The India Tobacco Company fired back by withdrawing all advertisements and support from sponsored events stating, “The legislation has not thought this thing through.” The India Tobacco Company released a statement, “ITC believes that this action on its part will create the right climate for a constructive dialogue that will help develop appropriate content, rules & regulations to make the intended legislation equitable and implementable". (Ban, n.d.)
The battle lines were drawn. The Government viewed this action as a way of responsibly looking out for the welfare of it 's people. From their perspective, tobacco is a dangerous threat for consumers as it 's maker 's intended. Therefore, the Government was responsible for assuming the role of a “scolding parent” and monitoring the welfare of it 's people. In contrast this industry had contributed largely to the government and the economy. India is the third largest distributor of tobacco products, and employs over 26 million workers. The opposition claimed the government was overstepping by interfering on a person 's right to chose. (Ban, n.d.)
International precedents had paved the way for the G...
... middle of paper ...
...e of this, again, it is my body, and it is my choice. When government steps in and tells me what I can and cannot do to my body, despite the risks involved, I feel as though my personal freedom of choice is being violated. Is there wiggle room for compromise? I believe in a person 's right to choose. I believe in freedom, but I also believe it is the responsibility of the government to educate and protect it 's citizens.
If the decision were up to me, I would agree with placing restrictions on types of media and content to be marketed. However, I would also promote educational ad campaigns warning of the dangers of smoking. There is currently a strong campaign to quit smoking here in the United States that I believe is proving to be effective. As a member of society we should have the freedom to choose, but also the information to make an informed decision.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Ban on Tobacco Advertising in India Tobacco consumption has become a widely known health risk over the past few decades. Many Governments and organizations have started to take action is reducing the consumption of tobacco products, and as result the divide between the tobacco industry and anti-tobacco movements has created much controversy. One example of this worldwide ethical struggle in regards to the tobacco industry is the ban on advertising of tobacco products in India. In 2001 The Indian government introduced a bill to ban the tobacco industry from advertising its products as well as prohibiting them from sponsoring sporting and cultural events.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Passive smoking]
1040 words (3 pages)
- Tobacco Advertising in India To Ban or Not to Ban. Government is defined as “the group of people who control and make decisions for a country, state, etc.,” (Merriam-Webster, n.d.). The extent to which the government of a country should be involved in and control its citizen’s lives has been a controversial topic for many years. This is the main argument seen in the issue over banning the advertisement of tobacco products in various countries. The Government of India (GOI) considered the ban on tobacco advertising in 2001 (Ban on Tobacco Ads by the Government of India, 2001).... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Cigarette]
968 words (2.8 pages)
- Summarize the arguments in favor of the ban on tobacco advertising in India Part of the ban on tobacco was based on the "need to protect public health". Cigarettes are not in the best interest of the public, on the contrary they provoke high risk in serious or lethal illness. Also, there was a difference of 0.07% between the contribution (to the G.D.P) of cigarettes and the costs related to health care. The objective of the banning tobacco advertisements was to invert these results so that the health care costs would be reduced in the G.D.P as cigarette sales would decrease at the same time.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Nicotine]
919 words (2.6 pages)
- In 2001, the government of India announced that it would issue a ban on advertising for all Tobacco Companies within the country’s borders. This ban would be in effect for any media source within the country. As a first step of an anti-Tobacco program, the ban’s ultimate goal is to discourage smokers, particularly in teens and young adults, away from the use of tobacco. There are those who support this ban with the contention that it will have little effect on the country’s economy and will ultimately save lives.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco]
1345 words (3.8 pages)
- 1. Summarize the arguments in favor of the ban on tobacco advertising in India. The argument was that if advertising was banned for tobacco products it could effectively cut down on the amount of people who would smoke. It would also cut down on the youth who were beginning to smoke since they would not see the advertising. The cost of health care was more significant than the cost of what the tobacco companies would give to the government in revenue each year. Examples of how the consumption of tobacco went down in a few other countries after advertising was used to support this outlook.... [tags: Tobacco, Nicotine, Tobacco advertising]
925 words (2.6 pages)
- 1. To discourage the young and old people from smoking and consuming tobacco products the government of India imposed a ban on all advertisements of tobacco products. One of the main reasons why cigarette advertising was banned in India was was due to the hazardous health issues arising from smoking tobacco. Tobacco was considered the most dangerous product consumed by humans. The website, http://www.icmrindia.org/free%20resources/casestudies/ban-tobacco-ads11.htm, states that, “According to world health organization tobacco accounted for over 3 million deaths in 1990, the figure rising to 4,023 million deaths in 1998, it was estimated that tobacco related deaths would rise to 8.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Cigarette]
726 words (2.1 pages)
- Ban on Tobacco Advertisements in India In favor of tobacco advertising ban: Being responsible for the welfare of its citizens, the Government of India (GOI) sought better to ban tobacco companies from advertising their products. It’s beneficial to ban such advertising because of teen smoking prevention. By promoting tobacco less or not at all, the adolescents were presumed to use the products less until they they no longer used them in the long run. Tobacco advertisements were instigating tobacco use in the teen population.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Nicotine]
722 words (2.1 pages)
- Government is defined as “the group of people who control and make decisions for a country, state, etc.,” (Merriam-Webster, n.d.). The extent to which the government of a country should be involved in and control its citizen’s lives has been a controversial topic for many years. This is the main argument seen in the issue over banning the advertisement of tobacco products in various countries. The Government of India (GOI) considered the ban on tobacco advertising in 2001 (Ban on Tobacco Ads by the Government of India, 2001).... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Tobacco industry]
958 words (2.7 pages)
- Tobacco Advertising ban in India Government involvement in personal decisions in life has frequently been a hot button topic. What role does the government have in personal decisions and at what point have they crossed the line of personal liberties. Here we will analyze a case study in India over the implications of government involvement in the advertising of tobacco. In February 2001, India announced a bill that would ban Tobacco companies from advertising and sponsoring sporting events. This decision was immediately met with dissension.... [tags: Cigarette, Tobacco, Tobacco advertising, Nicotine]
1168 words (3.3 pages)
- Case Study Analysis – Ban on Tobacco Advertising by the Government of India The connections held amongst the Government, the Tobacco Industry and the health of citizens has been a controversial and complicated topic for decades. This case analysis will focus on the ban on tobacco advertising in India. First, the ideas and arguments will be discussed for both the supporters and those who opposed the ban. The next topics will include the conflict of interest in regards to the government of India and my opinion on what governments should be doing in regards to tobacco advertising.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Government]
1015 words (2.9 pages)