The Invention Of Tradition Through Scripture Essay

The Invention Of Tradition Through Scripture Essay

Length: 1149 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

IV. Mani and the invention of tradition through scripture
A. The re-interpretation of tradition by British officials resided in the articulation of scripture (Pg. 89). Thus, the re-invention of culture and tradition became the defining feature of the debate on sati, as opposed to women’s rights. Through this women became the symbol for tradition, but were still denied their own agency throughout the debate.
1. Women become emblematic of tradition, thus the reworking of tradition was largely conducted though debating the rights and status of women in society (Pg. 90)
2. Scriptural interpretation
a) Throughout the discourse on sati scripture overrode custom and held greater weight (Pg. 88)
b) Scripture was used on both sides of the debate, from Indian who supported sati and the British who did not to substantiate their claims (Pg. 88)
c) The re-evaluation of Indian tradition that resided alone was compatible with the modern economy (Pg. 88)
d) Thus, we can infer that the re-creation of Indian tradition was a tool in which to modernize the nation and create a more systematized form of governance.
3. The production of scripture was strategic; it reinforced and worked alongside the idea of a scale of civilizations. It also privileged Brahmanic scriptures, and can be characterized as a mode of understanding Indian society.
a) The basis in which sati was rooted in scripture was produced though the interaction with a few natives (Pg. 90)
b) Warren Hastings made these texts the basis of personal law, although they pertained more to rules of social behavior (Pg. 90-91)
c) Advocates for and against sati grounded their case in a discussion of Brahmanic scriptures (Pg. 110)
d) The use of scripture was strategic (Pg. 110), one side ...


... middle of paper ...


...in which British men could save the degraded Indian woman.
4. Therefore, we can see that in a contemporary perspective, minority women are still without agency, as said agency is ascribed to culture, instead of the woman.

VI. Conclusion
A. In analyzing Metcalf, Mani and Volpp, we can discern that the Indian women were denied all forms of agency and subjectivity in terms of the debate on sati.
B. Instead, sati was debated in terms of difference between Indians and the British, and in terms of tradition through scriptures.
C. Therefore women within the discourse of sati were simply rendered sites upon which the debate could take place, rather than the subject of the debate.
D. The idea of women as victims of their culture and tradition has manifested within a contemporary discourse, in which minority women are still denied agency as it is credited to their culture.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Relationship Of Sacred Scripture And Sacred Tradition Essay

- Background on the relationship of Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition: The theological interrelationship between Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition, was first challenged by the Protestant Reformation and the Reformers’ espousal of the sola scriptura doctrine, which opposed the “accumulated customs, practices and speculative prepositions” or “human traditions” that had proliferated in late medieval Catholicism of the 16th century, where they alleged that such traditions distorted the evangelical message of the Bible, and that the Bible alone provides all authoritative teaching for Christian life....   [tags: Christianity, Bible, Second Vatican Council]

Better Essays
1615 words (4.6 pages)

Automobiles: The Greatest Invention Essay

- To many people, when they hear the word “invention” they think of clever gadgets and devices that are now common. Such as the safety pin, zippers, computers, telephones, and cars- all of which have amazing stories behind them. However the word “invention” actually goes back to the Latin word invenire for “to come upon.” Basically an invention can be any tangible device or a process, which is brought out by the human imagination. Now a lot of these inventions have helped shaped America....   [tags: Invention of the Car]

Better Essays
971 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on The Theological Mandate—Voices of Scripture

- The Theological Mandate—Voices of Scripture Organic intellectuals are “working academics who are intentionally connected to movements of social transformation and revolution, who permit their actual engagement in such movements to influence, shape, and provide categories for their academic research” (Antonio Gramsci). A peculiar question arises as one takes a theological leap into the nighttime of the ten virgins. Consider the following unorthodox and non-traditional exegetical move that was suggested by one of Franklin Chapel’s young preachers (who happened to have been out prayer-walking in his community early one morning): When I think about the fact that they were all virgins,...   [tags: Scripture Analysis ]

Better Essays
1326 words (3.8 pages)

The Position of Women in Religious Scripture Essay

- The position that women have in religious scripture has given them a lesser spot in society. When God created a man it made sense to create his partner, the female. Because the man is created first and then the women from his rib, the female gender in religious scripture has been discriminated on. This is shown in the various books of the Old and New Testaments, teachings of Jesus Christ, and the Qur’an. First, the Old Testament illustrates women as the corrupter of men. Next, the teachings of Jesus show more equality among genders even though the New Testament does not....   [tags: Women, feminism, Religion, Scriptures, ]

Better Essays
1664 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about Introduction to Classical Indian Literary Tradition

- This human life is believed to have evolved with difficulty after millions of birth. While on the other hand, the theory of “Karma” states that this birth and deaths are the results of one’s own action, and this human form is a unique opportunity to come out of this continuous circle of birth and death. With this life we are gifted with the power of “free will”. It suggests that unlike other animals we being the supreme organisms on the planet not only have the power to control nature, but also possess the capacity to use the free will....   [tags: indian tradition, free will, sanskrit]

Better Essays
1007 words (2.9 pages)

The Importance of Scripture Essay

- The calling of Abraham is where Abrahamic religion began and it is where the three major faiths; Judaism and Christianity in particular, were born. The story began with a man named Abram, later came to be known as Abraham, who was called upon by God, “Now the Lord had said unto Abram, Get thee out of thy country, and from thy kindred, and from thy father's house, unto a land that I will show thee: And I will make of thee a great nation, and I will bless thee and make thy name great; and thou shalt be a blessing: And I will bless them that bless thee, and curse him that curseth thee: and in thee shall all the families of the earth be blessed” (Genesis 12:1-3; cf Acts 7:2, 3: Hebrews 11:8)....   [tags: judaism, christianity, religion]

Better Essays
1843 words (5.3 pages)

A Thousand Splendid Suns : Tradition And Progressive Change Essay

- Tradition and Progressive Change in the Novel A Thousand Splendid Suns With the introduction and/or evolution of modernism characterized by the invention of new technologies, a different way of doing things, freedom among other things, traditional values and cultures that exist in a community are eventually threatened. As a result, the reactionaries attempt to find a way of maintaining tradition while the revolutionaries try to embrace the change. With reference to the novel A Thousand Splendid Suns, the author has not only successively and effectively discussed the culture of the Afghanistans, but has also brought out the rivalry between traditional and modern cultures....   [tags: Culture, Humanities, The Culture, Tradition]

Better Essays
1171 words (3.3 pages)

The Invention And Industrial Applications Essay

- From Iphone 6s to the airplane, patent is common in the daily lives of people. What are patents. In modern society, short-term patent usually be awarded to the sovereign state of the application of the exclusive rights field. As the inventor of the new invention, he or she will be able to apply for the invention of their time in exchange for the public and the details of the patent for a limited period. This is all about new, useful and non-obvious method, machine, article of manufacture, or there is a solution to a particular technical problem, if nobody said that some people had invented....   [tags: Patent, Invention, Patentability]

Better Essays
1517 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about Charles Chestnutt’s The Marrow of Tradition

- Charles Chestnutt’s The Marrow of Tradition Based on historical events, Charles Chestnutt’s The Marrow of Tradition, gives human details to produce a vivid picture of life in the south after the failure of reconstruction. His work has many underlying themes among which are the use of the press to stir already volatile emotions through propaganda, class structure not only along color lines but within races, and the effects of the white supremacists’ agenda on the integrity of those who claimed to be morally advanced....   [tags: Marrow Tradition Chestnutt Essays]

Better Essays
1182 words (3.4 pages)

Sacred Scripture Essay

- The term 'Scripture' refers to the sacred writing of the Old and New Testament. Sacred Scripture are the books which 'contain the truth of God?s revelation and were composed by human authors inspired by the Holy Spirit' (CCC 105). Sacred Scripture is one of the several names denoting the inspired writings which make up the Old and New Testament. The words of the Sacred Scriptures, 'for their part proclaim the works and bring light to the mystery they contain'. The term 'Tradition' refers to the living transmission of the Gospel in the Church....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
571 words (1.6 pages)