John Locke And Simons : A Letter Concerning Toleration And The New Birth

John Locke And Simons : A Letter Concerning Toleration And The New Birth

Length: 1293 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


One a rationalized philosopher, the other more akin to an Old Testament preacher of fire and brimstone, show a surprising similarity on the subject of religion and tolerance. Locke and Simons, authors of “A Letter Concerning Toleration” and “The New Birth” respectively, lay out paths that both contradict and condemn the systems in place by the Catholic Church of their day. Comparisons can also be made on the two men’s viewpoints on the ever-increasing amount of Christian religions coming into existence, how to live a Christian life, thinking critically, and the treatment of others. Though their works were written more than a century apart, there is an obvious connection in the thought process of Locke and Simons.
The Catholic Church was vastly influential throughout Europe; the clergy saw themselves as speakers of God on earth and used this stance to manipulate people and governments for earthly treasures and power. Locke and Simons, learned men of faith, both saw the issues inherent with claiming to be doing the Will of God while perpetuating violence and ritualistic ceremonies invented by man. Locke, in his 1689 work A Letter Concerning Toleration, says this on the subject of the hypocrisy between religious texts and the actions committed by Catholics:
“If the Gospel and the apostles may be credited, no man can be a Christian without charity and without that faith which works, not by force, but by love. Now, I appeal to the consciences of those that persecute, torment, destroy, and kill other men upon pretense of religion, whether they do it out of friendship and kindness towards them or no?” (Locke)
Locke questions and condemns Catholicism throughout his work and attempts to persuade the reader to think critically about w...


... middle of paper ...


...r sick?” (Locke)
It is never stated as fully as other issues regarding life throughout these works but the intent to drive those readers towards thinking critically is there within every paragraph of Locke and Simons works.
Despite the many differences of these men, Locke and Simons, there is a common strand of how to live life buried within these two works. The ideas of loving and tolerating your fellow man are prevalent throughout both works as well as the want for humans to think clearly for themselves and not to be led astray by the overly powerful Catholic Church and its priests. They had a drive to attempt to improve the conditions of life for people here on earth and to direct them to what they believed would be an afterlife of eternal bliss because of their actions here. Indeed, these two thinking men would have had much to discuss had they had the chance.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

John Locke: Forcing Someone to Become a Christian Essay

- In the letter ‘A Letter Concerning Toleration’ John Locke sets out the arguments as to why it is irrational to force someone to become Christian against their will and whilst Locke writes as a Christian it acknowledged that it is true for all religious beliefs. As a whole his letter makes a case for the toleration of other religious beliefs. The main argument within the letter is the irrationality argument but it also included others such as the unchristian argument and the inconsistency argument....   [tags: A Letter Concerning Toleration]

Strong Essays
2135 words (6.1 pages)

Letter Concerning Toleration Essay examples

- John Locke was born in 1632. He grew to become one of the most influential philosophers and was seen as the father of the Enlightenment. Locked studied at the Christ Church of Oxford in 1658 (AR). At Oxford he studied medicine which impacted his beliefs a great deal. His most famous works include First Treatise of Government, Second Treatise of Government, and Letter Concerning Toleration (AR). In his treatises he proclaimed that absolute monarchy was not the proper way to govern. These beliefs about a monarchy started in him at a very young age....   [tags: Religion]

Strong Essays
1057 words (3 pages)

The Devouring Dragon By Craig Simons Essay

- “The Devouring dragon, narrated by Craig Simons describes his travels across various parts of the world to study how China’s economic rise within the last few decades, has negatively impacted the global environment. Simons bases his book and findings primarily from theory, science. In addition, he enhances his approach by adding in bits and pieces from conversations he’s had with scientists, advocates, politicians and average citizens in order to gather a more personal response. By combining various types of material, Simons provides readers with both informing and justifiable explanations of how Chinas growth is destroying the planet at a rapid rate....   [tags: Greenhouse gas, Carbon dioxide, Climate change]

Strong Essays
706 words (2 pages)

Letter to a Newspaper Editor Concerning the Taliban

- Letter to a Newspaper Editor Concerning the Taliban To the Editor, As the Taliban has been driven out of Kabul after the September 11 crisis, life over there has been better, but it is still very poor. After being bombed the Afghan people have been forced to leave there family, friends, home and even society. Who determines what people are worth being in a country like Australia. These people are coming to Australia illegally because they can't afford to get here properly....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
521 words (1.5 pages)

The Controversy Concerning A New Method Of Death Essay example

- The controversy concerning a new method of death, Physician Assisted Suicide, has provoked a social, legal, and a massive medical debate. Nearly two decades ago, Oregon declared its legalization for the assistance of lethal doses of medication to help terminally ill patients end their lives. Several other states were subsequent to this movement such as Washington, Vermont, and Montana. Since then, oppositional views and disagreements on this topic have been brought up in court to be legalized for the suffering of patients who are unavoidably assured to death....   [tags: Death, Suffering, Suicide, Illness]

Strong Essays
1050 words (3 pages)

The Second Treatise Of Government And A Letter Concerning Toleration Essay

- John Locke is a man of many opinions, many contradictions and lengthy explanations. The focus of this paper is primarily on chapter V of John Locke’s book, The Second Treatise of Government and a Letter Concerning Toleration. Where Locke focuses on the topic of property, primarily man’s right to goods as long as he puts labour for it, restrictions to said right, and place of silver and gold in society. While the topics covered in this chapter are of importance and raise questions as to, if man consented to an unequal possession of earth, if man can fairly possess more land then needed without harm, if money represents wealth, and if the government should play a role in protecting disproporti...   [tags: John Locke, State of nature, Property]

Strong Essays
1121 words (3.2 pages)

The Power of Light in The Scarlet Letter Essay

- The Power of Light in The Scarlet Letter             Since the conception of humanity, man has been fascinated with that presence which illuminates, yet cannot be touched.  Mankind has brought it into his religions, giving it a great deal of importance in his creed.  Following in the footsteps of his ancestors, Nathaniel Hawthorne uses light as a tool of God that illuminates the darkness of human iniquity and exposes its permanence.  He studies the psychological theme of the impossibility of eradicating sin from the human heart in his novel The Scarlet Letter.  The use of light in order to fortify this psychological theme confirms its significance in the novel.  As...   [tags: Scarlet Letter essays]

Strong Essays
657 words (1.9 pages)

Letter To The Principal Essay

- Dear Mr.Johnson, This Letter is on the issue of closed campus, in my opinion this should not even be an issue. County High Scholl students should be able to go out during lunch, we have a right to choose what we pay for and we have the right to seek a comfortable environment. I have very strong reasons to back up my opinion. If I want to not wait in line for at least five to eight minutes for food I must skip the trip to my locker and lag around a heavy bag which has my first, second, third and fourth hour books in it....   [tags: Letter To The Principal]

Free Essays
620 words (1.8 pages)

Hester Prynne of Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter Essays

- “Religion today is too often merely the worship of guilt, an obsession with sin and an exercise in the rubrics of repentance” (Evely) 1. Such is the case of all sin, including the adultery of Hester Prynne, the main character in Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter. The novel takes place in the Massachusetts Bay Colony from 1642-1649 during an era of strict religion under Puritan watch. Hester Prynne, one of such people living in the colony, is punished greatly for her sin, although she is not punished in death....   [tags: The Scarlet Letter]

Free Essays
898 words (2.6 pages)

The Scarlett Letter Essay

- The Scarlett Letter The story opens with Hester Prynne standing silently on the scaffold in the middle of a town square in 18th century Boston. Hester, holding her small child in her arms, is publicly on trial for adultery. The town people, especially the women, are not happy that Hester has been sentenced only to wear a scarlet letter and to stand on a public platform for a few hours of public humiliation. However, the judge has decided to be merciful to her because, over all, she has been a good citizen up to this point....   [tags: The Scarlett Letter]

Free Essays
3043 words (8.7 pages)