The Issue Of A Retroactive Legislation Essay

The Issue Of A Retroactive Legislation Essay

Length: 1215 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Retroactive legislation is a clear indication of Austin’s account of sovereignty, whereby the power of the sovereign of Albion cannot be legally limited. Quintessentially, John Austin argued that constitutional laws are ”positive morality that the sovereign may disregard” . Thus, it appears that the sovereign need not comply with the Albion’s Convention of Rights. Per contra, one may wish to argue that Austin’s theory, whilst to an extent applicable in the United Kingdom, fails to account for constitutional democracies such as the United States where it is profusely clear that the sovereignty is indeed limited . Thus, it is debatable whether Austin’s theory and its applicability to this case scenario would outweigh the arguments presented against Jim’s defence.
The reference to ‘pyramid of law’ strongly suggests Kelsen and his concept of hierarchy of norms. For Kelsen, the constitution draws its validity only from the highest presupposed Grundnorm . Albeit, one may wish to argue that the retroactive norm need not be constitutionally correct, so long as it is Grundnorm-compatible, the perhaps stronger argument which is more in line with Kelsen’s view, is that the constitution which is positioned higher in the hierarchy will take precedence when laws are at conflict and thus invalidate the retroactive norm.
Whilst for Austin ‘the sovereign makes all the laws, for Hart the rules make the sovereign’ . Thence, since Albion has an ‘accepted constitution’ it constitutes part of the rule of recognition which determines the validity of law; with Hart advocating that “in some systems of law, as in the United States, the ultimate criteria of legal validity might explicitly incorporate […] legal constitutional restraints” . Thence, it ...

... middle of paper ...

...ish to advocate that albeit they have experienced a certain degree of hostility they are certainly not the least advantaged group in the society. Sequitur the application of the Critical Race Theory is also limited in such circumstances. The retroactive legislation and the exemption of the richest citizens would be best described by Marx and his theory of ‘laws of the bourgeoisie’, as there are the interests of the ‘most powerful class’ in the society that would be represented by the law .

Ultimately, the cornerstone of the liberal democracy of Albion, ie the equality before the law, need not be sacrificed, as the hostility shall not be used to excuse the rich citizens of Albion from paying due taxes. Perhaps, as Finnis would argue, this is what ‘the common good’ requires and what the natural lawyers per se would advocate as being the only just and fair solution.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Case Study : Retroactive Grade Inflation Essay

- Case Study #3 Case 6: Retroactive Grade Inflation The academic integrity of many academic institutions nationwide is becoming more challenging. This case study presents an example on how the academic integrity of Loyola Law School in Los Angeles is being challenged after they’ve decided to inflate students GPAs. The central moral issue in the case revolves around the fact that Loyola Law School in Los Angeles retroactively inflated its students‘ GPAs by 0.333. The grade inflation will effortlessly grant a student with an A- an A....   [tags: Ethics, Deontological ethics, Immanuel Kant]

Strong Essays
717 words (2 pages)

Breed Specific Legislation Essay

- Breed-specific legislation is a broad term that includes laws that ban or restrict the type of dog a person can own. Bree- specific legislation, or BSL for short, is often described as something that protects people or makes the world a safer place. In reality, there are many issues with this type of legislation. The whole premise of BSL is based off of misconceptions, it punishes innocent people and animals, and it does not ultimately lower the amount of people bitten each year where it is implemented....   [tags: Dogs, Dog Owners, Legislation]

Strong Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)

The Issue of Gun Control Legislation Essay

- The Issue of Gun Control Legislation One of the most controversial issues in our society is gun control legislation. Violence associated with guns is increasing every year and something must be done to stop it. Gun legislation varies in every state. In some states gun policy is stricter than in other states. Gun legislation should be abolished in favor of federal gun legislation. To analyze the problem with gun violence today you must understand the gun laws that are in effect. The gun legislation in the United States are mostly based on a state level....   [tags: Gun Control Weapons Laws Essays]

Strong Essays
1603 words (4.6 pages)

Legislation That Affects the Use of the Internet in Alberta Public Libraries

- It is difficult to overstate the important role that the Internet plays in public libraries. Patrons can use the Internet to find information, access services, and maintain connections with social media, while library staff can use the Internet to access informational resources, compile and maintain library statistics, stay networked with other libraries, and store files on "the cloud" . The Alberta government is working to make high-speed Internet available in all public libraries across the province; as of 2009, they had nearly reached their goal (just 15 of Alberta's 310 municipal public libraries that were not able to get high-speed Internet access due to problems with their infrastruc...   [tags: Internet Legislation in Alberta]

Strong Essays
2219 words (6.3 pages)

Essay Mental Health Legislation And The Criminal Legislation

- The Criminal Code is an example of legislation that is more aimed at protecting the public and obtaining justice, rather than ensuring psychiatric offenders are treated. That being said, mental health does not only become a legal problem if a mentally ill person enters the justice system. Law plays a large role in access to treatment in a general sense. In British Columbia (BC), the main legislation in this area is the Mental Health Act (MHA). It allows for the same treatment that is used in most jurisdictions – voluntary or involuntary treatment....   [tags: Psychiatry, Mental disorder, Mental health]

Strong Essays
2250 words (6.4 pages)

Political Polarization and its Affect on Human Services Legislation Essay

- We live in a world in which political trends can be very powerful, and yet feel far removed from our own spheres of existence. Policies get passed, politicians move into and out of office, and not much seems to really change. However, within the realm of human services, politics are especially salient and have the ability to impact not only our nation at large, but millions of individual lives as well. In the United States, the political party scene can be simplified into two main camps: the liberals (typically Democrats) and the conservatives (typically Republicans)....   [tags: Liberals, Legislation, Political Trends, Policies]

Strong Essays
1588 words (4.5 pages)

Legislation of ICT Essay

- Legislation of ICT The purpose of legislation is to control and regulate the use of ICT. Different acts in result in different benefits to the end user or other people affected by the technology. Use of computer systems can be intrusive and can lead to the loss of privacy to the individual. I will show below how legislation can protect against this intrusion. There many other problems and opportunities that are presented by the use of ICT. Legislation protects people and ensures that there is no abuse by others to those investing in the technology....   [tags: ICT Essays]

Strong Essays
1205 words (3.4 pages)

ICT and Legislation Essay

- ICT and Legislation New laws have been made to deal with issues and problems that have come about with using ICT. These issues include: * Misuse of personal information * Health and safety * Computer Viruses * Intrusion * Fraud Without these laws these problems would be more of a major issue than they already are. These laws were made to protect people from such things as fraud where people can get access to your personal details e.g. credit card details and they can buy things off your credit card....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
702 words (2 pages)

Legislation and ICT Essay

- Legislation and ICT The Health and Safety Act of 1974 was set up as a means to protect employees, the public, management and stop safety hazards at work. This is achieved by enforcing strict guide lines that all it may affect must abide by. Failure to do so can result in punishment and fines. The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1989 makes it illegal to copy or steal software in order to protect the designer’s prophets. This is done by placing a © symbol on all products protected by this act....   [tags: ICT Essays]

Free Essays
930 words (2.7 pages)

Coal Legislation Essay

- Coal Coal is a fossil fuel- hydrocarbon containing natural resource, much like petroleum or natural gas. It is extracted from the Earth by strip mining or underground mining. It is a readily combustible black sedimentary rock, which is one of the three main rock categories. Coal is composed of carbon and hydrocarbons, in coordination with other elements. It is the leading source of electricity the world over. It is estimated that half of the world’s electricity is powered by coal. Coal mining in the United States is recorded to have first occurred in Virginia when 50 tons were purged from the earth in 1748 (   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1257 words (3.6 pages)