Essay on India 's Criticism Of The Government Of Nepal

Essay on India 's Criticism Of The Government Of Nepal

Length: 1159 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I wish to address Mohana Ansari 's and India 's criticism of the government of Nepal, the government 's response to such criticisms, the attitude of some international non-governmental organizations to these two events, and reaction of Nepali intellectual to them.

Ms. Ansari, a member of the National Human Rights Commission, criticised the government of Nepal in the 31st session of the United Human Rights Council. Prime Minister K. P. Oli expressed his dissatisfaction with the Ms. Ansari and the NHRC about the statement. Subsequently, the NHRC sought international support to preserve its turf, and the Human Rights Watch issued a statement to this effect.

India expressed its dissatisfaction with the new constitution of Nepal by urging the United Kingdom and the European Union by calling on Nepal to make amends. The government rebutted the call as unnecessary interference in Nepal 's internal affairs of Nepal. The Crisis Group called on the international community not to help Nepal organize local elections until the government resolves the opposition of some quarters to the new constitution.

Unfortunately, many Nepali intellectuals criticized the government in both situations without showing an iota of objectivity.

Democracy is not perfect. Actually, it is designed to be imperfect with many checks and balances built into the system. The NHRC, NGOs, international organizations have been created to ensure that no government becomes so overarching that it begins to seek perfection through dictatorship.

Democracy works best when all actors know how to remain within their limits and learn how to remind those who stray away from their limits. Unfortunately, Nepal is one of those few countries where its principal actors have never ac...


... middle of paper ...


...nge in legislation to amendment in the constitution. Neither the government nor the NHRC should be above the constitution and due process.

However, no publicly funded organization, no matter how independent of government, should wash the dirty linen in public without reflecting both sides -- in this case, in international forums. Mohana Ansari seems to have crossed the line.

Neither the government nor the NHRC should be allowed to operate above the law. They must remain within their mandates and limits.

Intellectuals ought to be objective. They should criticise their own government, their own consitutional bodies, or foreign government and agencies objectively when they are in fault and offer practical solutions. Otherwise, we will be a bunch of vociferous parasites helping one side or another to to hollow out the country that has been happening for some time now.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Nepal Essay

- Nepal Despite nine development plans spanning five decades, Nepal remains one of the world’s poorest countries. Nepal’s underdevelopment is a result of the historical effects of unequal distribution of assets and social and economic status among different groups, and effects of recent development efforts that have generated further iniquitous income and assets distribution. Understanding Nepal’s underdevelopment has become particularly pressing in light of the Maoist insurgency that began in 1996....   [tags: Nepal Economy Culture Essays]

Better Essays
1824 words (5.2 pages)

The Nepal Monarchy Of Nepal Essay

- The Nepal monarchy was founded in 1768. Throughout history, rule of the country passed through generations of the royal family because political parties were banned. South Asia (2015) explains in 1990, the first People’s Movement began to steer the monarchy toward a more democratic government. In 1991, the first elections were held and by 1996 the Maoist party declared war on the elected government and existing monarchy. The Democratic Party launched another People’s Movement in 2006, which led to King Gyanendra surrendering his power to Parliament....   [tags: AIDS, Immune system, Nepal, South Asia]

Better Essays
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Nepal Is Extremely Sloping And Uneven Essay

- Nepal is extremely sloping and uneven. Generally rectangular fit as a fiddle, around 650 kilometer long and around 200 kilometer wide, Nepal is the third greatest nation in South Asia, with a range of 147,181 square kilometer of land. Nepal is a land-bolted nation, encompassed by India on three sides and by China 's Xizang Autonomous Region (Tibet) toward the north. It is isolated from Bangladesh by a roughly fifteen kilometer - wide piece of India 's condition of West Bengal, and from Bhutan by the eighty-eight vast Indian condition of Sikkim....   [tags: Nepal, India, Himalayas, Sivalik Hills]

Better Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

A Brief Note On The Country Of Nepal Essay

- The country of Nepal is located in Asia, right below China and over India. The size of the country is 56,827 miles squared. As of 2016, the population of Nepal is 28,978,100. The capital city of Nepal is Kathmandu. It is the largest city in the country and the most populated as it holds one twelfth of the country’s population. Kathmandu has a rich history which has lasted more than two thousand years. Kathmandu has a lot of art that can be seen anywhere from parks to street corners. The art is normally of gods and goddesses....   [tags: Nepal, Kathmandu, Buddhism, Gyanendra of Nepal]

Better Essays
1729 words (4.9 pages)

India And Nepal Relation : Recent Inter Relation Crisis And Problem Solving Workshop

- India and Nepal relation – Recent Inter-Relation Crisis and Problem Solving Workshop Introduction: Nepal is one of the landlocked country, which has three side border with India, and one side with China. India has deep security concern in regard of china throughout the history, and it put higher importance in Nepalese politics, as well as foreign policy. As an underdeveloped country, Nepal has been facing different challenges, such as economic, political, and social. Because of political instability, Nepalese foreign policy has been failed to establish a strong relationship with neighboring countries, especially with India....   [tags: India, Political party, Diplomacy, Constitution]

Better Essays
1811 words (5.2 pages)

The Blackbuck, India, Nepal And India Essay

- The blackbuck is found in Pakistan, Nepal and India. They like to live in open woodlands and grasslands. The blackbuck is an antelope that is medium size. The females have light brown body and their face and belly are white. The males will have a dark brown to black back, sides and legs by the time they are 3 years old. The blackbuck is 47 inches long and is 29 to 33 inches tall at the shoulder. The adult blackbuck male will weigh 75 to 99 pounds, and the female weighs 68 to 86 pounds. They will also get horns that are spiral shaped and are 70cm long....   [tags: Human, Male, Female, Reproduction]

Better Essays
943 words (2.7 pages)

Government And International Human Rights Essay

- The media were abuzz with rumors only recently that the government of KP Oli in Nepal was on the brink of a terrible collapse. Although the dark clouds of the crisis for the government seem to have passed for now, the frightening sword of Damocles is still hanging over its head. The next crisis could be even more vicious than the recent one. The hastily drawn 9-point agreement between the UML-led government and the Maoists to save the fragile coalition is unsustainable. First, it is impossible to implement in the agreed timeframe....   [tags: Nepal, India, Girija Prasad Koirala, Delhi]

Better Essays
717 words (2 pages)

Essay on Geography and Climate of Nepal

- Nepal is located in the Tropic of Cancer (Northern Hemisphere) (Shrestha) and lies between China in the north and India in the south, east and west.(1990 map) It has an area of 147,181 sq. km including water which has an area of 3,830 sq. km and its geographical coordinates are 28°00′N 84°00′E. (Australia 2014) Nepal is typically characterised by a rugged topography due to the amount of hills and mountains within its area. Nepal also lies in the tectonically active zone, making it prone to earthquakes....   [tags: nepal, himalayas, terai region]

Better Essays
1015 words (2.9 pages)

The Study and Findings of Climatology in Nepal Essay

- The Study and Findings of Climatology in Nepal In many areas in Nepal, the history of climatology only dates back to 1956. Around this time, the Indian Meteorological Department instituted stations in various areas around the country, which were eventually taken over by the Nepalese government in 1966. Having these stations in place has given scientists significant insight into the Nepalese climate. However, some of the Indian equipment remained in the Nepalese stations, and unfortunately many Indian findings vary significantly from the Nepalese records of the same areas....   [tags: Climae Environment Nepal Essays Papers]

Better Essays
1051 words (3 pages)

Electricity crisis: Alive in Nepal Essay

- Electricity crisis: Alive in Nepal This topic may seem irrelevant to the readers here in United States. Nepal is the second richest country in water resource but we still have problems with hydroelectricity. Everyday electric current goes off for hours and people are compelled to live in the darkness. Unable to form and established new hydroelectricity projects is the main reasons why Nepalese are still deprived to full electric facilities. Establishment of complex structure like hydroelectricity project is not a joke....   [tags: Nepal Hydroelectric Power Infrastructure Analysis]

Free Essays
1006 words (2.9 pages)