Essay on Katherine Paterson's "Jacob Have I Loved"

Essay on Katherine Paterson's "Jacob Have I Loved"

Length: 1450 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Katherine Paterson’s vivid use of imagery and symbolism brings alive the theme of overcoming the complexities of sibling rivalry in order to reclaim one’s life in “Jacob Have I Loved”. A stunning update of the classic Bible story of Jacob and Esau, Paterson recasts the brothers with sisters coming of age on the isolated island of Rass during World War II. The elder twin by mere minutes, Louise Bradshaw, finds her life immediately overshadowed by the dramatic birth of her twin sister, Caroline (Paterson 16). Caroline’s near-death experience gains the focus of not only their mother and father, but also their cantankerous grandmother (Paterson18-20). This trend continues when the residents of the small island are quickly enchanted by Caroline’s stunning voice and angelic looks (Paterson 20, 22-24). Meanwhile Louise’s tomboy behavior, independent thinking and strong demeanor does not endear her to the community (Paterson 29-31) and she struggles to keep her best friend Call and a mysterious stranger named the Captain from Caroline’s ever-growing influence (Paterson113-114). Never able to reclaim the spotlight, Louise struggles as she realizes the woman she should be is not necessarily not only what others, but especially herself, expected. Denied repeatedly by her family and friends in favor of Caroline, Louise finally finds herself once her sister leaves, taking with her what was Louise’s seemingly one chance at freedom.
The novel opens with the imagery and symbolism that is essential effectively telling the story. A grown Louise imagines the ferry ride to Rass Island she will soon take to pick up her newly widowed mother. The only way on and off the island, the ferry represents more than transportation, it is a lifeline between ...


... middle of paper ...


...n detail. With the stories progression, the reader discovers that the main characters are symbolic of those in the original Bible story and are able to identify Louise as Esau and Caroline as Jacob. Paterson’s audience makes these vital connection, clues are being given that the Captain is an earthly representation of God in the story. Meanwhile, the birthright that divides Esau and Jacob is represented in the scholarship opportunity that Louise loses to her younger twin, Caroline. With Paterson’s use of imagery, symbolism, and symbolic characters, “Jacob Have I Loved” is powerfully told and creates a tale that lingers with the reader.



Works Cited
Paterson, Katherine. Jacob Have I Loved. New York: Scholastic, 1990. Print.
Youthwalk Devotional Bible, New International Version. Ed. Dr. Bruce H. Wilkinson et al.
Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, 1997. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Katherine Paterson's "Jacob Have I Loved"

- Katherine Paterson’s vivid use of imagery and symbolism brings alive the theme of overcoming the complexities of sibling rivalry in order to reclaim one’s life in “Jacob Have I Loved”. A stunning update of the classic Bible story of Jacob and Esau, Paterson recasts the brothers with sisters coming of age on the isolated island of Rass during World War II. The elder twin by mere minutes, Louise Bradshaw, finds her life immediately overshadowed by the dramatic birth of her twin sister, Caroline (Paterson 16)....   [tags: Imagery, Symbolism, Literary Analysis]

Powerful Essays
1450 words (4.1 pages)

Analysis of Jacob Have I Loved Essay

- Louise, the protagonist of Katherine Patterson’s Jacob Have I Loved, infuriates me.  She fights against ghosts of what she wishes to be and against what she really is, kicking and screaming all the way.  I don’t debate that she struggles with good reason -- certainly the neglect from her family, whether perceived or real, and the expectations her culture (I really want to say environment here) has placed on her gender role have contributed to her plight -- but her great inner strength and insight belies her inability to overcome or at least circumvent those obstacles.  To me, she is a rebel with the sole cause of declaring her independence from her expected gender role.  And, in that, I find...   [tags: Jacob Have I Loved]

Free Essays
1888 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on Katherine Paterson's Happy or Unhappy Ending

- Katherine Paterson's Happy or Unhappy Ending Happiness seems different for all the characters, for Gilly happiness isn't something she has been able to experience yet. This is due to the fact she does not live with her mother and does not know her mother very well. At the beginning Gilly is very unhappy. Moving from one foster home to another is affecting her badly. She believes that happiness is being with her mother, but her theory soon changes. Gilly realises that being with her mother is not what she wants, being with Maime Trotter however is....   [tags: The Great Gilly Hopkins Katherine Paterson Essays]

Powerful Essays
1250 words (3.6 pages)

Of Nightingales That Weep by Katherine Paterson Essay

- Of Nightingales That Weep Chapter 1 This chapter is about Takiko and her first family home. It tells a lot about her family. They talk about the war In this chapter also. Takiko’s mother decides that she will remarry after her father dies. Takiko’s finds out that her father is died. Chapter 2 This chapter the book tells about Goro who is Takiko’s stepfather. Takiko finds out that Goro is a injured man. She thinks it will be very hard to live with Goro because of his problem. Chapter 3 This chapter tells about Takiko living with Goro for a few months now....   [tags: Of Nightingales That Weep Katherine Paterson]

Powerful Essays
699 words (2 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of Bridge, By Katherine Paterson

- Introduction Throughout the novel Bridge to Terabithia, Katherine Paterson introduces vivid and unique characters. These characters assist in helping readers identify and understand the themes of friendship, acceptance and imagination and the style of Paterson’s writing help reader’s better understand these themes and the characters within the novel. Jesse, also known as Jess is the main character in Paterson’s novel. He is the protagonist and the story is told from his point of view. He has a wide range of traits, including the desire to belong, a love for drawing, his sensitivity, kindness and fearfulness as well as being hardworking....   [tags: Fiction, Character, Protagonist, Narrative]

Powerful Essays
1196 words (3.4 pages)

Equality in Lyddie by Kathrine Paterson Essay

- Equality is perhaps one of the most controversial concepts that has plagued human society and communities as well as nations, since Earth’s earliest days. The idea that all are deserving of an equal amount of respect and acceptance, however appealing it may be, is quite impossible. There will always be factors (ie. economic situations, former methods of servitude, personality, etc.) that will affect the way in which humans treat one another, no matter the circumstance. It is a ridiculous idea to even attempt to comprehend that one’s feelings and thoughts and history as a person could ever be the equivalent to another’s....   [tags: debt, labor, family]

Powerful Essays
1733 words (5 pages)

Essay about The Reality of Childhood: Bridge to Terabithia

- When the word childhood is mentioned, a few synonyms come to mind. Adults when looking back at their own childhood, tend to think of innocence, being carefree, taking naps, a wild imagination, and the idea of simple pleasures. However today’s children tend to not be thought of with these characteristics. They are typically understood as spoiled, that lack most good morals. Ones that are being molded by culture and don’t display any values that past generation’s childhood had. However young adults and earlier generations can argue that childhood is as much present as it has ever been....   [tags: Katherine Paterson, Literary Analysis]

Powerful Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Bridge to Terabithia Essay

- When the word childhood comes up, a few former memories begin to resonate. When adults reflect on their own childhood, they are likely to think of innocence, taking naps, wild fancy, and the idea of simple pleasures. However today’s children tend to not be thought of with these characteristics. They are usually assumed to be spoiled rats that lack most good behaviors. Our youngsters are supposedly being molded by culture and don’t display any ideals that past generations respected. Yet young adults and earlier generations can reason that childhood is as much present as it has ever been....   [tags: childhood, Katherine Paterson, children]

Powerful Essays
1070 words (3.1 pages)

Katherine Patterson’s Bridge to Terabithia Essay

- Katherine Patterson’s Bridge to Terabithia All children can relate in someway to Katherine Patterson’s Newberry Medal-winning children’s novel, Bridge to Terabithia. The characters are realistic people who could be one’s next door neighbors. From the shy and demure Jess to the vivacious and carefree Leslie, every kid can relate to one of the characters in this novel. The themes in this novel vary as much as the characters. Bridge to Terabithia is a good coming-of-age book that captures our imaginations and our hearts....   [tags: Bridge Terabithia Patterson Essays]

Powerful Essays
1101 words (3.1 pages)

The Well by Elizabeth Jolley and Relationship of Hester and Katherine Essay

- The Well by Elizabeth Jolley and Relationship of Hester and Katherine Hester Harper is a lonely, single lady in The Well. It was her loneliness, lack of love and need for companionship that made her bring Katherine home. She did not have a life of her own. Katherine was an unloved child, who had already been rejected by people in her country until she luckily met with Hester. Katherine formed a close relationship with Hester, and soon realised that Hester was quite fond of her. Katherine fulfilled all her requirements, and Hester believed that it is the beginning of a secure and loving relationship....   [tags: Jolley well Hester Katherine Essays]

Powerful Essays
758 words (2.2 pages)