Is Racism in the Heart? by Tommie Shelby Essay

Is Racism in the Heart? by Tommie Shelby Essay

Length: 1353 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Racism is not a factor of the heart, according to Tommie Shelby in “Is Racism in the ‘Heart’?” He writes “the ‘heart’ does not have to be involved in order for an action or institution to be racist” (483). Instead, Shelby argues that racism is based on the effect of a person’s actions on deepening racist institutions or promulgating the oppression of a particular group of people based on their race. The individual intention of a person or the “purity” or his or her heart does not take precedence over the effect of his or her actions. Shelby’s argument is constructed as follows: Individual beliefs can be true or false but not inherently immoral. Therefore, it is not appropriate to morally condemn someone for holding a particular belief. However, when the particular belief leads to “race-based hatred...actions...or institutions” that is when it becomes appropriate to hold the individual with the belief morally culpable for racism.
Shelby suggests that Jorge Garcia presents an inadequate conception of racism, hence a new, more nuanced concept of racism is necessitated. Garcia contends that “racism is always wrong” and that it is an “individual moral vice” (479). Garcia’s “infection model” explains that an “act is racist insofar as a racist heart infects the conduct of the racist; and an institution is racist insofar as it is rooted in the racist attitudes and the resulting racist-infected actions of its founds and/or current functions” (479). Shelby’s response to this is that an action can be racist even if it is separate from racist intentions. Shelby perceives that Garcia holds the idea that “racist beliefs are a secondary and an inessential feature of racism” since “race-based non-cognitive attitudes are the key ingredient, an...


... middle of paper ...


...Shelby argues that this belief is not a valid excuse for behaviors that ultimately propagate racist norms and institutions (480).
Are racist attitudes necessary for racism? This is not the case according to Shelby. It is not the intention of an action that makes the action racist. It is the fact that the action contributes to the oppression of an “other.” While racist beliefs are more nefarious than intentions, Shelby only considers beliefs racist if the inner belief contributes to racist ideology. He ultimately argues that a person is racist if his or her actions promulgate racist institutions, despite the person’s original intentions or condition of the heart.


Works Cited

Shelby, T. (2002) “Is Racism in the Heart?” In G. L. Bowie, M. W. Michaels, and R. C. Solomon (Eds.), Twenty Questions: An Introduction to Philosophy (479-483). Boston, MA: Wadsworth.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Racism in Resident Evil 5

- Introduction When the gameplay trailer of Resident Evil 5 (RE5) was released in October of 2007 it attracted a lot of media attention surrounding racism. There were both ‘for’ and ‘against’ the idea that RE5 is a racist game. Earl Ofari Hutchinson made himself know by saying that “RE5 is a very racist game” however there were other commentators such as Jim Sterling who made himself known by defending RE5 by saying “He laughs at the idea of RE5 is racist. The stereotypical characters and settings in the game caused a lot of controversy, and yet it was not withdrawn from the UK market....   [tags: setting, zombies, africa]

Strong Essays
3327 words (9.5 pages)

Marlow's Racism in Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness Essay

- Marlow's Racism in Heart of Darkness          Heart of Darkness is an intriguing story as well as a symbol for Joseph Conrad's social commentary on imperialism.  Marlow's journey takes him deep into the African Congo where he bears witness to a number of life-altering revelations.  He beholds his most striking revelation when he begins to compare the "civilized European man" with the "savage African man."  These two opposing forces represent the two conflicting viewpoints present in every dilemma, be it cultural, social, or otherwise.  As a modern European man who believes religiously in imperialism, Marlow is inherently arrogant.  Yet, although he cannot accept the African jungle as bei...   [tags: Heart Darkness Prejudice Racism]

Strong Essays
3601 words (10.3 pages)

The Age of White Guilt by Shelby Steele Essay

- The Real Fault INTRODUCTION: “On his show Monday night, Sean Hannity spoke with Ann Coulter about the racism and the narrative she said the media is pushing in order to avoid discussing difficult issues. Everyone would be better off without “white guilt,” Coulter argued — decrying that all liberals want to talk about is racism.Rattling off a list of foreign policy concerns, Hannity noted that Democrats aren’t talking about any of those issues, “because all they can do is accuse Republicans of racism.” We’ve gotten to a point where everything is deemed racist, he and Coulter agreed....   [tags: white guilt, republicans, racism]

Strong Essays
1540 words (4.4 pages)

Prejudice and Racism - No Racism in Heart of Darkness Essay

- No Racism in Heart of Darkness      Chinua Achebe challenges Joseph Conrad's novella depicting the looting of Africa, Heart of Darkness (1902) in his essay "An Image of Africa" (1975). Achebe's is an indignant yet solidly rooted argument that brings the perspective of a celebrated African writer who chips away at the almost universal acceptance of the work as "classic," and proclaims that Conrad had written "a bloody racist book" (Achebe 319). In her introduction in the Signet 1997 edition, Joyce Carol Oates writes, "[Conrad's] African natives are "dusty niggers," cannibals." Conrad [...] painfully reveals himself in such passages, and numerous others, as an unquestioning heir of centuri...   [tags: HOD Joseph Conrad Heart of Darkness]

Strong Essays
1109 words (3.2 pages)

Essay Prejudice in Heart of Darkness - Racism in the Heart

- Racism in Heart of Darkness I find no elements of racism in Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness. I will admit that I began reading this with a little hesitation based on the fact that I do not like to read about human cruelty. However, after reading the story, I did not feel any negative feelings toward the story or author. I feel one must realize that the occurrences of this story were really happening. I do not feel that by the virtue of performing a task that one is hired to do makes one a racist....   [tags: HOD Joseph Conrad Heart of Darkness]

Free Essays
587 words (1.7 pages)

Prejudice and Racism in Heart of Darkness? Essay

- Heart of Darkness: Racist or not.   Many critics, including Chinua Achebe in his essay "An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad's Heart of Darkness", have made the claim that Joseph Conrad's novel Heart of Darkness, despite the insights which it offers into the human condition, ought to be removed from the canon of Western literature. This claim is based on the supposition that the novel is racist, more so than other novels of its time. While it can be read in this way, it is possible to look under the surface and create an interpretation of Conrad's novel that does not require the supposition of extreme racism on the part of Conrad....   [tags: HOD Joseph Conrad Heart of Darkness]

Strong Essays
874 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about Prejudice and Racism in Heart of Darkness

- Racism in Heart of Darkness        Heart of Darkness is a social commentary on imperialism, but the characters and symbols in the book have a meaning for both the psychological and cultural aspects of Marlow’s journey.  Within the framework of Marlow’s psychedelic experience is an exploration of the views the European man holds of the African man. These views express the conflict between the civilized and the savage, the modern and the primordial, the individual and the collective, the moral and the amoral, that is part of the general psychedelic experience....   [tags: HOD Joseph Conrad Heart of Darkness]

Strong Essays
3449 words (9.9 pages)

Essay about Prejudice and Racism - The Tone of Racism in Heart of Darkness

- Heart of Darkness:  The Tone of Racism “An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad's Heart of Darkness,” by Chinua Achebe, addresses the issue of racism as seen throughout Joseph Conrad's work. There is a certain degree of subtlety that Achebe uses to begin to confront the racism issue, but as the story goes on it is easy to tell his opinion. Achebe states his opinion not only on Heart of Darkness but also makes clear his opinion concerning Conrad by the end of the essay. The tone in “An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad's Heart of Darkness” changes dramatically from start to finish....   [tags: Heart Darkness essays]

Free Essays
758 words (2.2 pages)

Prejudice and Racism in Conrad's Heart of Darkness Essay examples

- Racism in Heart of Darkness         Joseph Conrad develops themes of personal power, individual responsibility, and social justice in his book Heart of Darkness. His book contains all the trappings of the conventional adventure tale: mystery, exotic setting, escape, suspense, and unexpected attack. Chinua Achebe concluded, "Conrad, on the other hand, is undoubtedly one of the great stylists of modern fiction and a good story-teller into the bargain" (Achebe 252). Yet, despite Conrad's great story telling, he has also been viewed as a racist by some of his critics....   [tags: Heart Darkness essays]

Free Essays
1029 words (2.9 pages)

Shelby Foote's Shiloh Essay

- Shelby Foote's Shiloh In the novel Shiloh, historian and Civil War expert Shelby Foote delivers a spare, unflinching account of the battle of Shiloh, which was fought over the course of two days in April 1862. By mirroring the troops' movements through the woods of Tennessee with the activity of each soldier's mind, Foote offers the reader a broad perspective of the battle and a detailed view of the issues behind it. The battle becomes tangible as Foote interweaves the observations of Union and Confederate officers, simple foot soldiers, brave men, and cowards and describes the roar of the muskets and the haze of the gun smoke....   [tags: Shelby Foote Shiloh Battles War Essays]

Strong Essays
1656 words (4.7 pages)