Jonathan Livingston Seagull And The Myth Of The Cave Essay

Jonathan Livingston Seagull And The Myth Of The Cave Essay

Length: 1279 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Jonathan the Freed Prisoner
Both Jonathan Livingston Seagull (a novel by Richard Bach) and “The Myth of the Cave” (a short story written by the commonly-studied philosopher, Plato) are commonly referred to as allegories. An allegory is a work of art that possesses a hidden moral or political message beneath its actual appearance. In many ways, one could easily interpret both of these superb writings to hold the same meaning. One presentation that holds true to this is that Richard Bach’s character, Jonathan, compares to the prisoner that escapes in Plato’s work, “The Myth of the Cave.” Metaphorically, both of these characters are held as prisoners in their life, but then later are freed and ultimately return to their origin to enlighten others still held captive.
To begin, if one were to return to Jonathan Livingston Seagull to examine the story’s similarities to TMOTC, he or she could easily guess that in the beginning, Jonathan and his flock are all bound by the chains of hunger in the constant struggle for food. When broken down, it’s clear that the non-stop mission to acquire food all these gulls possess is actually an illusion that fate has forced them to witness while bound by the chain of insignificance. Jonathan manifests to the reader that he absolutely despises that lifestyle, and partakes in a hobby the other seagulls scoff at. In JLS, Richard Bach writes, “It’s all so pointless, he thought, deliberately dropping a hard-won anchovy to a hungry old gull . . . I could be spending all this time learning to fly!” (5). Noticeably, flight is very important to this one-of-a-kind seagull, nevertheless, he can still be labeled as currently shackled due to the pressure constantly put on him to give up flight in the pursuit of co...


... middle of paper ...


...n noted, both Plato and Richard Bach spin almost-identical tales of bravery and discovery in “The Myth of the Cave” and Jonathan Livingston Seagull. Despite that the first of these works is only a short story and the second is a novel, the both speak to whoever that reads them in the same way. They speak of the curiosity and the enigma of the moment one’s shackles are removed as he or she is led out of the cave. They speak of curiosity and awe as one would take their initial steps out into the sun-filled expanse. And ultimately, they both remind readers of the feelings of loneliness and compassion as one determines to return to those still in chains to attempt to persuade them to make the same journey. Readers might find themselves wondering reading either story, “is not this unjust? . . . Ought we to give them a worse life, when they might have a better?” (Plato 5).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Myth Of The Cave By Jonathan Livingston Seagull

- An allegory is a story that has hidden meaning buried in it, usually a moral, political, or religious meaning. The book Jonathan Livingston Seagull by Richard Bach, and the short story “The Myth of the Cave” by Plato, are both considered to be allegories. In fact, they are very similar allegories because their hidden meanings are alike. In “The Myth of the Cave,” the people are sitting in a deep, dark cave with nothing to live for. Similarly, in “Jonathan Livingston Seagull,” the flock is wrapped up in the idea that all they have to do in life is find food and eat it....   [tags: Jonathan Livingston Seagull, Richard Bach]

Better Essays
714 words (2 pages)

John Livingstone Seagull By Richard Bach And The Myth Of The Cave Essay

- A young seagull who loves to fly is banished from his flock, but after mastering flight, returns to share these new discoveries with his old flock. A man kept imprisoned in a dark cave is introduced to the outside world, and later returns to the cave to tell his fellow prisoners about it. On the surface, both Jonathan Livingstone Seagull by Richard Bach and “The Myth of the Cave” by Plato have almost childishly simple plots. In both, a character leaves his home, learns something, and returns. However, these stories gain a deeper significance when the reader views them as allegories....   [tags: Jonathan Livingston Seagull, Richard Bach]

Better Essays
1094 words (3.1 pages)

An Analysis Of Jonathan Lingston Seagull And The Free Prisoner Essay example

- Allegory a word by definition means, contains a moral, political, or religious meaning. Both stories, (Jonathan Lingston Seagull, and Plato, “Myth of The Cave.” The Republic. Vol. VII, contain a religious meaning. Jonathan Lingston Seagull and the free prisoner are similar in many ways because both characters experience a religious awakening, return, and rejection. In both stories the characters Jonathan and the free prisoner both experience a religious awakening. Jonathan’s episode with religion is being what we as Christian’s call a disciple, meaning to spread the word of God, however; that is not exactly what Jonathan is....   [tags: Jonathan Livingston Seagull, Richard Bach, Prison]

Better Essays
783 words (2.2 pages)

`` Warriors Don 't Cry `` And Jonathan Livingston Seagull Essay

- The world is a vast place, separated by broken up landmass, but united by beliefs, languages, and similar interests. The world is made up of societies, but what exactly is one. The definition of the word society is, “the aggregate of people living together in a more or less ordered community”. In simpler terms, a society is made up of people, collectively and individually that decide what to make of it. So what does it take to make it a good one or a bad one. The answer is simple, but it’s also very hard to understand: the answer is the choices people make....   [tags: Jonathan Livingston Seagull, Richard Bach]

Better Essays
1087 words (3.1 pages)

Jonathan Livingston Seagull Essay

- Jonathan Livingston Seagull Jonathan was not an ordinary seagull. For a thousand years, seagulls have spent their whole life on scrambling after fish heads. But Jonathan saw something different. He thought that life should not be just eating and fighting, even seagulls should have a reason to live. For him, his meaning of life is to fly. We all wish that we could spend all our time on doing things we like, just as Jonathan spent all his time on his beloved flight. However, the success in finding his meaning of life didn't bring with him any honor, but caused him to be an object of shame and irresponsibility, and to be banished due to his neglect to finding food....   [tags: Jonathan Livingston Seagull Essays]

Free Essays
1119 words (3.2 pages)

Essay Jonathan Livingston Seagull by Richard bach

- Richard Bach’s existential novella, Jonathan Livingston Seagull, a rhapsody of joy and triumph; the triumph of the seagull metaphor for all humans against the prejudice of his species and socially imposed traditions. Written in the parable form in a very simple and clear language, it tells story of a seagull named Jonathan Livingston who crosses all barriers of society to achieve his dream of flying against the Council Flock of Seagulls which is designed to marginalize him. Jonathan Livingston Seagull a story is almost a fictional account of a seagull, which travelled against all odds of the flock to freedom....   [tags: freedom, novella, existence]

Better Essays
1657 words (4.7 pages)

Jonathan Livingston Seagull Essay example

- The book tells the story of Jonathan Livingston Seagull a gull who believes seagulls are meant for much more than just fighting for food. He has a passion for flying and for learning. For his strong beliefs he is marked and an outcast and sent to live alone. He however continues to fly and learns all he can learn. He never gives up on what he believes in. Part one of the Book begins with The Breakfast Flock fighting for bits of food. While everyone else if struggling to feed themselves Jonathan is out by himself practicing....   [tags: Literature Review]

Better Essays
1514 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on The Myth Of The Cave

- The myth of the Cave, found in the seventh book of Plato’s Republic, depicts a group of people chained in the pit of a cavern, unable to see anything but the shadows of people, and the objects they carry with them, traveling past a fire behind them (186-7). This serves as an illustration of the epistemology Socrates had begun to develop in the preceding book with the images of the Sun and the Line. It also functions as a segue into the related discussion of educational theory. Additionally, though less apparent, the analogy can also be read as a defense of philosophy, an important topic for Plato in light of his teacher’s infamous death, “the founding myth of the academic discipline of philo...   [tags: Plato, Philosophy, Epistemology, Logic]

Better Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' Bridge Across Forever ' Essay

- This epigraph begins the book "Bridge Across Forever" by the famous American writer, philosopher and essayist Richard Bach. And he is perfectly suited to his novel-parable "Jonathan Livingston Seagull", reflecting the idea of ​​a book about the perfection of a rational being, not limited by time and space. The process of reading the book is incredible emotions and thoughts. It is quite obvious the analogy of the world gulls and the world of men. Seagulls speak, think, aspire to freedom, have the will and intellect in general exhibit properties superior beings, that is, Homo sapiens....   [tags: Jonathan Livingston Seagull, Richard Bach]

Better Essays
892 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Multi Dimensionality in the Seagull by Anton Chekhov

- Anton Chekhov includes many dimensions to the plot of the Seagull in order to add increased depth to the story. The conflict, climax, complications, and denouement of the play all benefit from the wide range problems that Chekhov implants through the characters. In addition, the complex character relationships add to these events, without confusing the reader. These four events all rotate around the play's four main characters, Nina, Irina, Treplev and Trigorin. The play's central conflict is between Treplev and Trigorin, who holds the love of both Irina and Nina....   [tags: Seagull Essays]

Better Essays
995 words (2.8 pages)