Is Coherentism Not Gain Much Recognition Throughout The History Of Philosophy?

Is Coherentism Not Gain Much Recognition Throughout The History Of Philosophy?

Length: 1465 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Coherentism has not gain much recognition throughout the history of philosophy. According to the traditional definition of knowledge, knowledge is Justified True Belief. Hence, one must first justify their belief before they can acquire any knowledge. Since most of the time the knowledge we assume we have justified are beliefs that are justified based on other belief. Consequently, this promotes the concept of regress argument where the philosophers are on the quest to understand how a belief is justified. Coherentist attempts to solve the regress problem by suggesting a system of beliefs where the justification is done by referring to other beliefs within the relevant system. In this essay, I will be focused on two of the main objections to coherentism: isolation and alternative objection. While at the same time examines the concept of coherentism to determine whenever or not this is a sufficient solution to the regress problem.

The reason why coherentism has been neglected for so long throughout the history of philosophy lies in the search to find solutions for the regress argument. The regress problem brought by Aristotle and philosophers offers three options to the general question of method to justify beliefs: circles, regress, and foundations. Of these options foundationalism appears to be the most possible, this is the claim where the justification are done by referring to basic beliefs. Yet many coherentists pointed out that there is possibly a fourth option to the problem.: holism, the belief is justified if it is within a relevant justified system of beliefs, where the beliefs are able to fit together and stand in a interactive relationships with support to each other (BonJour, 2003). Sometimes coherentism gives the imp...


... middle of paper ...


...leading the regress into circle, by denying the assumption that justification requires the existence of an inferential chain of reasons, they claim it should be viewed as holistic in character instead. Other philosophers argued, for such a system of beliefs to function properly, it still require the beliefs to be justified circulatory, because all the individual beliefs that make up the system are related to one another in a circular fashion. There are many objections to the fundamental concept of coherentism, and they are: the input and isolation objection, the alternative systems objection, and the objection of truth connection. These objections do not need to be viewed separately. They can be divided into two common objections for coherentism. Despite the attempt, coherentism still fails to solve the regress problem and provide adequate respond to the objections.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Justification Of Knowledge Is Structured : Foundationalism And Coherentism

- For hundreds of years, philosophy has attempted to answer the question: what is knowledge. Although philosophers have come and go, the question still remains. Consequently, epistemology, the study of knowledge, became the focus for many famous philosophers in their search for defining knowledge as a justified true belief. However, along the way, a philosophical problem arose because of two opposing views as to how justification of knowledge is structured: foundationalism and coherentism. The former, foundationalism, is the view of the organization of justified knowledge that consists of basic, foundational beliefs that are self-justified and non-inferential, and all other beliefs are in the...   [tags: Epistemology, Foundationalism, Coherentism, Belief]

Strong Essays
751 words (2.1 pages)

History Wars: Recognition of Indigenous Australians Essay

- In the nineteenth century, the “History wars” became the fight between the most prominent historians revolving around the deception of frontier conflict between the labor and coalition. The debate aroused from the different interpretations of the violence that took place during the European colonization and to what degree. It became a crisis in history, emerging from the dispossession of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders (ATSI) that resulted in exclusion of their traditions and culture....   [tags: aborigines, human rights]

Strong Essays
1851 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on Homosexuality Throughout History

- Homosexuality can be tracked throughout history. In ancient Rome, philosophers, such as Socrates, were having sexual relations with their students. They believed it was a part of becoming a man. The Bible, one of the oldest books in literature, discusses homosexual practices among the citizens of Sodom and Gomorrah. Some of the most influential people throughout history were discovered to be homosexual: Susan B. Anthony, William Shakespeare, Leonardo Da Vinci, and Tennessee Williams. Homosexuality is worldwide and has a global impact on society; it transcends borders, cultures, and governments....   [tags: A Brief History of Homosexuality]

Strong Essays
2385 words (6.8 pages)

Laws and Rituals throughout History Began with the Code of Hammurabi Essays

- Throughout history, many civilizations have endured through a system of social, political, religious, and economic laws and rituals. Most of these laws and rituals were set up as procedures for moral behavior, family life, education, government, and business. These basic values were set forth by an early civilization known as the Babylonians. Law codes were regarded as a subject for prayer. However, to truly gain an understanding of Mesopotamia in the 17th Century BC, we should take a closer look at the penalties rather than the laws themselves....   [tags: Code of Hammurabi, history, ]

Strong Essays
1375 words (3.9 pages)

Gender Differences throughout History Essay example

- ... She provides a springboard for further investigation. The study of gender and its historical analysis has, itself, evolved. Linda Kerber in her essay Seperate Spheres, Female Worlds, Woman’s Place: The Rhetoric of Women’s History argues that the metaphor of a separate women’s sphere which she traces back to the Victorian era and to de Tocqueville’s analysis of America—and which may, indeed, have been useful at one point, in order to doth the coil of male dominance and oppression—has outlived it’s usefulness and become inherently problematic....   [tags: roles, evolve, women, history]

Strong Essays
844 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about The Interaction of Culture and Technology throughout History

- The Interaction of Culture and Technology throughout History Throughout human history, the expansion of technology has been dependent on the cultural environment into which it was introduced. Intricacies in social and cultural beliefs are among the reasons Europe’s technological dominance and expansion from the 15-1600’s to the early twentieth century. In addition, isolation and cultural conservatism are among the main reasons that Chinese culture, whose inventions range from paper to the wheelbarrow, never capitalized on their large technological advantage to expand their Empire....   [tags: World History]

Free Essays
1880 words (5.4 pages)

Epidemics and Pandemics throughout History Essay

- When looking back on history, it is evident to see that humans by nature are warriors. Humans often find themselves fighting mysterious battles against disguised enemies. Throughout history the earth has been afflicted with mysterious diseases, which tend to invisibly cause the preponderance of civilizations to perish. The evolution of infectious diseases has and always will provide challenges for humankind (Hoff, Smith, and Calisher 6-7). Over the course of time, humans gradually developed a preference to live in large urban settings....   [tags: Communicable Disease, Black Plague]

Strong Essays
1945 words (5.6 pages)

The Progression of Human Rights Throughout History Essay

- The strides that have been taken regarding human rights have made it impossible to forget the many memorable landmarks throughout history. Events dealing with civil liberties are especially important in the United States. The Revolutionary War and the passage of the nineteenth amendment are two such occurrences. The history of both the United States and human rights has not come without a fight. Americans have adapted to changes in living styles which allowed the country to battle through shifting times in order to survive....   [tags: American America History]

Strong Essays
1708 words (4.9 pages)

The Development of Childhood Throughout History Essay

- Throughout the history of childhood development poor social and economic conditions contributed to the many hardships and poor treatment of children. During the early Middle Ages the "paternalist" family concept evolved and the father had authority and control over family matters including the welfare and safety of his wife and children. Discipline was severe, young children both poor and wealthy were subjected to strict rules and regulations and often beaten if disobedient. Children took on the responsibilities of adults at an early age, sharing in the work of siblings and parents....   [tags: Sociology]

Strong Essays
3052 words (8.7 pages)

Encounters in Enemies and Recognition Essay

- Encounters in Enemies and Recognition An encounter is an unexpected meeting, and we see the leading characters in ‘Enemies’ and ‘Recognition’ having to come to terms with their past and as their encounters occur we see their changing perspective about certain issues surrounding them and how their characters develop from what they are to what they become. In ‘Enemies’ we see this being exercised upon by the leading character Mrs Clara Hansen. The title of the story ‘Enemies’ is in itself a description of what Mrs Hansen has become to her true self, an enemy....   [tags: Enemies Recognition Essays]

Free Essays
3525 words (10.1 pages)