Essay about Impact Of Urban Planning On The Film City Of God

Essay about Impact Of Urban Planning On The Film City Of God

Length: 1525 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Impact of Urban Planning on Poverty and Crime in the Film City of God
The film City of God (2003) co-directed by Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund explores the impact of urban planning and urban environment on the social and cultural behaviors of urban residents. The movie portrays urban planning as a factor in the allocation of resources to different urban neighborhoods, and how this allocation promotes the development of two social classes- the poor and the rich. Secondly, the film attributes urban planning to social decadence as the marginalization of poor neighborhoods through government policies that limit resource allocation creates the perfect social environment for crime, moral decadence, and socialization of a whole generation into criminal activities.
City of God is set in the sprawling slums of Rio de Janeiro, in a poor urban neighborhood built in the 1960s to host the city’s poor inhabitants. Lins Paulo, the author of the book of the same title on which the movie is based, describes a grim picture of the slum in its early years. He writes, “the new residents brought garbage, bins, mongrel dogs”… (Paulo 6), depicting the poverty of those who moved into the slum. The favela (the slum) is located far away from central Rio, in what can be interpreted as an attempt to create a as comfortable as possible distance between the rich who frequent and live with the main city, and the poor residents who present a security threat to businesses and Rio’s upper class society. This design of urban planning in which authorities go to great lengths to separate the haves from the haves not indicate a conscious and deliberate effort by governments to protect the rich at the expense of the poor. This may be partly explained by the fact...


... middle of paper ...


...rce allocation to poor neighborhoods. The ending scene drives this point home powerfully when the Runts ask each other if anyone of them can write so they can make the hit list. Without education, how does the government expect such youths to earn a living, and how much can they be justifiably blamed for turning out the way they did? In the City of God, crime is the beast. If you run away, it will catch up with you, if you stay, it will eat you.
In conclusion, City of God is a portrayal of the impact of poor urban planning on the social and behavior culture of marginalized urban dwellers. It demonstrates that poor urban planning promotes the growth of urban slums and the creation of a social environment that encourages lawlessness and decadent behaviors. It links urban planning to the unequal allocation of resources, and its consequences such as poverty and crimes.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Global City Of The Urban City Essay

- The thesis of 'the global city ' is fundamental to understand the global dynamics that have transformed the cities in the last decades. The global city refers to the linkages of cities within the context of a global economic market. There are different key aspects of the urban geography that can indicate this interdependence among global cities as, for example, the expansion of the APS or the growth of TCN in the CBD , the places are considered highly influential in the global cities due to the digital infrastructure (Sassen, 2005, pp.28-40)....   [tags: City, Urban planning, Global city, Saskia Sassen]

Better Essays
1005 words (2.9 pages)

Decline in Comprehensive Urban Planning Essay example

- The decline in comprehensive urban planning was one of the major assets in determining the capitalist view facing social resistance. This made it difficult for planners considering the number of critiques that persistently argued about the impact of planning. This is because cities have changed; there was no way to hold a consistent plan. The conflict between the central controls needed to perform comprehensive urban planning versus the capitalism in which individual property holders say about of how things are done because of their interests in their property....   [tags: Urban Planning]

Better Essays
1494 words (4.3 pages)

The Impact of Contemporary Urban Planning Principles and the Setback Regulations Implemented in Riyadh

- Since the 1950s, the cities of Saudi Arabia witnessed significant changes in the composition of the population and the arrangement of the built environment. The Saudi society has transformed from a nomadic pastoral society to a highly modernized one as a result of the increase in national revenues from oil production. Rapid growth and improved economic conditions led to the adoption of modern planning principles which are in contrary to the traditional city. Although modernization had contributed to raising the living standard of the neighbourhood, it led to the creation of social, cultural and climate problems as well....   [tags: Urban Planning]

Better Essays
2694 words (7.7 pages)

Essay on The Spectrum of Urban Planning

- The Spectrum of Urban Planning Urban Planning is the process of planning the development of land and other resources to improve a community in ways that benefit the lives of people within these communities. Urban Planning is a complex area of study because of the many different factors involved and the people it has an effect on. Planning can be controversial, political, and cause anger towards officials if it is not executed correctly. Urban planners must weigh their decisions and base them on the good of the environment and the people....   [tags: City Planning, Engineering]

Better Essays
1940 words (5.5 pages)

Urban Sprawl : A Growing Economy Essay

- INTRODUCTION Sustainable cities, also referred to as eco-cities, are metropolises that are designed with consideration of environmental impact, inhabited by people dedicated to minimal amount of energy required such as food and water, also the minimum outputs of waste products such as heat, air pollution, carbon dioxide, methane, and water pollution. Throughout the various planning decisions that is used to design cities, it eventually leads to the high tendency of urban sprawl. Urban sprawl describes the how the human population has expanded from central urban areas into communities which are low-density, mono-functional and often heavily car-dependant....   [tags: City, Suburb, Urban decay, Urban planning]

Better Essays
1146 words (3.3 pages)

Urban Sprawl vs the Sustainable City Essay

- Recently there have been many discussions about urban sprawl due to its negative impacts on society and the natural environment. However, looking at the aims of the sustainable city project it seems clear urban sprawl may be an obstacle Doubting this, i asked myself “to what measure is urban sprawl a problem to the aim of the sustainable city”. In this essay I will try to explain the aims of the sustainable city as well the process of urban sprawl and its limitations and relate how urban sprawl directly affects those objectives....   [tags: urban sprawl, natural environment]

Better Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

The Human Population: Eco-City Planning Essay

- As of October 31, 2011, the world population has reached 7 billion people (Collins, 2012). The growth rate of humans continue to be staggering, this generates a demand to change the land use, the allocation of resources, and more importantly the realization of the environmental pressures associated with more development (Ascione, 2009). The exponential growth of human development in the recent years has given rise to awareness to the natural ecosystem (Savard & Clergeau, 2000). This awareness towards the environment has created environmental planning....   [tags: environmental planning, quality of life]

Better Essays
1853 words (5.3 pages)

Essay about Georges Eugene Haussmann and His Impact on City Planning

- ... This continuous influx of people from the country served to exponentially increase the total population that took refuge inside the city walls, swelling the number of citizens to well over 3.3 million by 1900. These increased numbers led to very overcrowded living conditions, an inability to maintain even the slightest control over sanitation conditions, and widespread death from diseases such as cholera and tuberculosis. In these conditions, Emperor Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte found Haussmann through an interview process and quickly had him appointed to levels of high status that practically made him the major of Paris....   [tags: Buildings, Infrastructure]

Better Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Death And Life Of Great American Cities

- At the time Jane Jacobs was writing The Death and Life of Great American Cities, city planning was not a process done by or for the people who lived in them. Residents were rarely consulted or involved in decision making, rather it be left to few elites who dictated their vision of the city for everybody else to conform to. This is clearly illustrated in her conflicts with Robert Moses, an outspoken Yale educated city planner operating in New York, where Jacobs was living at the time. Moses had a clear and unshifting vision for the city and used his persuasive manner and connections to push forward his proposals at alarming rates....   [tags: City, Urban planning]

Better Essays
1096 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Impact Of Globalization On International Security

- A mere 200 years ago, the amount of people that lived in urbanized areas accounted for less than 5% of the world’s population. Today, as many as 50 percent of the world’s population has followed the trend of urbanization, and moved from agriculture to the industrial world. Urbanization can be seen as a global challenge that has advantages and disadvantages to the world and humanity. These aspects can be explored through multiple perspectives: including its effects on international security, the political/ economical aspect, the repercussions to the environment, and even its impact on culture itself....   [tags: Urban area, City, United Nations]

Better Essays
1566 words (4.5 pages)