Juxtaposing Viewpoints on Genetic Species Revival Essay

Juxtaposing Viewpoints on Genetic Species Revival Essay

Length: 1347 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Though it may seem that the issue of species revival through a means of genetic science is a modern idea, similar arguments throughout the past also hold relevance to the modern issue of genetic species revival. To better understand the issue as it becomes more prevalent, it is important to examen different perspectives that span many centuries time, generating new insight on the issue. Examining different perspectives on the perceived human influences on species extinction vs. natural law and lack of adaptability, and give a determination on the ethical implications to society and ecology from the above arguments and philosophies from each viewpoint. Through these key statements, the arguments on genetic species revival can be effectively argued.
The premise of the entire argument for and against genetic species revival rests with either the belief in human influences on species, or natural law. Human influences as a cause for species extinction is a recent idea which author Carl Zimmer gives a his main reason for favoring genetic species revival. “If we’re talking about species we drove extinct, then I think we have an obligation to try to do this” (Zimmer 451). In the authors opinion, human influences trump natural law, which he would consider to be an outdated and non-effective way of looking at how species become extinct. Therefore, because natural law is only a way of looking at how species become extinct, it is not a solution to species extinction. Thus, genetic species revival is the only way which human influences can be combated and the problem of species extinction can be solved.
True, human influences may be a new idea ascribed as reason to species extinction. Yet Charles Darwin, an 19th century natural b...


... middle of paper ...


...ophies from each viewpoint. From these statements, the issue of genetic species revival can be argued and a real and ethical solution to the issue derived.




Works Cited

Darwin, Charles, and David Quammen. On the Origin of Species. New York: Sterling, !
! 2008. Print.!
Leakey, Richard E., and Roger Lewin. The Sixth Extinction: Biodiversity and Its ! !
! Survival. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1996. Print.!
"Marcus Tullius Cicero Quotes." Marcus Tullius Cicero. European Graduate School ! ! EGS, 2014. Web. 16 Mar. 2014.!
Parry, Roland L. "Ancient Beasts Roam Spain's Wilderness." NewsDaily.com. Agence ! ! France Presse, 02 Mar. 2014. Web. 16 Mar. 2014. !
Zimmer, Carl. "Bringing Them Back to Life." Good Reasons With Contemporary ! !
! Arguments. 6th ed. Ed. Lester Faigley and Jack Selzer. San Francisco: Pearson, !
! 2014. 445-451. Pearson eText. Web. 5 Feb. 2014.!

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Role of Ethics in Bringing Extinct Species Back to Life Essay

- Bringing Them Back to Life, an article written by Carl Zimmer for National Geographic April 2013 edition, discusses the possibilities in modern science to clone and revive species that have been driven to extinction in the past ten thousand years (445). Throughout this article, the author makes use of the rhetorical devices logos, ethos, and pathos to argue to an audience that humans have an obligation to revive species which have been driven to extinction directly due to human influences....   [tags: Genetic Species Revival]

Strong Essays
1182 words (3.4 pages)

Genetic Engineering : A New Kind Of Species Essay

- Imagine playful laughter and trivial quarrels radiating from a family as they enjoy dinner together on a warm summer night. Fully prepared food lies on a red and white-checkered tablecloth, fairy lights line the back porch, and the sun begins to set. Smoke seeps through the area, crafting that familiar summer night smell of a freshly used grill. While most families would grill burgers or chicken, this family grilled beefalo. Beefalo, a hybrid of beef and buffalo, resulted from genetic engineering....   [tags: DNA, Genetics, Gene, Francis Crick]

Strong Essays
709 words (2 pages)

Genetic Engineering, Evolution, And The Advancement Of The Human Species

- The topic of this article deals with genetic engineering, evolution, and the advancement of the human species. Specifically, it highlights the implications of genetic engineering in relation to human nature and the continuation of the human species. Furthermore, it discusses whether the ethical scrutiny placed on genetic intervention has any validity to it. It is very likely that one day humans will be able to alter themselves physically and biologically through genetic modification. The evidence that supports this is the successful genetic modification of plants and animals....   [tags: Evolution, Natural selection, Genetics, DNA]

Strong Essays
983 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Genetic Effects of Intensive Breeding

- ... This is caused by population size and fragmentation, and leads to differentiation between populations. Brown (1965) did a study on the selection in a population of house mice containing mutant individuals. The mice were trapped in a barn, and examined for fur colour and eye colour (Figure 3). Mutant mice were homozygous for yellow fur and pink eyes. Mice that had dark fur and dark eyes were either homozygous dominant or heterozygous. Cats were then introduced into the barn at the beginning of Spring and removed at the end of Summer....   [tags: getting a specific genetic trait from a species]

Strong Essays
4295 words (12.3 pages)

Essay about Genetic Diversity on Restoration of Endangered Species

- Genetic Diversity on Restoration Compilation of all direct and indirect effects on the planet by human activities has become very critical to the restoration of endangered species to their native environment. Efforts around the world are in the works to help preserve many species from disappearing from the face of the earth. In areas where fitness species or population is low, conservation management strategy have been advocated to help avoid extinction. Such case can be seen with the Florida Panthers in which unrelated species from another population was introduced to the population to reestablish the population....   [tags: environmental issues and concerns]

Strong Essays
2250 words (6.4 pages)

Genetic Modification of Forest Tree Species Essay

- Biotechnology can be defined as a “collection of tools for modifying tree physiology and genetics to aid breeding, propagation and research” (Burdon and Libby 2006). These tools include the use of tissue culture, genetic engineering (genetic modification) and the use of genetic markers for marker assisted breeding (Harry and Strauss 2010). Tissue culture is the process of growing plants in a cultured medium under controlled conditions from small plant parts. The plants produced in this manner are then transferred to the greenhouse and then grow....   [tags: bioengineering, biotechnology]

Strong Essays
1459 words (4.2 pages)

Cloning Endangered Species Essay

- Fierce, magnificent, and free. On June 20, 1782 the bald eagle was unofficially declared as the representative of the United States of America. Instead of protecting the national emblem, “on July 4, 1976, the US Fish and Wildlife Service officially listed the bald eagle as a national endangered species” (History of…). The representation of the country’s freedom, strength, and beauty lies heavily on this bird; if it were to become an extinct species, what would that say for the United States. There is a very realistic and near-future solution: cloning....   [tags: extinction, extinct species, technology]

Strong Essays
1180 words (3.4 pages)

Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species Essay

- Charles Darwin in his book, On the Origin of Species, presents us with a theory of natural selection. This theory is his attempt at an explanation on how the world and its' species came to be the way that we know them now. Darwin writes on how through a process of millions of years, through the effects of man and the effects of nature, species have had an ongoing trial and error experiment. It is through these trials that the natural world has developed beneficial anomalies that at times seem too great to be the work of chance....   [tags: Evolution Charles Darwin Species Essays]

Strong Essays
2156 words (6.2 pages)

Genetic Engineering Essay

- Genes are, basically, the blueprints of our body which are passed down from generation to generation. Through the exploration of these inherited materials, scientists have ventured into the recent, and rather controversial, field of genetic engineering. It is described as the "artificial modification of the genetic code of a living organism", and involves the "manipulation and alteration of inborn characteristics" by humans (Lanza). Like many other issues, genetic engineering has sparked a heated debate....   [tags: Genetic Engineering ]

Strong Essays
1882 words (5.4 pages)

Genetic Screening Essay

- Genetics has provided knowledge that is changing humanity's view of itself and its relation to the rest of the universe. This has brought changes of our current philosophies and religions. For instance, the catholic church has accepted the evolution theory (1). Genetic, cytogenetic and molecular studies show that we are related to every living thing on the planet, including plants, fungi and bacterium (6) An important area in which current genetic knowledge is causing revolution is anthropological science (14)....   [tags: Genetic Engineering Essays]

Strong Essays
3323 words (9.5 pages)