Is Corporal Punishment Effective? Essay

Is Corporal Punishment Effective? Essay

Length: 1663 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Corporal Punishment

On a student’s cell phone, a teacher is caught hitting students with a thick stick. He continually hits everywhere from the students’ hips to the head harshly without a hesitation. This video is opened to the public by a student in the class posting it on the Internet. According to the other students, they were punished because they skipped class when the school inspectors came. All the people who looked at it on the Internet were surprised to see this kind of behavior. Recently, we’ve heard a lot on the media about punishment by teachers in school. Some people agree with the teacher’s power to punish, claiming that it is a part of education. However, contrary to this opinion, I disagree with corporal punishment because physical punishment brings only temporary effects in correcting children’s behavior. Also, it can humiliate a child by insulting his or her personality and have a poor affect on their self esteem. Besides, physical punishment can be abused because there aren’t any concrete standards to regulate how much punishment is proper in disciplining.
Hyman (1989) says corporal punishment refers to intentional application of physical pain as a method of changing behavior. It includes a wide variety of methods such as hitting, slapping, punching, kicking, pinching, shaking, choking, use of various objects (wooden paddles, belts, sticks, pins, or others), painful body postures, use of electric shock, use of excessive exercise drills, or prevention of urine or stool limination (p.161).
The effect of the corporal punishment
Some people believe that teachers’ using physical punishment is the most effective way to educate students. It is largely because they believe it brings a very quick r...

... middle of paper ...

...bad behavior. However, I cannot completely agree with physical punishment. It is largely because the effects of corporal punishment are just temporary. Also, according to studies, physical punishment has had a bad effect on students such as students imitating the corporally-punishing behavior of their parents or teachers and reducing self-esteem and the IQ of children. Corporal punishment can be abused as well. Most teachers are now using corporal punishment out of anger instead of using it to correctly change behavior of students. Spanking children is an action that goes against the times and it is time for a change in the world. Corporal punishment isn’t the best way to discipline children. There are other ways like encouragement and consultation. All in all, I can say without hesitation that we should find other means of discipline instead of corporal punishment.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Should Corporal Punishment Be More Effective Or Successful Than Imprisonment?

- In Bring back flogging, Jeff Jacob argues that the current criminal justice system in America is not effective or successful. He then suggests that America should bring back the old fashioned form of punishment once used by the puritans, flogging, as an alternative to imprisonment (198). Also, he says that corporal punishment is a better way to punish criminals since it is less costly for the state (98). He appeals to pathos and uses statistics to prove his thesis and persuade the audience. His argument that the current criminal justice system is not working is extremely convincing; however, he gives no reason why corporal punishment is the best alternative to imprisonment and never offers a...   [tags: Criminal justice, Crime, Prison, Punishment]

Powerful Essays
1128 words (3.2 pages)

How Should Corporal Punishment Be More Effective Or Successful Than Imprisonment?

- In “Bring Back Flogging,” Jeff Jacoby, a journalist, argues why the current criminal justice system in America is not effective or successful. As a solution, he suggests that America should bring back the old fashioned form of punishment, flogging, once used by the Puritans as an alternative to imprisonment (198). This article originally appeared in the op-ed section of the Boston Globe. Therefore, the primary audience of this article is people who want to read arguments about controversial topics and have probably read some of Jacoby’s other articles....   [tags: Prison, Criminal justice, Crime, Punishment]

Powerful Essays
1417 words (4 pages)

Disciplinary Spanking Is Not Child Abuse Essay

- Child abuse is an issue within society that effects the lives of not only the victims but also the lives of many people in the social order. Child abuse is any mistreatment or neglect of a child that results in non-accidental injury or harm and which cannot be logically explained. There are several forms of abuse and neglect and many state governments have developed their own legal description of what constitutes child maltreatment for the purposes of removing a child and prosecuting a criminal charge....   [tags: Effective Use of Corporal Punishment]

Powerful Essays
1640 words (4.7 pages)

Should Corporal Punishment Be Allowed? Schools? Essay

- Whether corporal punishment should be allowed in schools has been long disputed. Advocates reason corporal punishment is necessary to produce well-behaved children (Hicks-Pass 71.) Although these supporters of corporal punishment in schools argue it is a normal, necessary part of child education and a successful way to enforce appropriate behavior, it should not be permitted due to the great potential of long-lasting, harmful effects on students such as damaging their self-esteem and causing the belief that violence is acceptable and as there are alternative disciplinary actions that are far more effective such as providing direction and teaching personal responsibility in ways that are mea...   [tags: Corporal punishment, School corporal punishment]

Powerful Essays
1515 words (4.3 pages)

The Effects Of Corporal Punishment On Children Essay

- The use of corporal punishment is not effective, and can have negative long term effects on children. Of the many different forms of discipline, corporal punishment is one of them. This act of punishment can be defined as the intentional infliction of pain on the body, usually done on children by spanking or with a paddle. Though there are parents who still do this in their household, it is not necessary or very effective long-term. Being that it is a true public health issue in the United States, both the society that we live in and the mental health of children are clearly at stake when it comes to physical punishment....   [tags: Corporal punishment, Spanking]

Powerful Essays
1136 words (3.2 pages)

The Effects Of Corporal Punishment On Children Essay

- Think of the Children Cultures throughout the world view corporal punishment with varying degrees of approval. In thirty-three countries, most notably those in Scandinavia, physical discipline of children is illegal, which gives children the same rights to safety as spouses. In other countries, including the US, bodily punishment is legal and common. Despite the widespread use of corporal punishment, parents should not physically discipline their children. Due to the negative effects of corporal punishment on children’s futures, parents should not physically discipline their children....   [tags: Corporal punishment, Spanking]

Powerful Essays
738 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Effects Of Corporal Punishment On Children

- Corporal punishment among children has been around for decades. Many years ago, it was allowed for educators to punish students who were misbehaving by hitting them with a wooden paddle on their behind. As time continued to pass, it became against the law for the school employees to discipline the students who took part in misconduct. The parents became the only people with the right to discipline their children. Today, parents continue to have the right to spank their children however it is now an issue that is frowned upon by many....   [tags: Corporal punishment, Spanking, Caning]

Powerful Essays
1283 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about The Morality Of Corporal Punishment On Children

- The Morality of Corporal Punishment on Children In order for a house to stand, there must be a strong foundation. The same is true in a society; if children are raised with strong discipline, the civilization that they lead will also stand strong. In many circumstances, parents find the situation appropriate to control their children through physical means in order to ensure a negative action is not repeated. This notion is ideal in theory; however, some people see a negative effect that it has on the children....   [tags: Suffering, Pain, Corporal punishment, Spanking]

Powerful Essays
1255 words (3.6 pages)

We Must Put an End to Corporal Punishment Essay

- There was an old woman who lived in a shoe She had so many children she didn't know what to do She gave them some broth, Without any bread Whipped them all soundly, and sent them to bed (Mother Goose).   All across American households, adults whip, spank, paddle, and swat children as a form of acceptable punishment and as deterrent to unwanted behaviors. These actions are considered corporal punishment, and can be defined numerous ways. The American Public Health Association defines corporal punishment as "the infliction of bodily pain as a penalty for behavior disapproved by the punisher"(American Public Health Association)....   [tags: Corporal Punishment Essays]

Powerful Essays
2374 words (6.8 pages)

Essay about Corporal Punishment

- The deciding factor in the future of corporal punishment is seen in the Ingraham v. Wright Supreme Court case. In 1970, James Ingraham, an eighth grade student of Drew Junior High School was one of the many beneficiaries of corporal punishment distributed by Willie Wright, the principal of the high school. The rationality behind Ingraham’s punishment was that he was slow to respond to his teacher instructions. As a result, his teacher sent him to the principal office where he bent over the table was given twenty licks with a paddle....   [tags: Law, Ingraham]

Powerful Essays
1731 words (4.9 pages)