Kidney Thieves Urban Legend

Kidney Thieves Urban Legend

Length: 1079 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Losing Organs at a Party: The "Kidney Thieves" Legend and the Immigrant Experience

My family, most being first generation immigrants, has at times a slightly negative view of American culture. Because of this, many of the family dinner conversations are about the differences between American and Iranian cultures and often how the Iranian culture is better in some ways. To support this theory many urban legends are brought up that show the “dark side” of the American culture. For example, when the family was gathered together for the Iranian new year, a version of the famous legend about the traveler who was drugged and robbed of his organs in a hotel room was told by a family member. It is important to note that he told the story in Farsi, which means that I am translating and not merely re-telling the story verbatim.

The storyteller's version of the story was about an Iranian foreign exchange student who had recently come to the US. The story begins with the student, being alone in this country, going to a party he had heard of from other students. In the party, having had a few drinks, another “American thing” my family is against, he met a beautiful innocent girl who offered him a drink and asked to go to his place at the end of the night. The tone with which he described the girl was specially interesting, noting that even the innocent looking girls cannot be trusted. The story goes that the Iranian student did not remember anything from that point on until he woke up the next day in his bathtub covered with ice. There was also a note next to him telling him not to move and call 911. When the ambulance arrived at his apartment he was told that his kidney was removed and that he was not the first person this has happened to. To add to the accuracy and suspense of the story, the storyteller, a physician, mentioned how the ice was used to keep the student’s body cold to prevent excessive blood loss and inflammation, which was essentially what kept him alive. After being discharged from the hospital for a few weeks with a missing kidney, a big hospital bill, and having fallen behind his studies, the student found out that there is an organized ring of organ thieves who specialize in lonely foreign students, who are as the storyteller sees it, more susceptible to being seduced by girls.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Kidney Thieves Urban Legend." 24 Jun 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Urban Legend of the Kidney Thieves Essay

- The Kidney Thieves Urban legends are apocryphal stories involving incidents of the recent past, often including elements of humor and horror that spread quickly and are popularly believed to be true (1). They reflect society's deepest fears and anxieties. One urban legend can be retold with different settings and people, but the central theme or idea remains constant. The appeal of these legends is the possibility they can be true and that they bring out the listeners' deepest fears. The storyteller in the following urban legend is a nineteen-year old man from Annapolis, Maryland....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Research Papers
1455 words (4.2 pages)

Urban Legend of the The Monster's Chase Essays

- The Monster's Chase Background and Story It was late on a weekday night a couple of weeks ago when I was unexpectedly told an urban legend by a friend of mine in my dorm. I brought up a report I had to prepare about a local urban legend and my desire to find someone who knew a tale of the “Goatman,” a famous figure in folklore. My friend immediately recounted to me a story about a hairy monster that sounded rather similar. He had been told the story by a member of his group one night at a youth hostel in Japan during an organized trip....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Research Papers
1216 words (3.5 pages)

The Clown Doll: An Urban Legend Essay

- The Clown Doll: An Urban Legend When my friends and I were younger, we loved to tell each other scary stories late at night at sleepovers. This memory resurfaced this past February as three friends and I exchanged tales late one night while on a trip in New Jersey. All of the stories were entertaining, but this purportedly “true” urban legend remained in my mind long after the other accounts. “The Clown Doll” was told by a twenty-year old, Christian female University biology major. She was born and raised in Pittsburg, PA, which is where she heard the story and where the story itself is set....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Research Papers
1240 words (3.5 pages)

Urban Legend of The Boo Hag Essay

- The Boo Hag Background Urban legends survive through time by having three elements: “a strong basic story-appeal, a foundation in actual belief, and a meaningful message or ‘moral’” (Brunvand 10). These characteristics are not only inherent in the content of the story, but also in the performance of the story to an audience. Like an actor on stage, storytellers have the responsibility of keeping a story entertaining, yet believable, through their gestures and attitude while telling the story....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Research Papers
1810 words (5.2 pages)

Urban Legend of Car Headlights Essay

- Lights Out In preparation for this writing assignment, I interviewed about 15 students at the University to collect their urban legends. One legend, often called “Lights Out,” was mentioned by just about all of the students I interviewed. Those who did not mention it on their own recognized it when I described it. I interviewed a 19-year-old male sophomore who anticipates getting into the School of Business. He transferred from Community College this past fall, and currently lives with a relative in a nearby off-campus home....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Research Papers
1488 words (4.3 pages)

Urban Legend of Humans Licking Essay

- Humans Can Lick Too I collected the story on Saturday, October 9th in my dorm. It was late at night, which added to the effect of the story. The storyteller is a student at the University. He is 17 years old, is from Rockville, Maryland, and is Methodist. He is half Sri Lankan and a quarter Irish and Palestinian. His father is a diplomat and works for the state department, and his mother is a homemaker. The story, as told by the student, is as follows: There once was a girl who lived with her parents in a nice little town....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Research Papers
1267 words (3.6 pages)

Urban Legend of the Goatman Essay example

- Goatman Version 1--Montgomery County, Maryland It seemed from my story-collection that nearly everyone knows of some urban legend, but I found one story to be especially interesting because it is a relatively famous legend that has roots here in Maryland. The story of “The Goatman” has a number of variations, as with most urban legends. My roommate told me that he first heard the story from his parents when he was about 12 years old. He suspected that it was probably a joking attempt to scare him from playing outside so late at night because the sound of the basketball dribbling in the driveway would keep his parents awake....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Research Papers
1134 words (3.2 pages)

Essay Urban Legend of Ghostly Dreams

- Ghostly Dreams of Owners Passed The following ghost story was told to me by a friend when I had a small group of friends over to my house in Massachusetts during spring break. He is a 20-year-old white male. The story was told at night after we had finished watching the show Lost on television, so the atmosphere was a little bit tense. It did not simply come up in context; I prompted all of my friends to tell any ghost stories or urban legends that they knew. I wrote the story down a few hours later after my friends left....   [tags: Urban Legends]

Free Essays
1180 words (3.4 pages)

The Urban Legend of Bloody Mary Essay

- Bloody Mary Version 3 The story of Bloody Mary is told in different versions all around the world has been included in nine different movies (three in the past two years) (The Internet Movie Database). This particular version of the popular urban legend of Bloody Mary originates locally from North Potomac, Maryland. The storyteller is a female 19-year-old Caucasian sophomore student, currently studying psychology at the University. The story was collected in the spring on the University campus....   [tags: Urban Legends Ghost Stories]

Research Papers
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Urban Legend of Bloody Mary Essay

- Bloody Mary Part One: Collection of the Story The story of “Bloody Mary” was told to me by a twenty year old male. He is a current student at a University, studying accountancy. He has very conservative beliefs regarding politics. His father is an insurance broker and his mother stays at home. This story was collected on March 18, 2006, at his residence. This is the story as he told it to me: I originally heard this from my brother when I was like ten years old. I also saw it in the movie Urban Legends....   [tags: Urban Legends Ghost Stories]

Free Essays
1082 words (3.1 pages)

The storyteller then took on a joking tone, also shown by his mockingly smile and by putting his hand on his stomach and gesturing his kidney being ripped off, when he went on to say how only in America they would rip out a person’s organs by using beautiful girls as bait. This incited small side conversations as each person was discussing the validity of the storyteller’s statement with the person sitting beside him or her.

Other versions of this legend mostly include a traveler, often in Las Vegas, or another popular tourist destination, being given a drink at a bar or lounge and waking up in a bathtub full of ice with a missing kidney. Almost all of the versions found online state the fact that the organ thieves knew what they were doing, shown by the elaborate description of the ice filled bathtub and the clean, sterile surgery. Also, as most legends go, the story happened to the friend of a relative of a friend of a friend, or some other untraceable source. The legend in this case tries to warn off lonely travelers from the possible dangers of being away from home. The thieves are mentioned to be professionals, implying that they can easily victimize anyone they choose. The untraceable source also indicates that it can happen to anyone and anywhere.

Analyzing this legend, coming from a storyteller who is roughly 40 years old and came to the US when he was in his early 20s, shows that this story is in fact rooted in the teller's experiences as a young immigrant student. When he moved to the US to finish his studies, he was alone and away from family and friends in a foreign country with different customs and culture. The differences he saw in his traditional life style and the new environment he lived in created a sense of conservatism in him. Going through the inevitable assimilation all immigrants go through when placed in a different society, the storyteller, as I suspect many others, analyzed and compared each aspect of the new culture with his own culture. He accepted those aspects that seemed to be “good” while rejecting the aspects that he saw as “bad,” either religiously, like drinking and partying, or culturally, including practices that were perhaps too different from the Iranian culture he was used to. In a sense, he tried to conserve as much of his own culture while trying to assimilate as much as he could so as to fit in better.

When it comes to the first generations children, the second generation born and raised in the US often assimilates more extensively, which to the first generation is not always a good thing. I am not sure if the reason for bringing up some specific urban legends, such as the one mentioned, is to deliberately scare the younger generation of the family from assimilating too much into the American culture, but it certainly seems to have this effect. When I asked the storyteller where he had heard this story, he said that he does not remember from whom, but it was back when he was my age. I further asked him if he thought the story was in fact true or just an urban legend, to which he replied “I don’t know, but anything’s possible in this country,” further showing his negative view on some aspects of the American culture.

What is also interesting is that when I asked the storyteller why he doesn’t move back to Iran where he was born and raised, he mentioned a few stories he has heard about how Iran has changed over the two decades he has not lived there. These urban legends showed the negative aspects of the new Iranian culture that somewhat scared him from moving back. The cultural differences this storyteller faced, backed by urban legends, are what made his move to the US difficult and now prevent him from going back to the “new” Iranian culture.
Return to