The Issue Of Cell Ownership Essay

The Issue Of Cell Ownership Essay

Length: 1346 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

While both researchers and human subject’s battle over the basic issue of cell ownership, here in United States the rights to those cells remains a constant tug of war. There are four types of specimens obtained for research; tissue for a future research project, extra or leftover tissue taken for diagnosis or treatment during procedures, such as fluids collected and biopsies; cadaveric tissue, and tissue with human potential or reproductive tissue, fetal tissue, eggs, sperm, and embryos. Scientist and researchers are fighting to preserve their foundation of cell and tissue sample collection and testing claiming the sources discarded or forgot about the tissue and cells, and ownership should remain with their institution. Whereas human subjects or donors are contending to retain the proprietary rights to their own cells and preserve the moral justification under which people are not property, but do have individual sovereignty and self-ownership. Human subject, patients, or donors should hold the rights, receive ownership acknowledgement in patents, and reap fiduciary benefits of any scientific development found while using their individual cells.
Self-ownership vs. Cell ownership, to many people, there should be no difference. Consider cells that were taken from your body like blood because you are ill or tissue of a mole removed from your arm. They will test those cells and tissues to aid in a diagnosis. By law, in the United States, the cells and tissue worked on and reviewed outside of your body by the lab are now property of that institution. Therefore, no matter whose body the sample came from, that person has no property rights. Although now an institution of research and development does, the rights to those cells are now...

... middle of paper ...

...ees ownership, it is clear that you can hold rights to tangible property. Whatever else I might own in this life it would seem obvious that I own the cells of my body. Where else could the idea and concept of ownership begin other than the discernible physical structure that all would recognize as “me”. Ownership and rights of cells and tissues outside of the body should rightfully be those of the original person, from whom they were taken, as it can clearly link its origin to them. Acknowledgement, if chosen by cells original owner, should be written in patents and publications, as it was their state of nature that was altered. Last but, not least, some percentage of monies earned and potential benefits of scientific discovery or development found while using their individual cells should be compensated, to the person from whom the cells originated.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Cell Phones for Children: A Clear and Present Danger Essay

- It starts in grade school now, “Why can’t I have a cell phone; everybody else does?” From the perspective of a Generation Y or the Millennials, a person born between 1984- 2002, owning a cell phone did not take place until after high school. This makes it hard to imagine an eight year old toting around a cell phone. Parents have to make a decision based on a child’s maturity level as well as asking the big question: Will ownership of a cell phone help or hinder the child. While cell phones can be a security measure for children, when a child is given a cell phone at an early age, the doorway to possible problems is opened....   [tags: Cell Phone Safety]

Strong Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)

Defining Ownership of Ones Body Essay

- Before one can answer the question of “Who Owns the Body?” it must be defined what the body is. The spiritual route of defining the body is to encompass the “soul” or “spirit” inside of the body. This is a deeper form of ownership in that an individual’s integral being is controlled as opposed to simply their physical form. Merriam-Webster defines the body as “a person's or animal's whole physical self” (Merriam-Webster). The physical form of the body is a factual, concrete definition of the body, giving it more merit in society, and in law institutions....   [tags: abortion, treatments, research]

Strong Essays
643 words (1.8 pages)

Essay on Ownership of Human Genes

- Ownership of Human Genes With the advent of the Human Genome Project, a Pandora's box of ethical, legal, economic, and social issues was irrevocably released. The project, which aims to map the entire human genome by the year 2005, is an enormous international undertaking (7). At the onset, many realized that redundancy and its extraordinary cost could be minimized through international collaboration. With a $3 billion allocation to the DOE (Department of Energy) and NIH (National Institute of Health) towards this project, a database of sequences and gene identifications was established and research poured in from countries around the world such as France, Britain, Switzerland, and Japan....   [tags: Genetics Science Technology Papers]

Strong Essays
2431 words (6.9 pages)

Ethical Decision on Embryonic Stem Cell Contributions Essays

- If a revolution of medical technology is allowing people to obtain the best quality of life right now, why aren't we taking advantage. Scientists have discovered how to potentially cure diseases and treat all kinds of ailments. Human embryonic stem cells, though a new concept, has been debated over since the discovery in cord blood in 1978. The cause for controversy comes from the struggle between law makers, religious officials, and scientists surrounding this topic. The ethical question on why stem cells are controversial is “Is using stem cells from embryos right?” However, the question when politicians are included changes to “How can we fund research to killing potential people for the...   [tags: medical technology issues]

Strong Essays
1025 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Stem Cells, Umbilical Cord Blood Banking and Transplantation

- Nowadays, there are many alternatives or any other methods to improve the healthcare especially in a transplantation world. There are few choices available for the people today such as the embryonic stem cells, bone marrow stem cells, peripheral blood cell and the most new is the umbilical cord blood. The umbilical cord blood (UCB) defined by Chima and Mamdoo (2011, p. 79) as the blood which taken from the cut umbilical cord attached to the placenta of a newborn baby after a delivery. It been stated (Chima and Mamdoo 2011, p....   [tags: Stem Cell Research paper]

Free Essays
2886 words (8.2 pages)

The Ethical Dilemma Of The Polio Vaccine, Gene Mapping, And Even Cloning

- Imagine being the seed that germinates a billion dollar industry, and leads to a plethora of medical innovations and advancements, without granting informed consent or being compensated for your part in a movement that transmogrified the landscape of the medical world. Though one could ponder the ethical quandary delineated in such a hypothetical situation, this very event has already transpired. Henrietta Lacks, an impoverished African-American woman who suffered from cervical cancer, died in 1951 and was the unknowing seed, or in this case cell, that germinated the very tangible billion dollar medical industry created by her cell line....   [tags: HeLa, Cell culture, Henrietta Lacks]

Strong Essays
1112 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Issue Of Stem Cell

- Introduction The term stem cell is a broad term that when spoken often comes along with positive language such as untapped potential, therapeutic treatment, and self-revival. However, this same term when spoken also comes along with alarming language such as ethically questionable, widely unproven, and even in-humane. By definition, “stem cells are characterized by their ability to self-renew and to differentiate into multiple different cell types and tissues” (Koch, Berg, and Betts, 155). Stem cells are undeveloped cells that are able to, once injected into the afflicted organ, tissue, or bone, self-renew into the cells that belong to that bodily region....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Strong Essays
1794 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on The Ethical Issue Of Stem Cell Research

- Is destroying life to prolong another, ethical. What if the life you are destroying has no thoughts, no memories. What if it is alive but not truly living. That is the ethical dilemma for embryonic stem cell research. Is it right to use and study stem cells from human fetuses, to potentially lengthen the life of a terminally ill cancer patient. While some would say no right off the bat, if they were properly educated on the subject, they might just change their minds. Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) are stem cells derived from the undifferentiated inner mass cells of a human embryo....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell, Organ transplant]

Strong Essays
1036 words (3 pages)

The Issue Of Gun Ownership And Utilization Essay

- School shootings, gun disputes, a significant number of events inclining on today’s news have identified as anything related to weapons or acts of brutality. When will the America 's government regulate laws to address these issues. When has this become a daily routine in the general public, when will America obtain the change it deserves?Current US citizens question regulations required and moreover, what sorts of hindrances are legitimate to restrain gun ownership and utilization. This issue is much more essential than individuals might suspect, as this choice is influencing the American society and citizen 's security....   [tags: Firearm, Gun violence in the United States]

Strong Essays
1180 words (3.4 pages)

A Controversial Issue Of Stem Cell Research Essays

- Stem cell research has proven to be a controversial issue since its inception due to the high number of stakeholders in the matter. These include biologists, medical corporations, ethicists, governments, politicians, donors, patients, and researchers. While the methods and research are extremely complicated, the premise behind it is actually quite simple: to isolate stem cells in the hopes of reproduction and growth eventually to be used for therapy, treatments, and cures (Watson and Freudenrich 2)....   [tags: Stem cell, Cellular differentiation, Stem cells]

Strong Essays
2294 words (6.6 pages)