Essay about Is Animal Experimenting (Rats, in Particular) Right or Wrong?

Essay about Is Animal Experimenting (Rats, in Particular) Right or Wrong?

Length: 1117 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When it comes the issue of killing a living being for a greater good, there are so many possible justifications for either side of the argument. If I were to take a look at this subject from a morality standpoint, I would have to approach this question differently for different types of living creatures. This could mean that the answer to the matter could change pending what creature is in question. An example of such an issue is the question to whether or not I can plausibly justify the practice of subjecting rats to these painful research experiments in a way that does not imply that it would also be permissible to subject human beings to the same painful experiments without their consent. In this paper, I will argue that it is possible to justify the painful research of rats in a way that does not justify the same treatment to human beings. This issue is important because in “The Use of Nonhuman Animals in Biomedical Research,” Ringach remarks, “history shows moral boundaries to be dynamic” (Ringach 308). This means that just because it is the societal norm does not make it morally permissible, and if that were the case in this situation, thousands of people would be murdering thousands of animals everyday.
I will open this paper by presenting my position on this issue. I will show how human beings are naturally separated from rats and what makes humans so unique. I will then go on to introduce a compelling criticism that you might have of my argument on how human babies factor into the equation. To conclude, I will demonstrate how that criticism of my argument fails.
The answer to this question lies within the similarities and differences between human beings and rats. The most significant similarity is that both...


... middle of paper ...


...owing the researcher to experiment on him, and if he does not say this then any experimentation is a violation of his right to life. In response to the critic’s other conclusion, my argument does not imply that if a person lacks goals, does not understand the concept of a future, or does not value his future then the person loses his right to life. This implication is incorrect because my argument states a future that is valuable to him, not valued by him. The difference is that the first statement means that every human being has a future, and the fact that he does, makes it valuable to him. If he were to stop valuing his own future, that does not mean the future is no longer a valuable thing. In other words, the fact that he has a future that he can steer and set goals for is a valuable thing in and of itself, regardless of whether or not it is appreciated.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Rats and Rationality by Joel Marks Essay

- Rats and Rationality by Joel Marks As the scientists Jonathan Crystal and Allison Foote have found that rats have “high mental power,” the report of the research suggests that rats can be used in future neuroscience experiments. As a result, the usage of rats in the neuroscience experiments will be increased. The author of the article, Rats and Rationality, Joel Marks argues against this proposal and emphasizes that the usage of rats in the experiments should be decreased. Mark argues that the conclusion of the research to use rats in neuroscience experiment is illogical....   [tags: Article Review]

Better Essays
982 words (2.8 pages)

Black Rats : A Bad Reputation Essay example

- Black Rats have a bad reputation then and now, to many others, rats were the main reason why people were killed in the bubonic plague in Europe. It was believed that rats spread infected diseases by biting into human skin. Rats have contributed to many endangered species like seabirds, but are rats really that vicious. Introduction to black rats The black rat is nocturnal, notwithstanding, it may become more active in the day in undisturbed areas. It is an omnivore, but haves a tendency to prefer plant matter such as fruits and seeds, although they will feed on insects, carrion, refuse and feces....   [tags: Black Death, Bubonic plague, Plague]

Better Essays
1309 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on The Black Of Black Rats

- The Black Rat Black Rats have a bad reputation then and now, to many others, rats were the main reason why people were killed in the bubonic plague in Europe. It was believed that rats spread infected diseases by biting into human skin. Rats have contributed to many endangered species like seabirds, but are rats really that vicious. Introduction to black rats The black rat is nocturnal, although it may become more active in the day in undisturbed areas (4). It is an omnivore, but tends to prefer plant matter (4) such as fruits and seeds, although it will also feed on insects, carrion, refuse and feces (2)....   [tags: Black Death, Bubonic plague, Brown rat, Plague]

Better Essays
1288 words (3.7 pages)

Animal Experimentation And The Medical Field Essay

- For centuries, the use of animal experimentation in the biomedical field has been questioned ethically. Do the benefits of animals used in research outweigh the pain that the animals endure. Animal rights activists will argue that there are new alternatives that are more accurate than animal testing. Nonetheless, scientists will continue to use animals for the advancement in the medical field because there have been various cases where animals have paved the way, medically, for humans to this day....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Better Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Growing Human Kidneys Of Rats Essay

- Growing Human Kidneys in Rats In most aspects of life we face the need to make decisions and choose right from wrong, or use personal judgement and morals to decide. These are all aspects of what we refer to as ethics and ethical principles. Within different communities there are diverse core values and ethical principles that can become individualized and bases on personal integrity and beliefs. In the medical world we have medical ethics, which then consist of a code of ethics based on your discipline that sets a standard of behavior within your job....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Abortion, Organ transplant]

Better Essays
1335 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Animal Testing Should Be Banned

- It is evaluated that every year twenty-six million animals in the United States are utilized for animal testing. Animals are utilized to test logical improvements and cosmetic products. New medicines are tried on animals to check the poisonous quality of new medication or the security of an item that will be utilized on people. The human services and business commercial enterprises additionally swing to animal testing hence. While some challenge the utilization of animals for animal testing it is not another thought....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Better Essays
1164 words (3.3 pages)

Animal Moralities and Human Negligence Essay

- Tom Regan is an American philosopher and teacher. Regan was born in November 28, 1938 in Pittsburgh, and he received his B.A. at Thiel College. He has spent most of his career teaching philosophy at North Carolina state university, where he is now professor emeritus. Regan is regarded as one of the leading intellectuals in the animal rights movement. One of his ethic essays includes “The Case for Animal Rights”, and it was published in 1985 when he was 47 years old. According to the essay “The Case for Animal Rights,” Tom Regan discusses the objectives about the abolition of the use of animal in sciences, the termination of industrial animal agriculture, and the elimination of market...   [tags: animal testing, animal industries, animal rights]

Better Essays
968 words (2.8 pages)

Animal Testing: The Future of Pharmaceuticals Essay

- Millions of chemicals have been discontinued in everyday uses, such as in plant poisons, through animal testing, they have been donned to be unsafe for people and environment. Without animal testing, the general public would still be using these hazardous chemicals. Many humanitarians may be opposed to testing chemicals on animals, but if scientists didn’t test on animals, individuals would have to test the deadly chemicals or live in a world where people don’t know if the chemicals they are using are poisonous and lethal to the human society....   [tags: Animal Rights ]

Better Essays
1246 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Animal Experimentation Is Cruel, Unfair And Pointless

- Animal experimentation has been credited for the medicines made to assist diabetes, vaccines for smallpox, deep brain stimulation for parkinson’s disease, and many more along with millions of dollars spent on failed experiments, millions of animal deaths a year, misleading data and an overall bigger loss than gain. The main point of animal testing is to benefit the safety and overall health of humans, but testing on non humans to learn about humans doesn’t contribute to the cause. Humans have the voice protective of their own lives and demand rights, though every living creature deserves the right to life and to safety....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Better Essays
1060 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Morality Of Animal Experimentation

- The morality of animal experimentation has always been up for questioning. People would like to think animals are not on the same levels as them. After all, people are the alpha on the food chain simply because animals don’t have the capabilities or intelligence as humans do. However, putting them on the level with non level things is a bit unfair. Animal experimentation can be dated back many of centuries. An old scientist once performed live lectures on pregnant dogs. The scientist would harm the pup right in front of her....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights, Experiment, Science]

Better Essays
1330 words (3.8 pages)