James Madison’s Federalist Papers' Comparison of the Republic and Democatic Governement

James Madison’s Federalist Papers' Comparison of the Republic and Democatic Governement

Length: 690 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

It started back in the early days of 1787 where ideas of the best government for the current and future of this country. Its something our four fathers had to think about after only a short time being a nation after the Revolution. The Revolution was a lesson that there needs to be a government where the people have more say. This question has been asked before and much like our four fathers the best thing to do is write about it. Write about what is better, whether that be a Republican government or a Democratic government. Through the source of James Madison’s Federalist paper ten, the following question will be answered. Comparing and Contrasting both governments and explaining the side of each. However, like Madison and his Federalist paper there will be a clear choice what’s best.
The biggest threat to our country in the eyes of Madison is something phrased repetitively in his writing and that is “Factions”. A Factions is simply a small group that shares an interest which eventually will destroy our system if it can not be contained. The most difficult thing about Factions is it can not be removed completely for by doing so would eliminate the citizens’ liberty. In the words of Madison, “Liberty is to faction, as Air is to Fire”. There needs to be liberty for politics to survive and since liberty feeds the factions the problem is how can it be maintained? There will always be a group of people that share interests or opinions about a topic positive or negative that is their right. What concerns Madison is that these factions will grow and eventually poison the system.
Keep in mind that either Democracy or Republican governments are not the perfect solution. A Democracy is a government built for a smaller scale and focuses o...


... middle of paper ...


... the ballot. The Representative government is the best possible solution for now and the future of governing a large group or nation. Its a “cure”.
There are many similar questions asked about both governments in 1787 and today in 2014. Both sides make valid arguments to bring the citizens more involved in what is going on in their country. Yet the biggest concern for both is factions, in what system can it survive with factions in place. As long as there is liberty there will always be factions. The Democratic side is to small of a scale to limit the factions, eventually there will be an overwhelming number of them. The Republican version however will limit the factions to where they would not affect the system in the long run. Eventually all of the Representatives would out number the Faction groups enough to where they could not make a big impact on the ballots.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Dangers of Factions Explained in James Madison's The Federalist No. 10

- ... Madison believes that factions are inherent to human nature, making it unavoidable that people are living under a state of liberty. Madison argues that "the most common and durable source of factions has been the various and unequal distribution of property" (Madison). I think what Madison is trying to state is that as long as people have different talents, economic statuses, and amounts of property, people will always continue to associate with others who have similar qualities as them. The difference between those who have and those who do not has always existed throughout human history, thus making it one of the most unavoidable causes of factions....   [tags: republic, tyranny, governement]

Better Essays
514 words (1.5 pages)

Federalist No. 10 and No. 51 by James Madison Essay

- Federalist No. 10 and No. 51 were a series of essays written by James Madison, arguing for the ratification of the U.S Constitution. Before the ratification, the Articles of Confederation only bounded the thirteen colonies, uniting them as military alliance rather than a cohesive government. The central government lacked authority; the national government could not collect taxes or force states to comply with their laws. The lack of a strong central government made it difficult for states to operate effectively as one single nation....   [tags: thoughts of the 4th US president]

Better Essays
1349 words (3.9 pages)

James Madison and the Federalist Papers

- On September 17, 1787, the Philadelphia Convention sent their new constitution to the states for ratification. The Federalists highly approved of the Constitution because it allowed for a more central and powerful government that was previously undermined under the Articles of Confederation. The Anti-Federalists, however, didn’t want a powerful central government, but, instead, powerful state governments; in response to the Constitution, many Anti-Federalists began writing essays and creating pamphlets as a means of arguing against it....   [tags: Federalist Papers]

Better Essays
739 words (2.1 pages)

An Analysis Of James Madison Writes 's Federalist No Essay

- James Madison writes in Federalist No. 51, “[i]n framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself.” He goes on to explain his concept of “compound republic” in which two distinct governments (national and state) are further subdivided into separate departments. In each of the two distinct governments, the legislative, executive and judicial branches (departments) work like a scale to balance each other and prevent one from gaining too much power or influence....   [tags: Democracy, Government, Federalist Papers]

Better Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)

A comparison and contrast of the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution of 1787

- A comparison and contrast of the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution of 1787. The Articles of Confederation voted on and adopted by the Continental Congress, November 15, 1777 (Carey, 2013). It was the first constitution of America, though complete ratification of the Articles of Confederation by all thirteen states did not take place until March 1, 1781. After some of the states realized that the Articles of Confederation did not adequately resolve the national and international issues that the United States was facing....   [tags: american history, drafting of the constitution]

Better Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)

James Madison And The Federalist Papers

- James Madison and the Federalist Papers In the late 1700s, it was apparent that the Declaration of Independence and the Articles of Confederation did not establish the type of government needed to keep the nation together as a nation-state. The American people needed to find a more effective way to govern themselves and this was no easy feat. Most Americans had varying political thoughts in the 18th century. The challenge because how to best take care of the masses in a fair and equitable way....   [tags: United States Constitution, James Madison]

Better Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)

The Federalist Paper By James Madison

- James Madison wrote the federalist papers to explain the federal system should of government to the the american people. The federalist papers also introduced the idea of factions in a republican government. James Madison describes a faction as a small, organized group that forms within a larger group which is often present in politics. Republican governments are prone to factions. In order for a republican government to be successful it is important to protect against factions. Madison believed there are two ways to protect against factions;to get rid of them or control them....   [tags: United States Constitution, United States]

Better Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)

Federalist Paper 10, by James Madison

- The theories presented in Federalist Paper #10 by James Madison directly apply to many of the world’s utmost dilemmas. Madison’s first theory states that Factions can be very detrimental to the common, good. Madison’s second theory explains that a strong, large republic is the best form of government. Federalist Paper #10 is one essay in a series of papers written mostly by James Madison, John Jay, and Alexander Hamilton, fighting for the ratification of the United States Constitution. In Federalist Paper #10 James Madison addresses the issue of “how to guard against factions.” The definition of a faction is “a group of citizens, with interest’s contrary to the rights of others or the inter...   [tags: Theories Modern Influence]

Better Essays
1774 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on The Creation of the American Republicn - James Madison

- The Creation of the American Republicn - James Madison James Madison prided himself on his knowledge from books and theories. Madison was born into a class of Virginia planters. His father was the wealthiest landowner in Virginia and it was known that Madison would lead a financially secure life. This factor helped him in his pursuit of education. He gained opportunities to go to elite schools because of his status. Madison was ambitious and he graduated from the College of New Jersey a year early....   [tags: James Madisom Biography US History]

Better Essays
1175 words (3.4 pages)

Federalists Essay

- James Madison was a very intelligent man and was one of the forefathers for our country. In Madison’s Federalist Paper Number 10 he describes the need to control factions in the United States and how the government is to do so. The Federalist papers are a key point in describing how to control “factions” that are so dangerous to the young government, or so Madison feels. In Madison’s paper he clearly lays out his idea on the sources of factions, his feelings on democracy versus a republic, and how to control factions....   [tags: American History, Madison, Factions]

Free Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)