Japanese Samurai and European Knights: Were the Similarities Greater Than the Differences?

Japanese Samurai and European Knights: Were the Similarities Greater Than the Differences?

Length: 1083 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I believe we can all agree that Japanese samurais and European knights are two of the most skilled and famous forms of warriors in history, right? Well both warriors began their trade at a very young age, and went through multiple stages of training throughout their lives. They both had a code of honor basically, but they differed from one another in quite a few ways. The big question is, “Were the similarities greater than the differences?”. Right off the bat I began to ponder the technicalities of the answer to this question. Before I get too scrambled up in the technicalities, let’s discuss some these differences and the similarities and figure out how this plays out. Before we conduct this discussion, let’s review our key terms. A clan is a group of close-knit and interrelated families. Feudalism was a political and economic system that flourished in Europe from the 9th to the 15th century, based on higher classes giving random services and items in exchange for something else. Knights were men who served their lord as a mounted soldier in armor. Samurai’s were members of a powerful military social class in feudal Japan. A shogun was a hereditary commander-in-chief in feudal Japan. Chivalry was the medieval knightly system with its religious, moral, and social code. Bushido was the code of honor and morals developed by the Japanese samurai.
In Document A, we see a very nicely displayed social pyramid. This pyramid attempts to show the reader which classes’ match up as closely as possible with their equivalent counterpart. As you began reading the pyramid for Japan, you see something that may strike you as being odd. This being that the shogun has more power than the emperor, yet the emperor is still higher on the pyramid. Thi...


... middle of paper ...


...e respect, honor, and loyalty make this difference for me, but there is something to be said about the comparison. I find that the knights are very efficient, great warriors, and are very similar to samurai’s in a lot of ways. They both wear armor, they both train from a young age, and both are taught about honor, loyalty, and respect; but samurais are taught more effectively in their training, and the Japanese concepts were better. So to answer the essential question of this essay, I would say that there is certainly a large amount of similarities between the two warriors, but if you would consider the samurai’s skills that are better, or enhanced; to be differences, than I would have to conclude with no. The ‘differences’, are far too great in my opinion to say that the similarities are so great that they are almost the same, because they are very different indeed.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Modern Japanese Literature and Theater: Betsuyaku Minoru Japanese Essay

- Japanese modern theater has gone through several changes during the years. From the early attempts of 1870 to reform the Kabuki, which resulted in the new form of shin-kabuki to the creation in the 1960s of shugekijo undo (Little theatre movement). One of the individuals that made an impact in Japanese modern theater is Betsuyaku Minoru. The following essay would be talking about Betsuyaku and his contribution to modern theater in Japan. In the Japanese state of Manchukuo on April 6, 1937 Betsuyaku Minoru was born....   [tags: japanese modern theater]

Better Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Japanese Soldiers: The Samurai Essay

- ... The training, barely, could take from the early morning till the late evening. Few other things, that the general student didn’t learn, were navigation, strategy, moral, and few others. But the most important lesson was learning the warrior code. With the help of this, they were introduced to the rules of morality and the law of “bushido”. Bushido stands for the “doing the work, that is dedicated to you (related to samurai).” This code of honor emphasized loyalty and bravery. This unusual code of honor referred to not only to martial rectitude, but also to personal rectitude....   [tags: japanese culture, loyalti bravery]

Free Essays
657 words (1.9 pages)

Essay Comparison Of Japanese And Europeans ' Feudal Systems

- Summation One way through which both the Japanese and Europeans’ feudal systems were built was via consistent hereditary practices among the ruling classes. This was in the sense that power was continuously retained among the persons at the top positions of office. The alignment of authority was such that the noble family was at the top position, and the warriors were situated at the second position of command in these systems of rule among both the Europeans and Japanese. The persons who fell at the bottom position were referred to as the serfs or the tenant farmers owing to the fact that these individuals were considered to have very little power and authority within their distinctive area...   [tags: Feudalism, Nobility, Warrior, Fief]

Better Essays
1376 words (3.9 pages)

The Balance of Novelty and Similarities Essay

- The article “When Innovations Meet Institutions: Edison and the Design of Electric Light” by Hargadon and Douglas analyses how Edison successfully introduced and commercialized the electric lighting system within the resistant social context. One method he used is to apply robust design, which the authors believe as a useful tool of helping Edison’s innovation to acquire social acceptance and break lock-in of gas lighting institutes. The notion of robust design requires the innovators and entrepreneurs to make sophisticated decisions including what to present as new (novelty), what to present as old (similarity), and what to hide (Hargadon and Douglas 2001, 476--501)....   [tags: light, similarities]

Better Essays
1957 words (5.6 pages)

The Knights Templar Essay

- The Knights Templar The Knights Templar have been portrayed as evil knights and only concerned with their glory in video games (i.e. Assassins Creed) and movies (i.e. Kingdom of Heaven). What happened to them and their treasure has been much speculation ever since their fall in 1314. They have become such a huge part of popular fiction that a lot of people do not know what to believe when it comes to the Knights Templar. So who were the Knights Templar and what really did happen to them. Sometime between the years 1100 and 1122 the Poor Knights (or Fellow Soldiers) of Christ and the Temple of Solomon, more commonly known as the Order of the Temple or The Knights Templar, were founded in Jer...   [tags: king phillip IV, evil, video games]

Better Essays
1535 words (4.4 pages)

Japanese Internment Camps Essays

- World War II was a time of deliberate hate among groups of innocent people who were used as scapegoats. Japanese-Americans were persecuted due to the fact that they looked like citizens of Japan, who had attacked the United States on December 7th, 1941 at the naval base, Pearl Harbor. This hatred toward the group was due to newspapers creating a scare for the American people, as well as the government restricting the rights of Japanese-Americans. The Japanese-Americans were mistreated during World War II for no other reason than being different....   [tags: Japanese-Americans in WWII]

Better Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Influential Japanese Playwrights Essay

- Vengeful ghosts, evil demons, and people turned to animals. These are all features of a typical Japanese Noh play. The battles for power in medieval Japan are responsible for inspiring the creator of the noh genre in Japanese theater. The noh theater is interesting and colorful with an assortment of masks and costumes carefully crafted to represent the character they represent (Noh). Many of the great plays written by playwright Zeami Motokiyo, the most highly regarded of all in the genre, inspired many and helped make noh a success (World 114)....   [tags: noh theater, Japanese history]

Better Essays
1130 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Knights Templar

- Have you ever heard of the knight’s templar. Who they were, what the stood for. Were they loyal. Let me take the time to tell you a little about what I know about these men. Allow me to persuade you to study these loyal Knights.( nicholson,helen.)That were neglected for their beliefs along with their outlook on life. Their military beliefs and their ways of serving their lives for the law. Most of the Knights Templar’s were members of the military and religious order of the poor Knights of the Christ, called the Knights of the temple of Solomon from their house of Christ, in which they all were very loyal to their lord, strong believers in Christ....   [tags: Early Christianity, European History]

Better Essays
1161 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Importance of Honor in Sir Thomas Malory’s King Arthur and his Knights

- Importance of Honor in Sir Thomas Malory’s King Arthur and his Knights For centuries, the Arthurian legend has captivated an untold number of readers. What is it about Camelot that draws us into its complex code of chivalry and amusingly brute anecdotes. Human nature, as one can surmise from antiquated literature, has still not changed in the least—we still experience the boons and pitfalls of love, joy, envy, lust and sorrow. This certainly explains why the tantrums of Malory’s jealous Queen Guinevere strike chords of familiarity and even evoke an empathetic chuckle....   [tags: King Arthur Knights Essays]

Better Essays
1784 words (5.1 pages)

Knights Essay

- Knights In the fourth century A.D. the Roman Empire fell and Europe was invaded by various barbarian tribes. One of the dominant groups was the Franks of central and western Europe, who gradually expanded their power until their leader Charlemagne became emperor of the West. Powerful local lords and their mounted warriors offered protection to peasants, who became their serfs in return. By the 11the century a new social order was formed my armored knights, who served a local lord, count, or duke, and were in turn served by serfs....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
991 words (2.8 pages)