages)

Forensic Evidence Admissibility For or Against in the Bloodsworth v. State Case

- In this position paper I have chosen Bloodsworth v. State ~ 76 Md.App. 23, 543 A.2d 382 case to discuss on whether or not the forensic evidence that was submitted for this case should have been admissible or not. To understand whether or not the evidence should be admissible or not we first have to know what the case is about. This case started on July 25, 1984, with the death of a nine year old girl by the name of Dawn Hamilton. The story plays out as follows: Dawn approached two boys and an adult male that were fishing at a pond in a wooded area near Golden Ring Mall in eastern Baltimore, Maryland....   [tags: legal case analysis]

Strong Essays
1944 words (5.6 pages)

Essay on Ann Hopkins/Price Waterhouse Sex Discrimation Case Analysis

- Facts: In 1978, Ann Hopkins began working for Price Waterhouse. Price Waterhouse policy prohibited hiring anyone who was married to a partner or had a close relationship with a partner in a national accounting firm. Hopkins husband was a partner at Touche Ross. Nevertheless, Price Waterhouse honored their offer and hired Hopkins anyway. Ann Hopkins was a senior manager at Price Waterhouse in the firm's Office of Government Services (OGS) in 1982 when she was nominated for partnership. OGS' nominating proposal praised Hopkins "outstanding performance" and said it was "virtually at partnership level." It underlined Hopkins "key role" in connection with a large State Department project....   [tags: Legal Case Analysis]

Strong Essays
1642 words (4.7 pages)

Seperate Is Not Equal Essay

- Separate is Not Equal The decision rendered by the United States Supreme Court on May 17, 1954, was one of the most defining moments in American history. A multiethnic movement for social change developed into a legal campaign aimed at altering the constitutional basis of government in the United States. This struggle was not only about children and their education, but also about issues of race and equal opportunity in America. The decision of Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka initiated educational and social reform throughout the United States....   [tags: Legal Case Study Analysis]

Strong Essays
1539 words (4.4 pages)

Analysis of the Paul Cronan Case Essay

- Analysis of the Paul Cronan Case I. Legal Analysis, Issue 1 Issue: Does party bringing suit (Plaintiff – Paul Cronan) qualify under the ADA for disability. Rule: In Review of ADA and the principles set forth at that time, there are several relevancies to consider here. A disability is described as follows: “For purposes of nondiscrimination laws (e.g. the Americans with Disabilities Act, Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and Section 188 of the Workforce Investment Act), a person with a disability is generally defined as someone who (1) has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more "major life activities," (2) has a record of such an impairment, or...   [tags: Legal Analysis Discrimination Equality Essays]

Strong Essays
3733 words (10.7 pages)

Essay on Employment Law Case Presentation and Analysis

- ... Paige could bring a state court lawsuit based on the torts of IIED and invasion of privacy, or a federal court action based on those torts plus hostile work environment under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. She could also file a complaint with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) making similar claims under Title VII (Maatman, Jr. & Degroff, 2012), especially hostile work environment. 3) How should Paige approach any legal cause of action, and what is that cause of action....   [tags: legal and ethical issues]

Strong Essays
867 words (2.5 pages)

Case Analysis : Prosecutor 's Duty Essay

- Prosecutor’s duty is to seek justice, present the judge and jury with facts and sound legal arguments that result in the conviction of the guilty defendant and not conviction of the innocent as we have seen in many cases in the past. They have a duty also to disclose exculpatory evidence to the defense attorney (Burke, 2010. P. 2135). Prosecutors consist of the group of criminal justice professionals with no accountability for their professional action or deliberate inaction. They willfully manipulate facts and evidences in order to secure a conviction at all cost....   [tags: Criminal law, Crime, Legal terms, Lawyer]

Strong Essays
1126 words (3.2 pages)

Case Analysis : Christie Jr. Essay example

- COMPLAINT Bozena Czeremcha, submitted a complaint on April 14, 2015, regarding William Y. Christie Jr., Esq. As a former paralegal for Christie Jr., Czeremcha alleges that the staff in the office essentially worked unsupervised, Christie Jr. misused his IOLTA funds, signed a release without his client’s consent, sent an inexperienced attorney to handle his matters in court, and had a substance abuse problem. Christie Jr. has allegedly violated Mass.R.Prof.C 1.4(a)&(b), 1.6(a), 1.15(b), 5.1, 5.2, 5.3(a)&(b), 8.4(a), and 8.4(c)....   [tags: Pleading, Cause of action, Legal terms, Lawyer]

Strong Essays
1408 words (4 pages)

Business Law Case Analysis Essays

- Business Law Case Analysis Plaintiff: Panitia Penyelesaian Perselisihan Perburuhan Pusat (P4P) Defendant: PT. Bouraq Indonesia Airlines Case Background The defendant is an Airlines Company that had 900 employees. The economic crisis followed with monetary crisis gave bad effects to the defendant. They should decrease the number of their airplanes form 9 to 2 airplanes. They also had to do the efficiency on their employees to 700....   [tags: Business Law Legal Law]

Free Essays
736 words (2.1 pages)

Business Law Case Study Essay

- The University of Rummidge organises a conference entitled "Law for small Businesses" which is followed by a luncheon at the Grand Hotel. Jim, a law lecturer, is a speaker at the conference and the conference is attended by Albert who has just started a graphic design business and Percy a well-established market gardener. At the conference Albert meets Barry, a fellow student from University days, whom he has not seen for some time. During lunch, while discussing pension investments, Barry tells Albert that if he (Albert) invests some money in Dunmore Limited (of which Barry is a director), he will obtain a good return on his investment....   [tags: Analysis Business Legal]

Free Essays
1517 words (4.3 pages)