Kant 's View On Capital Punishment Essay

Kant 's View On Capital Punishment Essay

Length: 972 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Kant has a very extreme view on capital punishment that agrees with a retention point of view. Questions arise when discussing the death penalty such as is it a deterrent, does racial bias come into play and is life in prison a better choice. All of these questions are discussed by Kant, Cassell and Stevenson in detail. I agree very strongly with capital punishment and feel that it is a viable form of punishment when dealing with first degree murder.
Kant holds a strong view that capital punishment is the only form of punishment that is suitable for murder. Kant states, “Criminals should be punished because they deserve to be punished, because they must receive their just deserts. And murderers deserve death, and a just society will punish them accordingly” (353). Kant’s view further strengthens a retentionist position in that a retentionist believes that capital punishment should prevail as a form of punishment in certain cases. Retentionist are, “those who want to retain the death penalty as part of a system of legal punishment, who believe that sometimes capital punishment is warranted.” (348). Kant ‘s retributivism is, “the doctrine that people should be punished simply because they deserve it and that the punishment should be proportional to the crime.” (351). I feel that Kant’s retributivism is a good law to follow when deciding how to punish a guilty person to some extent. I feel that retributivism should be used to the fullest extent if the crime is murder or stealing; however, I feel that retributivism should not be used in the exact form as stated when dealing with other crimes such as rape. I feel that to have someone rape a rapist would not be moral or fair to the both parties and that life in prison would be a more...

... middle of paper ...

...ng factor whether capital punishment is lawful or not. I think that the death penalty is moral and should be exorcised universally not only because the murderer has no respect for the family he is effecting but also because he is no benefit to society. Also I feel that I agree with the death penalty because I had a family member taken and tortured and murdered when I was younger and I feel the only true form of justice for that man is death.
Kant has a very extreme view on capital punishment that agrees with a retention point of view. Me and Kant agree on every aspect of capital punishment and I feel that it should be universalized. I also agree that we need to look into our justice system and find ways to end discrimination in the courts. Stevenson and Cassell make very good points but I don’t feel like these are good arguments for getting rid of capital punishment.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Kant and Mill’s Positions on Capital Punishment

- Capital punishment is most commonly known as the death penalty or punishment by death for a crime. It is a highly controversial topic and many people and great thinkers alike have debated about it. Two well-known figures are Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill. Although both stand in favor of capital punishment, their reasons for coming to this conclusion are completely different. I personally stand against capital punishment, but my own personal view on it incorporates a few mixed elements from both individuals as well as my own personal insight....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Better Essays
1862 words (5.3 pages)

The Deontological Views of Capital Punishment Through the Works of Kant’s Categorical Imperative

- Capital Punishment has been used in the United States justice system for many years now, yet one must question whether or not it should be used at all. This paper will look at the Deontological views of capital punishment through the works of Kant’s categorical imperative. Arguments such as the unethical misuse of medical practice by physicians, who swear an oath to do everything in their power to save the lives of the people they care for, while using their expertise on an individual for an execution....   [tags: Capital Punishment]

Better Essays
2080 words (5.9 pages)

Capital Punishment : A Liberal Society Essay

- Capital Punishment INTRODUCTION Capital Punishment is viewed to many people as inhumane, unnecessary, and over the line. Most people would ask, who is just enough to decide who lives or who dies. This idea comes from being a very liberal society now, where everyone should love anyone and hate should not exist. Sadly this idea is not always what everyone believes, some people believe in getting revenge and embracing the hate that this world has to offer and that is where the concept of capital punishment takes place....   [tags: Capital punishment]

Better Essays
1495 words (4.3 pages)

Utilitarianism and Retributivism Views of Capital Punishment Essay

- The court handles all cases with extreme seriousness; however, different cases are handled differently. For instance, murder cases have different pre-trial procedures to be followed as compared to a case like violation of traffic rules. This paper outlines philosophers’ view of punishment and how the County District Court Division handles capital punishment. To begin with, punishment is an act that involves intentional infliction of agony or misery to a person for wrong doing, with the aim of correction....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Better Essays
665 words (1.9 pages)

Philosophy: Emmanuel Kant Essay

- Kantian Duty Immanuel Kant has a several "duty based" ethics. Another word for his belief in "duty based" is Deontological ethics. Other two theories are teleological ethics, and consequential ethics. Kant believes teleology is wrong, which put's Kant into the category of a Deontological ethicist. This is apprehensive to specifically what people do, and totally disregard the consequence of the person's actions. Some specific "duty based ethic's are , Do the right thing, do it because it's the right thing to do, don't do the wrong thing, especially avoid the wrong things because "they are wrong"....   [tags: deontological ethics, capital punishment]

Better Essays
945 words (2.7 pages)

Justifying Legal Punishment : An Argument Essay

- Justifying Legal Punishment Igor Primoratz defends the retributivist idea that a punishment is justified only if it gives a criminal his just deserts. But what do criminals deserve. Primoratz argues for the following principle: criminals deserve to be deprived of the same value that they deprived their victims of. Primoratz regards all human beings as possessed of lives of equal moral worth, and believes that the human life is the most valuable thing. He thinks that murders deserve to die. Since justice is a matter of giving people what they deserve, it follows that justice demands for murderers to be executed....   [tags: Murder, Capital punishment, Prison, Human rights]

Better Essays
1355 words (3.9 pages)

Philosophy: Kant´s Maxim Essay examples

- Kant's Maxim "Act so that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or that of another, always as an end and never as a means only." There are two opposing maxims that relate directly to Kant's point, and they both come to mind simultaneously. The first is that "the end justifies the means," and "the end never justifies the means that made it possible." We will examine both of these viewpoints in relation to Kant's maxim, and discuss them in terms of the issues of assisted suicide, euthanasia, capital punishment, and using people for our own purposes....   [tags: the end, capital punishment]

Better Essays
825 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Analysis of Kant´s Ethnics, Punishment, and Dealth Penalty

- ... According to Marshall retribution was a form of revenge which is low as it can get in his opinion. To allow the death penalty to him was to allow revenge to occur and not the laws of the land to prevail. Thurgood Marshall wanted justice to be served in reactions to crime, not revenge or allowing the emotions which was in high demand to conquer the court system. This is what he suggests about the theory of retribution. This in itself is also a form of utilitarian because in order to please others they will give the murderer the death penalty....   [tags: morally, retribution, just, ethically]

Better Essays
1573 words (4.5 pages)

Capital Punishment Argument Essay example

- Capital Punishment Argument In this philosophical study of applied ethics the concept of punishment will be argued using philosophers such as Mill, Bentham and Kant. And the case of John Martin Scripps ‘The tourist from hell’ will be used. The concept of capital punishment as a form of punishment brings about questions such as ‘is there any crime so bad that it permits the state to kill. Does anyone deserve to die for his or her crime. Is the execution a sign that society has failed its responsibilities to all its citizens....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2110 words (6 pages)

Kant Essay

- Immanuel Kant, a supporter of capital punishment, offered us of the most complicated, if not ambiguous, views on the subject. In fact, he would’ve ironically disagreed with its modern proponents. Those who advocate capital punishment today often do so for utilitarian reasons. For example, the death sentence would protect society by not only preventing a purpertrator from committing the same crime again, it would also deter others by setting an example. Kant would’ve argued the rights of the condemned are being trampled; by using him as an example, we are using him as a means to an end....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1054 words (3 pages)