Essay about Koch vs. Virchow

Essay about Koch vs. Virchow

Length: 1225 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Koch believes that most health issues arise because of biological issues, and thus can only be cured with medical advancement. On the other hand, Virchow believed that the main cause of adverse health was because of poverty and biological principles. Both men have fantastic arguments, but to see which makes more sense in our modern world, we will have to delve into some real world examples. First we will take a look at an article on malaria, which is scholarly work by Packard. Secondly we will analyze a video on Guatemala’s new approach to health care. And lastly I will bring up a real world example on the Colorado Haiti Project. While looking at these three very different subjects, I will conclude whether these regions side with Koch or Virchow.
First let us look at Packard’s articles that he wrote on malaria. Packard gave many examples of why and how malaria spread rapidly in some regions. The first examples are as follows, “The drought that damaged the crops and undermined peoples’ resistance to disease, the subsequent flooding that produced breeding conditions for local anopheline mosquitoes, and the mass migration of people in search of food who returned infected with malaria (Packard, 2).” In this example Packard states that the spread of malaria was a result of three specific actions. The first action was the drought, which was followed later by the flooding, and lastly mass migrations. All three of these things had to be in play in order for malaria to spread in the Archangel region. But the argument stands, who is right in this situation? Koch or Virchow. In the following example, I think that Virchow holds the upper hand. These people had a lack of wealth and government development, and because of that they were affec...


... middle of paper ...


... at the real world example about the Colorado Haiti Project, which also has the same outlook as our other examples, Virchow. In conclusion, I would like to say that biology is very important aspect for health in nations, but without structural integrity of the people and governments disease will always be on the rise.



Works Cited
Butterfoss, F. D., R. M. Goodman, and A. Wandersman. "Community Coalitions for Prevention and Health Promotion: Factors Predicting Satisfaction, Participation, and Planning." Health Education & Behavior 23.1 (1996): 65-79. Print.

No Author. "Mission | Colorado Haiti Project." Colorado Haiti Project Mission Comments. N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Nov. 2013. .

Packard, Randall M. The Making of a Tropical Disease: A Short History of Malaria. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins UP, 2007. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Christof Koch and the Theory of Consciousness Essay

- Consciousness was first described and introduced by Sigmund Freud and Friedrich Nietzsche (Crick & Koch, 2001). It has been described as a realm of the mind that controls human behaviour. However consciousness is not accessible to conscious introspection, self-examination or a source of knowledge. On the contrary, Christof Koch, a neuroscientist collaborator of Francis Crick, describes unconsciousness as any neuronal activity that does not give rise to conscious sensation, thought or memory (Crick & Koch, 2001)....   [tags: Consciousness]

Better Essays
2734 words (7.8 pages)

Analysis Of ' The Dinner ' By Herman Koch Essay

- Money—in the form of gold bars or paper faces, currency has been a system used in almost every modern society to regulate exchange and to represent wealth. While it is an effective bureaucratic system, money creates inevitable social divides. In the vein of philosopher and sociologist Karl Marx in his famous work, The Communist Manifesto, the haves and have-nots are in a constant struggle between oppressor and oppressed. The Dinner, a novel by Herman Koch, chronicles a brief encounter between the narrator and main character, Paul, Claire, Serge, and Babette, his wife, brother, and his sister-in-law, respectively....   [tags: Karl Marx, Marxism, Working class, Social class]

Better Essays
793 words (2.3 pages)

Robert Koch Essay

- Robert Koch was a physician and a scientist. According to Blevins and Bronze (2010), his work “launched the new field of medical bacteriology,” and “ushered in a ‘golden age’ of scientific discovery and a new era of public health” (p. E744). Brock (1999) claimed Robert Koch was “one of the most important figures in medical science and was also the founder of bacteriology” (p. xxi). How did one man accomplish so much and impact the world around him in such a profound way. The three areas that must be examined in order to unveil the magnitude of influence that he possessed are as follows: • The Life of Robert Koch • Microscopes, Research, and Revolutionary Discoveries • Beyond one man These to...   [tags: Biography, Physician, Scientist]

Better Essays
2495 words (7.1 pages)

Rudolf Virchow: The Link Between Inflamation and Cancer Essay

- Introduction In the 19th century, Rudolf Virchow observed the presence of leukocytes within tumor tissues. This observation made the first possible link between inflammation and cancer. Over the past two decades our understanding of inflammation and cancer has supported Virchow’s observations (1). Up to 15 % of global cancers have been associated to infections, furthermore there is strong evidence that chronic inflammation, and autoimmune reactions can increase the risk of cancer (2). Inflammation can act as initiator of cancer, since local inflammation enriches tissue in oxygen, nitrogen and free radicals that kill pathogens, and can directly cause DNA damage, and DNA mutations (3)....   [tags: tumors, therapeutic strategies]

Better Essays
1440 words (4.1 pages)

Minorities Say, “DUMP KOCH”: Mayor Koch and His Troubled Relationship with Minorities

- Love him or hate him, no one can deny that Ed Koch loved his city. Often described as New York’s “Quintessential Mayor,” Koch had none of the glamor that one expects from a person in such a formidable position. Like the city he took control of in 1977, he was loud, brash, imperfect, yet proud. Above all his memorable characteristics, his firmness in his beliefs defined his leadership. “Part of the thing that was most refreshing and most appalling about Koch is that he will stand for what he believes in," Reverend Al Sharpton, one of Koch’s great critics, said of Koch....   [tags: New York, Discrimination, Politician]

Better Essays
763 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Norma Jean Koch and Her Stories

- ... Not a year later the eldest of her family, Lucy, was born. The story of Lucy ended with a tragic twist. After a heart attack and a stroke rendered her unable to walk, she took her own life at the mercy of a bullet. But Jean’s life had much more interesting detail. She was born in a small town 30 miles South of St. Joseph. A town of 500 people. She lived there until age three when they moved to Arkansas City, to 405 West Chestnut Street. She, at the time, went to Frans Miller School until 1935....   [tags: journey, life, history, love]

Better Essays
532 words (1.5 pages)

Essay about Reasons for Edward Koch's Promotion of the Death Sentence

- Since 1976 over 1350 people have been executed in the United States (Facts about the Death Penalty). In 1985 Edward Koch published an article on the New Republic discussing the death penalty. Serving 22 years in public service as a district leader, councilman, congressman, and mayor, Edward Koch has heard all the pros and cons of the death penalty (4). With that knowledge and experience Mr. Koch begins discussing, as well as promoting the death penalty. The arguments used against the death penalty range from religious concerns such as “Thou shalt not kill” (12), to more in-depth government related attacks like the death penalty being used as a state sanctioned murder....   [tags: punishment, murder, ignorance]

Better Essays
558 words (1.6 pages)

Edward Koch and AIDS in New York City Essay

- ... People were proud of their city as major sports teams were bring in championships, artwork around the city was being installed around the city and public spaces were being restored. It was a great time to live in New York City and it was attracting people from all over the world. Moreover, gay men and women from all over the country were flocking in from small towns to this major metropolitan area in order find people like themselves and escape the oppression they faced from their home communities....   [tags: rights, gays, justice, leader]

Better Essays
1990 words (5.7 pages)

Comparing Death And Justice : How Capital Punishment Affirms Life By Edward Koch And The Death Penalty

- Justifying the Death Penalty: An Analysis of Two Essays “Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them. Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement” (Tolkien, 1994.) Capital punishment, or more commonly known as the death penalty, has been a hotly controversial issue throughout the history of humankind. Some people have the view that Hammurabi had in his own law code, “an eye for an eye,” whereas others believe that it is wrong to kill another person no matter the nature of their crime....   [tags: Capital punishment, Murder, Death row, Crime]

Better Essays
1073 words (3.1 pages)

Advancing the Argument, Analyzing Modes of Persuasion in Edward I. Koch’s 1985 Essay “Death and Justice”

- What does rhetoric have to do with capital punishment. Plenty actually if you want to advance an argument as well as Edward I. Koch has in his compelling essay in support of the death penalty. Koch is introduced by the editors of the book containing his essay as “The feisty, opinionated mayor of New York City…” (handout). The editors continue describing Koch’s character and abilities as they point out that he is politician with a law degree and experience as a lawyer. More specifically that he was a leader for the Democratic Party and then a congressman (handout)....   [tags: rhetoric, capital punishment]

Better Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)