Is a Murder Worth a Murder

698 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Capital punishment and ethics

In the short story “A Hanging” by George Orwell, an execution is about to occur in Burma. A man who is has committed an unnamed crime is about to receive the ultimate punishment of death. The story describes in great detail his short walk to the gallows where he will face his death. Everyone in the prison camp knows what is to come and all have a somber feeling in their hearts. The jail superintendent wants the death to proceed quickly so that the day can go on as normal. As a young magistrate watches the painful walk, he notices the prisoner walks around a puddle. At that point he realizes the prisoner is still human. “This man is not dying, he is just as alive as we are alive,” he says. After the execution, the men all share a drink in laughter with the body hanging only a few yards away.

In this story the men were brought together by the death of a prisoner. They are used to the fact someone dies everyday by there hand and they go on with their lives. There is a moment where they do share some sympathy with the prisoner but that doesn’t keep them from doing their job. The murders...

Show More
Related

  • Capital Punishment Sherman Alexie

    1361 Words  | 3 Pages

    At this point, the speaker's newfound empathy toward the killer prompts his diatribe about American support of capital punishment. He begins with a hypothetical portrayal of an audience chaotically discussing the meaning of the word "kill," each person exclaiming "how they spell it" and "what it means to them." Subsequently, he recounts a story about insensitive reporters at a hanging, followed by a claim that "we throw killers in one grave / and victims in another. We form sides / and have two separate feasts." While the speaker may seem to be utilizing the description of the audience and the story of the reporters in order to denounce the mindset of his peers, he is in fact condemning his own former mentality. By denying five times that he is a witness, the speaker avoids the guilt that results from involvement in the death of another man. Through his repeated use of the phrase "I am not a witness," he essentially enables and catalyzes the execution of the killer, dismissing his humanity and conforming to the opinion that he deserves to be killed; however, once the speaker recognizes his fault and his conformity to this mindset, the tone of the poem suddenly shifts. The speaker's empathy for the killer reaches its maximum when he fully understands the pain of the condemned and finally sees the killer as his equal, which prompts his own admission of guilt and prior indifference: "I am a

    Read More

  • The Hangman versus The Terrible Things

    645 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the poem "The Hangman," by Maurice Ogden, the poet explained that a person could resolve a situation by showing acts of courage. One day, a hangman came to a town and built a scaffold on the courthouse square. The townspeople asked him which criminal would be hanged and he replied with a mischievous grin and a glint in his eye that it would be the person who will continually make his job easier. When the hangman spotted a foreign person, he chose him to be the first victim. The townsfolk were relieved that they weren't picked to be hanged, and that the gallows frame would be gone the next day. However, after they saw that it was still there, the hangman said that the foreigner was used to determine how strong the hemp was. When a man cri...

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Murder At The Margin

    860 Words  | 2 Pages

    Murder at the Margin is a murder mystery involving various economic concepts. The story takes place in Cinnamon Bay Plantation on the Virgin Island of St. John. It is about Professor Henry Spearman, an economist from Harvard. Spearman organizes an investigation of his own using economic laws to solve the case.

    Read More

  • Comparing Two Hangings Analysis

    1155 Words  | 3 Pages

    “He was about to signal his aides to pull the chair from under the young man's feet when the latter shouted, in a strong and calm voice: ‘Long live liberty! My curse on Germany! My curse! My—’” The two hangings are similar because during both executions a verdict is read, the Jews are forced to watch, and the Jews are forced to take their caps off and quickly put them back on. They differ in who is being hanged, the Jews overall mood after the hangings, and the Nazi’s overall mood as the the execution proceeds. The hangings differ in who is being hanged because it is a tall and strong young man during the first and a small pipel during the second. The soup tastes better than ever to the prisoners after the first hanging and there is a general mood of hope. After the second, all hope is lost and the soup tastes

    Read More

  • Capital Punishment in the Work of George Orwell, H.L. Mencken, and Norman Mailer

    716 Words  | 2 Pages

    The pleasure of relieving stress in George Orwell's essay "A Hanging" was detailed by his thoughts written as one of the executioners. This character drank alcohol to relieve the painful memories of escorting the prisoner to the gallows. The character would have rather saved the man from hanging when the author wrote "It is curious, but till that moment I had never realized what it means to destroy a healthy, conscious man" (pg 89). Orwell describes in detail how the condemned man "was not dying, he was alive just as we are alive all the organs of his body were working, bowels digesting food, skin renewing itself, nails growing, tissues forming, all toiling away in solemn foolery." (pg 89). The author continues to illustrate the character's mental anguish when he says "he and we were a party of men walking together, seeing, hearing, feeling, understanding the same world, and in two minutes with a sudden snap, one o...

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Death Row Syndrome

    1206 Words  | 3 Pages

    In 1986, Warren Hill was sentenced to death for killing his girlfriend, and then was sentenced to death for a deadly prison beating of a fellow inmate in 1990. What is special about Hill’s case is that he has seen the death chamber four separate times. Although it is not uncommon for an inmate to have numerous execution dates, all of Warren’s reprieves were last minute, during his last hour of being alive. One in which he was already strapped to the gurney and heavily sedated. Brian Evans, head of Amnesty International USA’s Death Penalty Abolition Campaign, states that mock executions are a form of torture under international law. Just imagine being strapped to a gurney, knowing that your life has come to an end. You think of all the good and bad things that have happened in your lifetime, in which you have finally accepted death, only to have that stripped away from

    Read More

  • A Good Man is Hard to Find by Flannery O'Connor

    1957 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the short story, “A Good Man Is Hard to Find” a family comprising of a grandmother, a father, three children, and a wife is headed on vacation has the misfortune of meeting a murderous band of serial killers. The Misfit and his band of serial killers are recently escapees of a federal prison. In the following paragraphs this paper looks into the issues of, what one would do in a situation such as that and the background of the the family and murderers as well.

    Read More

  • What Effects the Death Penalty Causes to Society?

    567 Words  | 2 Pages

    The effects Death Punishment causes to society is not one side answer as humans feelings are important, people have the right to have them, to express them; however, when the life of an individual is the topi...

    Read More

  • An Analysis of the Final Words of Texas Death Row Inmates

    1343 Words  | 3 Pages

    While the debate rages on about the appropriateness of capital punishment, since 1982, hundreds of Texas inmates have been executed using various methods such as hanging, lethal injections, and the electric chair. Factors such as racial and sexual profiling, increased public opinion and pressure, reliance on public polls (Ellsworth and Vidmar 1269) have seemingly affected the decision making process, which in turn has raised ethical and social concerns about the genuineness, and an unbiased implementation of the irreversible capital punishment. According to the Death Penalty Information Center, Texas and Virginia alone account for 586 of 1277 executions since 1976, with Texas accounting for over 37% of the total executions in the United States of America. The high execution rate in Texas provides an opportunity to perform a case study on the death row inmates in Texas. Irrespective of the execution method and the state in which it is performed, just before their executions, the inmates are given the chance to make their final statements. It would be intriguing to understand what goes through the mind of an individual facing death, and what they consider as the most important thought to share in their dying moments. Some may express love and gratitude toward their friends and families or remorse about their crimes. Others may be incensed with a feeling of injustice and plead innocence in an angry yet helpless manner. Some may turn pious, claiming to be at peace and going to a better place, while some exhibit apathy or shades of humor. All these notions converge toward analyzing the emotions emanating from the inmates’ statements. A research study to evaluate the theme of emotions that they exhibit would lead to empirical answers. ...

    Read More

  • Difference And Diversity For A Good Death

    754 Words  | 2 Pages

    For instance, dying in prison, The Open University, (2009) Brings with it social inequalities with limited or no access to palliative care, although basic medical needs are met. No family surrounding them. For many, the option to leave the prison will be declined for safety reasons, but for the few that can leave to die often refuse to do so. The feeling of safety and familiarity that their prison cell brings them opposed to the outside world which views them negatively. Therefore, this indicates the power over prisoners resulting in a social disadvantage and inequality, removing away their rights in death.

    Read More

  • Analysis of George Orwell’s Essay, A Hanging

    671 Words  | 2 Pages

    “I had never realised what it means to destroy a healthy, conscious man.” After reading and understanding George Orwell’s feelings through his experiences in his essay “A Hanging.” We come to realize that George Orwell, a visitor from the European establishment, gets the opportunity to participate in the execution of a Hindu man. The author is degraded by what he has witnessed and experienced, and decides to share his feelings with the rest of the establishment through his writings.

    Read More

  • David B. Muhlhausen's Article: How The Death Penalty Saves Lives

    869 Words  | 2 Pages

    “How the Death Penalty Saves Lives” According to DPIC (Death penalty information center), there are one thousand –four hundred thirty- eight executions in the United States since 1976. Currently, there are Two thousand –nine hundred –five inmates on death row, and the average length of time on death row is about fifteen years in the United States. The Capital punishment, which appears on the surface to the fitting conclusion to the life of a murder, in fact, a complicated issue that produces no clear resolution.; However, the article states it’s justice. In the article “How the Death Penalty Saves Lives” an author David B. Muhlhausen illustrates a story of Earl Ringo , Jr, brutal murder’s execution on September ,10,

    Read More

  • Use of the Gas Chamber in Capital Punishment

    526 Words  | 2 Pages

    Execution as a form of criminal punishment has been used throughout various parts of the world since the Middle Ages. In fact, back in that time, even petty offenses such as committing adultery or stealing from a food vendor were considered criminal enough to be worthy of death. During the 18th century, death by execution became subject to public display, and was even thought by some to be a form of entertainment. This “entertainment” took shape via methods such as burning at the stake, breaking on the wheel, and slow strangulation. However, due to a growing humanitarian movement in the late 1800’s, these torturous methods became extinct. Rather, more “humane” forms of execution were implemented, such as by guillotine, hanging, or the headman’s axe. The pain inflicted by these was far less than the first three methods, as death was nearly instantaneous.

    Read More

  • Mother's Day: An Unearned Good-Bye

    1164 Words  | 3 Pages

    difficult relationships present that day in the prison, and emphasizing with detail on a few inmates

    Read More

  • Speech: Against Capital Punishment

    1171 Words  | 3 Pages

    A small, scrawny man comes to collect you. Your whole life rushes past you as you take your few, final footsteps to the execution. chamber. The sand is This is the thought 7,000 people have experienced in the last 18 months. Then there are the days.

    Read More

More about Is a Murder Worth a Murder

Open Document