Is rule-utilitarianism preferable to act-utilitarianism Essay

Is rule-utilitarianism preferable to act-utilitarianism Essay

Length: 1769 words (5.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Is rule-utilitarianism preferable to act-utilitarianism?

Classical utilitarianism is a normative ethical theory which holds that an action can only be considered as morally right where its consequences bring about the greatest amount of good to the greatest number (where 'good' is equal to pleasure minus pain). Likewise, an action is morally wrong where it fails to maximise good. Since it was first articulated in the late 19th Century by the likes of Jeremy Bentham and later John Stewart Mill, the classical approach to utilitarianism has since become the basis for many other consequentialist theories such as rule-utilitarianism and act-utilitarianism upon which this essay will focus (Driver, 2009). Though birthed from the same utilitarian principle of maximising good, rule-utilitarianism and act-utilitarianism provide two very different accounts on how the maximising of good should be approached. This essay will compare these two approaches and try to ascertain whether rule-utilitarianism is indeed preferable to act-utilitarianism.

Act-utilitarianism is a direct form of consequentialism in that its principles are applied directly to ones actions under particular circumstances and the action is then judged as morally permissible or impermissible based solely on whether your action achieved or failed to maximise pleasure. In contrast, rule-utilitarianism is considered indirect because your actions are carried out according to a set of accepted moral rules of which compliance with which would ensure maximum aggregate good. Whether an action is morally permissible or impermissible is judged on your adherence to the agreed set of moral rules as opposed to the direct outcome of your actions. It would seem already that rule-utilitaria...

... middle of paper ...

...ough its own capacity as a theory of both decision making and moral judgement, and by default- as act-utilitarianism has been proved too demanding and often immoral by our common sense intuition- I conclude that rule-utilitarianism is indeed preferable to act-utilitarianism.

Works Cited

Driver, J. 2009. The History of Utilitarianism. [online] Available at: [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].
Hooker, B. 2003. Rule Consequentialism. Read in: Shafer-Landau, R. 2013. Ethical Theory: An Anthology, Second Edition. Wiley-Blackwell.
Hooker, B. 2003. Rule Consequentialism. [online] Available at: [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].
Sinnott-Armstrong, W. 2003. Consequentialism. [online] Available at: [Accessed: 14 Mar 2014].

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Kantian Ethics And Rule Utilitarianism

- James Liang is one of the Volkswagen engineers who helped to deceive the United States government as to the emissions produced by Volkswagen’s diesel engines. The Volkswagen team built the diesel engines in 2006, but failed to meet the American emissions standards. Instead of delaying their launch in America or redesigning the engines, the engineers chose to include software that recognized emissions testing and changed the settings of the engine to meet the standards during tests. When not being tested, these engines produced up to 40 times the allowed emissions....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Philosophy, Ethics]

Powerful Essays
952 words (2.7 pages)

Utilitarianism, Utilitarianism And Rule Utilitarianism Essay

- Utilitarianism is a moral theory that states that an action is considered right as long as it promotes the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. This theory was first proposed by Jeremy Bentham and later was refined by J.S Mill. Mill differs from Bentham by introducing a qualitative view on pleasure and makes a distinction between act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism. John Hospers critiques utilitarianism and shows that rule utilitarianism under more specific and stricter rules would promote utility better....   [tags: Utilitarianism, Ethics, Jeremy Bentham]

Powerful Essays
1570 words (4.5 pages)

The And Utilitarianism And Rule Utilitarianism Essay

- Utilitarians are people who believe that good is everyone’s pleasure. This is simply what they call general happiness. They believe that happiness is primarily pleasure and the absence of pain. Utilitarians think actions that give most pleasure to a larger quantity of people is morally right. Their two basic view consist of believing that we should nurture everyone’s happiness and not just one’s own, and accepting that some pleasures are bigger than others. Act and Rule Utilitarianism is based on two principles called the Consequentialist Principle and the Utility Principle....   [tags: Morality, Utilitarianism, Ethics, Human]

Powerful Essays
1411 words (4 pages)

Essay on Critisism for Rule and Act Utilitarianism

- “Utilitarianism is the view that the supreme principle of morality is to act so as to produce as much happiness as possible, each person counting equally” (Mill, 114). By ‘happiness’, this includes anything that is pleasurable and free of pain. Simply put, utilitarianism is the theory that an action is right, as long as it produces the greatest good for the most number of people (Peetush). The central point to this theory is that one must consider every consequence before taking any action. There are two classical forms of utilitarianism; rule utilitarianism and act utilitarianism....   [tags: utility, individuals, justice]

Powerful Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Using Utilitarianism to Address Abortion Essay

- ... So if a parent decides not to get an abortion and has the baby, and the baby grows up to live a terrible life filled with misery and unhappiness, then in this case abortion would be morally impermissible. If the parents, family members, or anyone involved with abortion is effected in a negative way that outweighs the positives, then abortion is morally impermissible again. In another case, if an abortion produces more good than bad in the parents, babies, or anyone else involved in the abortion, then abortion is morally permissible....   [tags: act and rule, morality]

Powerful Essays
1293 words (3.7 pages)

Shafer Landau An Act Utilitarianism Essay

- Answer (A) According to the book Shafer Landau an act utilitarianism is “the version of act consequentialism that says that only well-being is intrinsically valuable, and so says that an act is morally right just because it maximizes overall well-being” (Shafer Landau, G1). In the other words, it means that the act that produces the maximum of the happiness at that time than any other act. Another similar example of this act for the better understanding is, if I have a friend and being with her gives me the most happiness than being with any other friends at that time, but it does not give the same happiness to her and I am unaware about it at that time then it’s also defines as an act...   [tags: Utilitarianism, Ethics, Consequentialism]

Powerful Essays
906 words (2.6 pages)

Ethical Relativism And Act Utilitarianism Essay examples

- Question 1: Consider a landscaping company that employs illegal aliens. The owner of the company pays them $3.00 an hour and keeps $17.00 for each hour they work to cover operating costs and personal profit. If the employer did not make this margin of profit, he would not be willing to run the company. Without this company, many local businesses would have to pay more for landscaping services. Thoroughly assess this situation from the two different perspectives of Ethical Relativism and Act Utilitarianism (Jeremy Bentham)....   [tags: Ethics, Utilitarianism, Morality]

Powerful Essays
1593 words (4.6 pages)

Utilitarianism And Utilitarianism Essay

- Throughout this essay, when describing defensible utilitarianism, it will refer to the term defensible as defined in the Oxford English Dictionary (2011), because this version is typically understood by all academics studying under the British English language. The term utilitarianism is supported on the basis of morals and acts which can be deemed either right or wrong (Concise Oxford English Dictionary, 2011). The purpose of this essay will be to identify the advantages and disadvantages of utilitarianism, with consideration of morally right acts and morally wrong acts....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Human, Utilitarianism]

Powerful Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on Act and Rule Utilitarianism: Article Review

- “The only rational course of action is to allow people to override the rules in the interest of the greatest utility.” Act and Rule Utilitarianism are said to be very similar and maybe even collapse into each other when trying to distinguish one from the other. One article has distinguished between act and rule utilitarianism by referring to them as "extreme" and "restricted" utilitarianism. This article claims that the extreme or act version of utilitarianism will use the rules of morality as rules of thumb only....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
842 words (2.4 pages)

Utilitarianism Essay

- This essay will present the key features of Utilitarianism and identify the problems of Utilitarianism to the extent to which they make Utilitarianism unacceptable. Jeremy Bentham founded Utilitarianism. He lived at a time of great change. With revolutions in France and America, demands were being made for human rights and greater democracy. Bentham worked on legal reform. Utilitarianism is associated with the principle of utility. Utility means the amount of satisfaction or pleasure that somebody gains from consuming a commodity, product, or service, i.e.; useful....   [tags: criticisms of utilitarianism]

Powerful Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)