Essay on Just One Of The Guys By Kristen Schilt

Essay on Just One Of The Guys By Kristen Schilt

Length: 881 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Transitions in life come in many forms. Some people may graduate from high school and move out for college. Other people get married and buy their first house. Although all of these examples seem fairly ordinary, some transitions that people may go through are not as common. In the book Just One of the Guys? by Kristen Schilt, Schilt depicts the truth behind gender inequality in the workplace from the perspective of transgender men who were once biological women. Through their transition, these people experienced natural difference schemas, inequality depending on race and class, and differences between stealth and open transitions.
Undoubtedly, the elephant in the room experienced in everyday life is the natural difference schemas between men and women. Yes, both men and women have different sexual organs and physical traits. However, the reality that men and women are treated differently goes further than just the fact that one has a penis and the other has a vagina. At any workplace; although it is not always blatantly obvious, inequality between this gender binary has affect on promotion, salaries, and even daily task preformed. People that have transitioned between genders have experienced this difference and describe it as infuriating. While they were women, they did not realize the advantage men had in the workplace. However, when they transitioned into males, they became increasingly privileged and were given more opportunities to succeed. Transmen also experienced a sense of “culture shock” from moving from one gender to another. In order to fit into their new gender status, they had to learn how to adapt from being a female in social situation then transitioning into a male. This leads into the following assumption th...


... middle of paper ...


...he did not respect his decision to swap genders. This individual was not fired, but soon left his job because psychologically they felt out of place.
Overall, Schilt clearly has a dedicated argument supporting the inequality between males and females in the workplace. It was very interesting to read about the different perspectives and experiences that the transmen went through during their transition. When it comes to critiquing this piece, there needed to be more detail on the perspective of men who went through transitioning into women. Schilt seemed to only cover one side of the argument and if she had put in more time, she could have better supported her claim using a transwomen perspective. Nevertheless, Schilt demonstrated a solid argument that supported gender inequality that goes beyond natural difference schemas and physical traits between men and women.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Just One Of The Guys By Kristen Schilt Essay

- Upon arriving the first day of class I initially realized, this is a female dominated class. I immediately went and sat next to another male and proceeded to talk about sports; anything manly to be honest. Going through the syllabus pegged some social challenges for me, however I decided to push through in order to gain a closer insight to this growing social construct. Upon reading “Just One of the Guys” by Kristen Schilt, I started to become aware of many instances in my own professional life where I acted inappropriate or standoffish for no reason....   [tags: Gender, Transgender, Man, Gender role]

Better Essays
1091 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Just One of the Guys

- If a person was asked what he or she thought males and females are like, what would he or she answer. There was such a survey done, and the list for females was as follows: “compassionate, loves children, dependent, interpersonally sensitive, nurturing,” while the list for males was “leader, aggressive, ambitious, analytical, competitive, dominant, independent, and individualistic” (Fine 3-4). By this standard, all women are interpersonally sensitive, and all men are aggressive. Is this true. In some cases these generalizations may be true, but in many others this is far from the truth, making these lists gender stereotypes....   [tags: Movies, Gender Roles]

Better Essays
1535 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about One Direction: How Their Lives Changed on the X-Factor

- ... Niall loved to perform in his schools plays and sang in the choir. He also enjoyed sports , especially football and derby. Liam James Payne was born on August 29, 1993, in Wolverhampton. He lived with his father Geoff, mother Karen, and two sisters Nicola and Ruth Payne. He was very interested in sports and music growing up. He was a member of Wolverhampton & Bilston Athletics Club and trained as a runner.He also had previously auditioned for xfactor in 2008 but did not make it through to the live shows....   [tags: band, guys, artists, aution]

Free Essays
539 words (1.5 pages)

Kristen Stewart in "Speak" Essay examples

- I'll admit this now. I absolutely adore Kristen Stewart. I think she's one of the most uniquely beautiful woman in the world, with so much more about her, then Twilight. I unfortunately hadn't been able to get a copy of Speak, I couldn't seem to be able to find it anywhere. Thanks to an online movie watching site, I managed to find this gem. I can honestly say, Speak is a film, that toyed with my emotions, like no other film has done in some time. This is very much like my high school was. Full of bullying, teasing, and people hurting others....   [tags: Acting Analysis]

Better Essays
558 words (1.6 pages)

Travel in Space: Sally Kristen Ride Essay

- Sally Kristen Ride, an American astronaut, made history when she became the first woman and youngest person to travel in space. To educate children, she enjoyed writing books concerning travel and discoveries in space. Ride was born on May 26, 1951 in Encino, California and passed away from pancreatic cancer on July 23, 2012 in La Jolla, California. Ever since she was a young girl, Ride had always been curious about the world around her. Ride’s various accomplishments led her to receive many prestigious honors such as being inducted into the Astronaut Hall of Fame and recognized as a renowned American leader....   [tags: spaceflight, NASA]

Better Essays
562 words (1.6 pages)

Essay about Full Body Burden By Kristen Iversen

- There is a point in life where silence becomes a comfortable old friend. Silence is the only friend that we truly listen to because our mind is able to run free without limitations. In the space where our mind runs side by side with our silence, a great portion of life’s secrets can be found. What differs between each person is how they deal with their silence. One can stand up against the silence and stand alone, or one can hide behind the cloak of silence blending in with the others around them....   [tags: Government, Family, Dow Chemical Company]

Better Essays
792 words (2.3 pages)

The Power Girls Have on Guys Essay

- It is interesting to see the effect that girls can have on guys. In the short story, “A & P” by John Updike, a teenage boy’s daily routine at work is completely rattled due to a group of three teenage girls that walk into the store he works at which he works and as a result, the teenage boy makes a life changing decision. The young men (Sammy) morals are put to the test along with his life expectations due to this group of teenage girls that help Sammy see his life through a different perspective....   [tags: Literary Analysis]

Better Essays
1913 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on Production Processes at Kristen's Cookie Company

- Kristen’s Cookie Company Missing Charts We have studied Kristen’s Cookie Company’s planned production process, and have drawn a number of conclusions based on our analysis. The understanding of our analysis will be facilitated by the following flow chart, which shows each step along the production process. The coloration denotes work performed by each member of the two-person workforce, and capacity and timing are specified below for each step: From the above chart, we see that when the process is continuing at maximum efficiency, filling one order of a dozen cookies will take 26 minutes....   [tags: Business]

Better Essays
1065 words (3 pages)

Essay about Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room

- The thing I liked most about this documentary was the fact that it focused on the guys at the top, the self-proclaimed "smartest men in the room", the so-called geniuses who knew the energy business so much better than the rest of the industry. And what a piece of work these men were. Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room shows us how basic human nature does not change, whether it's in the easy fall into killing as a means to resolve disputes, or in the incessant human obsession to acquire for acquisition's sake....   [tags: Business Fraud]

Better Essays
1884 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on I Like Guys

- I Like Guys The topic of homosexuality has become a constant issue throughout our society for many years. Many people believe that being gay is not acceptable for both religious and moral reasons. Because being gay is not accepted, many homosexuals may feel shame or guilt because of the way they live their everyday lives. This in turn can affect how the person chooses to live their life and it can also affect who the person would like to become. Growing up, David Sedaris struggled to find the common ground between being gay as well as being a normal teenager....   [tags: Homosexuality Gay Testimonial Social]

Free Essays
1367 words (3.9 pages)