Essay on The Importance Of Robbing For A Good Reason

Essay on The Importance Of Robbing For A Good Reason

Length: 914 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A person lives in a third world country where the minimum wage is not enough to provide for his whole family. He decides that stealing money from people on the street is easier than working extra hours. The action of robbing for a good reason is morally bad when analyzed in a Kantian way. It simply cannot be a universal practice, without negative results. on the other hand, if one analyses the issue in a Utilitarian way, the results become a lot more complicated because a great degree of speculation is needed to reach a conclusion, and even then, the conclusion is not definite.
In order to analyze whether this person’s actions are morally correct in a Kantian way, the person reasons whether stealing money from others, in order to bring food to his table, would contradict his duty. The individual wonders if this principle can become universally accepted, and formulates a maxim: the love that I have for my family, and the duties corresponding to me as the head of my family, lead me to steal what belongs to others as I see no other way to provide sufficient goods for my household. If this practice became common knowledge and practiced by everyone, the acknowledgement of others’ property would cease to exist. Moreover, if stealing money from another person, in order to feed your own, became universally practiced, anarchy would break out, and no one would see the point in working for your own goods. Consequently, peace would be lost, for when the respect of others’ rights is disregarded, the peace is disturbed. Therefore, to steal from others in order to feed one’s family opposes one’s moral duty. In other words, in this case the man’s will is not good because he is acting out of inclination, for it is easier to gain money by steali...


... middle of paper ...


... correct even if it is done with the intention to provide food for your family. The use of the Kantian analysis gives one a more generalized or universal view of this unethical issue. It shows the issue as wrong by thinking of the problems that would come if stealing, for good reasons, was practiced and accepted by society. On the other hand, the use of the utilitarian method gets very complicated for one has to depend on unknown future situations in order to make a moral decision. One has to look closely at the effects that each action causes, as opposed to Kant’s generalized evaluation. Seeing that the first ethical analysis is more systematic, one can infer that by following it’s specific test, the results will be more constant than the second method. Thus, in order to prove if stealing is ethically acceptable, the use of the categorical imperative is preferable.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Importance of Worship for God

- ... In order to show sincere worship to God, you have to worship him from your heart. This lady shows that the things that we use for evil, is what we should really use for kingdom building. She uses to use the expensive alabaster box, full of very precious fragrances, to subdue/lure men, but now she’s using it to subdue the presence of God. We as Christians have to use our evil methods for good. Instead of robbing men, we should be robbing the enemy from everything he stole from us. Instead of killing one another through our words, especially in the church, we should be killing these demons by speaking the word of life into each other....   [tags: worshiping the devil through music]

Better Essays
2008 words (5.7 pages)

The Theory Of Human Reason Essay

- To know thyself, an individual must act within the capacities of his own actions in order to discover truths about himself and live with purpose. Greek thinkers believe to know thyself an individual must use live the examined life by using reason and inquiry in order to analyze their own actions. Judeo-Christians, on the other hand, believe that a call to know thyself is only possible through Faith. The Greek use of human reason provides the best understanding to know thyself because it emphasizes the use of an individual’s own capacity to find the mean between characteristics, act out of habit, and come to know the truths of life....   [tags: Plato, Knowledge, Truth, Reason]

Better Essays
1344 words (3.8 pages)

Robbing the Rich to Give to the Poor Essay

- Robbing the Rich to Give to the Poor Poverty has conquered nations around the world, striking the populations down through disease and starvation. Small children with sunken eyes are displayed on national television to remind those sitting in warm, luxiourious houses that living conditions are less than tolerable around the world. Though it is easy to empathize for the poor, it is sometimes harder to reach into our pocketbooks and support them. No one desires people to suffer, but do wealthy nations have a moral obligation to aid poor nations who are unable to help themselves....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)

The Good Life: Reason and Religion Essay

- A good life can be defined with continuous happiness, various accomplishments, and everlasting prosperity. The eternal desire for a good life has influenced philosophers and their reasoning throughout the years. Many have followed ancient religions; while others followed the modern belief of listening to your heart and therefore one’s self. Pascal, Luther, and Augustine are some of the philosophers who followed religion, and believed it to be the ultimate way of achieving a good life. Other preachers like Rousseau and Nietzsche believed in following one’s heart and conscious in order to achieve the desired goal....   [tags: Philosophy]

Better Essays
2101 words (6 pages)

The Importance Of A Good Listening Skill Essay

- Listening can be defined as the way we received and interpret messages accurately during a communication. In organizations, a good listening skill can lead to an increase in productivity with fewer errors, customer satisfaction as well as an increase in information sharing that can in turn lead to more creative and innovative work. For example: a business woman listening to the type of products her customer is requesting from her. A good example of a website that offers instruction on how we can develop our listening skill is www.skillyouneed.com.( Feminism, 2015)....   [tags: Customer, Good, Management]

Better Essays
758 words (2.2 pages)

The Importance Of A Good School Administrator Essay

- I really enjoyed completing this activity. It is definitely one I know I will refer back to and utilize when I am an administrator. Completing this activity reinforced what a good school administrator needs to do. Many times, too many times, I have noted various school leaders just managing; just maintaining the school day like every other school day, day after day, year after year. They may look the part, but at times they are far from acting like leaders. A school leader should be inspiring and constantly looking ahead to the school’s future....   [tags: Education, Need, Leadership, Teacher]

Better Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

The Importance Of A Good Nutrition? Essay

- ... What is a balanced diet. A balanced diet is the action and effect of feeding, this includes the selection of food,the preparation, and its ingestion; food provides substances that are called nutrients and vitamins, which are needed to be able to support a good health and prevent diseases. All depends on the needs, religion, culture, economic, and social situation of every individual. Besides water, food is important because it is also vital to have a suitable diet which must contain a series of proteins, vitamins and fundamental minerals for the good health and life....   [tags: Nutrition, Health, Obesity, Eating]

Better Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Importance of Good Communication

- Good communication is solution the in any organization. It is also the connection between all levels of personal. Good communication can be improved in practically every workplace and community. The Pleasantville district utilizes their human resources department as they conduct random questionnaires and staff submit department suggestions boxes placed randomly thought the school district in which all are answered in a timely fashion. It is very important to employees because they all need to add their verbiage in order to handle the daily stress....   [tags: Communication]

Better Essays
2379 words (6.8 pages)

Importance of Money in Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil Essay

- Importance of Money in Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil     Inherited money is held in much higher esteem than earned money in Savannah, Georgia. This is a theme seen throughout Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil, John Berendt's non-fictional account of life in Savannah. Characters such as Jim Williams, who worked for their money and brought themselves up the social ladder, are seen as being beneath those who inherited their money, such as Lee Adler. The old wealth tend to look down on anyone who wasn't born with their money....   [tags: Midnight Garden Good Evil]

Better Essays
862 words (2.5 pages)

The Importance of the "Guide of Reason" Essay

- The Importance of the "Guide of Reason" The "guide of reason" is a concept from the Renaissance period that is used to describe the need of the people from this specific time period to have their questions answered about certain issues such as their connection with God and what their place was in the world or even the universe. The "guide of reason" is another way of saying keeping order by creating structures within society that everyone can and will follow. The "guide of reason" was an important concept during the Renaissance period and was a key factor in the lifestyles of people in the early sixteenth to the late seventeenth centuries....   [tags: European History]

Free Essays
803 words (2.3 pages)